Character Discussion Top 10 most evil characters in One Piece

[LubeDaddy]

I judge these by what we would think of them if they were real life people.

1.Celestial Dragons/Gorosei/Imu (Goes without saying)
2.Big Mom (Genocide of an island for not delivering candy, Chaotic Neutral, sociopath)
3.Akainu (Participator and facilitator of the genocide of a whole people)
4.Aokiji (Participator in genocide of a whole people, yeah motherfucker I didn't forget)
5.Crocodile/Kaido/Orochi (Enslavement of entire nation/Holding nation hostage by limiting food/water supply)
6.Doflamingo (False flag slaughter of innocent civilians in order to become the ruler of Dressrosa, Major figure in the slave trade, sociopath)
7.Rob Lucci (Massacred innocent soldiers held prisoners, will do whatever evil that WG tells him)
8.Caesar Clown (facilitator of child experiments)
9.Arlong (Just because you were hurt in the past, doesn't give you the right to do the same to other people)
10.Black Beard (Chaotic neutral/sociopath/Will occasionally do evil if it can further his own goal in the pursuit of becoming pirate king but hasn't been shown to kill or hurt any civilians)


I might have forgotten some but these are the 10 that come to mind out of the major characters.

 

[fakename]

I judge these by what we would think of them if they were real life people.

1.Celestial Dragons/Gorosei/Imu (Goes without saying)
2.Big Mom (Genocide of an island for not delivering candy, Chaotic Neutral, sociopath)
3.Akainu (Participator and facilitator of the genocide of a whole people)
4.Aokiji (Participator in genocide of a whole people, yeah motherfucker I didn't forget)
5.Crocodile/Kaido/Orochi (Enslavement of entire nation/Holding nation hostage by limiting food/water supply)
6.Doflamingo (False flag slaughter of innocent civilians in order to become the ruler of Dressrosa, Major figure in the slave trade, sociopath)
7.Rob Lucci (Massacred innocent soldiers held prisoners, will do whatever evil that WG tells him)
8.Caesar Clown (facilitator of child experiments)
9.Arlong (Just because you were hurt in the past, doesn't give you the right to do the same to other people)
10.Black Beard (Chaotic neutral/sociopath/Will occasionally do evil if it can further his own goal in the pursuit of becoming pirate king but hasn't been shown to kill or hurt any civilians)


I might have forgotten some but these are the 10 that come to mind out of the major characters.

Axe Hand Morgan, he's a scrub but from an evil level he was quite bad, even not carring about his son but also letting him psycophaticly abuse everyone for no reason

 

[LubeDaddy]

Axe Hand Morgan, he's a scrub but from an evil level he was quite bad, even not carring about his son but also letting him psycophaticly abuse everyone for no reason

In terms of the total of harm he has inflicted on the world he pales in comparison to the ones listed though

 

[fakename]

In terms of the total of harm he has inflicted on the world he pales in comparison to the ones listed though

I guess but then it gets philospical: if intent doesn't matter, just the consequences, doesn't it get muddy, like some charachters on your list may have conflicted motives and even have some redeeeming qualitys, so it's hard to call them more evil than a literal one dimmensional villian.
For a more extreme example to make my point, Joy Boy apologised to the previous Neptune for messing up. What if this mess up, that he may did in a moment of personal weakness, lead to the 800 years of slavery and subjugation? Is he than the most evil charachter, even if all his other actions tell otherwise?

 

[LubeDaddy]

I guess but then it gets philospical: if intent doesn't matter, just the consequences, doesn't it get muddy, like some charachters on your list may have conflicted motives and even have some redeeeming qualitys, so it's hard to call them more evil than a literal one dimmensional villian.
For a more extreme example to make my point, Joy Boy apologised to the previous Neptune for messing up. What if this mess up, that he may did in a moment of personal weakness, lead to the 800 years of slavery and subjugation? Is he than the most evil charachter, even if all his other actions tell otherwise?

I took all of that into consideration. If you indirectly and unintentionally cause harm I don't put that on the same level.
That's why Aokiji is on this list. There are some acts that are so atrocious that it really doesn't matter what conflicting thoughts you had. Genocide is one of those.

 

[fakename]

I took all of that into consideration. If you indirectly and unintentionally cause harm I don't put that on the same level.
That's why Aokiji is on this list. There are some acts that are so atrocious that it really doesn't matter what conflicting thoughts you had. Genocide is one of those.

Fair enough, but I guess I still consider someone who is pure evil but to weak to fullfil their evil desires fully (like wanting to kill everyone but being a scrub) as pretty evil, if they dont change their ways

 

[LubeDaddy]

Fair enough, but I guess I still consider someone who is pure evil but to weak to fullfil their evil desires fully (like wanting to kill everyone but being a scrub) as pretty evil, if they dont change their ways

Yeah I am not saying those characters are not evil just that there are levels to it

 

[Extravlad]

Akainu and Aokiji aren't more evil than Kaido

 

[LubeDaddy]

Akainu and Aokiji aren't more evil than Kaido

Well when we reach the point of genocide and enslavement of nations it becomes tricky to rank. There are arguments for both. Like who is more evil: kim Jong Un or Pol Pot

 

[Minatoze Narutomaki]

With Sugar by his side Doflamingo is the Worst

 

[Desert Waifu]

I think Doflamingo is the most evil of them. Unlike Sakazuki or Lucci, he doesn't believe that his actions, no matter how extreme, ultimately serve a good cause. And Kaido's cruelty, for example, was the result of his environment or his hard life. He grew up thinking that only the strong should survive. But Corazon said that Doflamingo was already born evil. And he is indeed evil personified. He's evil just to be evil. He has no higher aspirations, just wants to bring death and despair to the world. He killed his own father and brother. He was responsible for slavery and slave trade, killing countless innocent people and overthrowing a good king. And his only reaction to that was laughter.

 

[vikas]

I think Doflamingo is the most evil of them. Unlike Sakazuki or Lucci, he doesn't believe that his actions, no matter how extreme, ultimately serve a good cause. And Kaido's cruelty, for example, was the result of his environment or his hard life. He grew up thinking that only the strong should survive. But Corazon said that Doflamingo was already born evil. And he is indeed evil personified. He's evil just to be evil. He has no higher aspirations, just wants to bring death and despair to the world. He killed his own father and brother. He was responsible for slavery and slave trade, killing countless innocent people and overthrowing a good king. And his only reaction to that was laughter.

True.... Before dressrossa I used to think he might have some agenda like crocodile.... But nothing like that... He just doing business and is evil.... That's it.

 

[LubeDaddy]

I think Doflamingo is the most evil of them. Unlike Sakazuki or Lucci, he doesn't believe that his actions, no matter how extreme, ultimately serve a good cause. And Kaido's cruelty, for example, was the result of his environment or his hard life. He grew up thinking that only the strong should survive. But Corazon said that Doflamingo was already born evil. And he is indeed evil personified. He's evil just to be evil. He has no higher aspirations, just wants to bring death and despair to the world. He killed his own father and brother. He was responsible for slavery and slave trade, killing countless innocent people and overthrowing a good king. And his only reaction to that was laughter.

As I said there are discussions to be had about where these characters should rank. There are definitely good arguments for Doflamingo. The only place that is set here is the World Government and I won't budge on that one

 

[vikas]

Kid is same as BB.

Post automatically merged: Jun 16, 2022

Hody & group are also evil... He maybe lame villain.. But what he did effected the FI for years.. Delaying stuff and all.

 

[LubeDaddy]

Kid is same as BB.

I don't see it. I mean the WG claims that he caused civilian casualties but they will claim a lot of shit about the people they want eradicated. So until we see him do shit like this I will withhold judgement. Other than that we haven't really see him do anything like Blackebard. Kidd seems to genuinely care about his crew mates. Blackbeard would back stab anyone if it would further his plan

 

[fakename]

I don't see it. I mean the WG claims that he caused civilian casualties but they will claim a lot of shit about the people they want eradicated. So until we see him do shit like this I will withhold judgement. Other than that we haven't really see him do anything like Blackebard. Kidd seems to genuinely care about his crew mates. Blackbeard would back stab anyone if it would further his plan

I would find it interessting if BlackBeard would actually develop a real bond with his crew, would be a interessting plotpoint at the final confrontation, maybe a scene where he instinctivly hangs on to them, even if it is giving up on his dream. But I know that won't happen and BlackBeard will stay the manipulative shemer till the end and be just a generic evilguy to defeat.

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

1. Gaimon's crew, leaving him stranded.
2. Wapol, taking away medics, running away from drum
3. Fake SHs, don't like them
4. Member of calgara village who kicked away Noland (fiend level of bad)
5. The mountain bandits

 

[fakename]

1. Gaimon's crew, leaving him stranded.
2. Wapol, taking away medics, running away from drum
3. Fake SHs, don't like them
4. Member of calgara village who kicked away Noland (fiend level of bad)
5. The mountain bandits

I think Wapol is a good example, because even though he had less power than someone like Doflamingo he seemed more evil, because he seemed not to have any conflict in him, any deep backstory or trauma, not even some weird dream, just a evil lazy guy willing to do anything. Atleast Doflamingo had the discipline to get strong while Wapol just relied on his fruit

 

[Peenix]

I judge these by what we would think of them if they were real life people.

1.Celestial Dragons/Gorosei/Imu (Goes without saying)
2.Big Mom (Genocide of an island for not delivering candy, Chaotic Neutral, sociopath)
3.Akainu (Participator and facilitator of the genocide of a whole people)
4.Aokiji (Participator in genocide of a whole people, yeah motherfucker I didn't forget)
5.Crocodile/Kaido/Orochi (Enslavement of entire nation/Holding nation hostage by limiting food/water supply)
6.Doflamingo (False flag slaughter of innocent civilians in order to become the ruler of Dressrosa, Major figure in the slave trade, sociopath)
7.Rob Lucci (Massacred innocent soldiers held prisoners, will do whatever evil that WG tells him)
8.Caesar Clown (facilitator of child experiments)
9.Arlong (Just because you were hurt in the past, doesn't give you the right to do the same to other people)
10.Black Beard (Chaotic neutral/sociopath/Will occasionally do evil if it can further his own goal in the pursuit of becoming pirate king but hasn't been shown to kill or hurt any civilians)


I might have forgotten some but these are the 10 that come to mind out of the major characters.

To be fair to Kuzan, the civillians in Ohara were originally going to be spared. The Marines didn't have orders to kill them
It's just that Sakazuki chose to blow them up because he's a psycho

 

[LubeDaddy]

To be fair to Kuzan, the civillians in Ohara were originally going to be spared. The Marines didn't have orders to kill them
It's just that Sakazuki chose to blow them up because he's a psycho

I would have to go back and read it again. Taking you for your word here. The problem here is that Kuzan could have chosen to try to put a stop to it but he chose to basically say "fuck it" and went along with it. So that's not a good excuse at least in my book. A good person would never put up with shit like that