Well movies are also different story wise, are they not?
Not really, Horikoshi thought the movies inside the overall plot. It seems to be part of the story. The movies happen between arcs in the manga.
(But I agree that some movie feats / plot can be weird like Bakugo / Deku sharing OFA and not talking about it after that).
So let’s say we don’t take movie into account.
All Might (and by extension Endy and other top tiers) are certainly flashy in their offense. But that still doesn't negate the fact that Homelander survives everything Endy throws at him, unless he has something > a nuke.
If the vs was against Shigaraki or some other hax user then I might give it to Shigaraki because I don't know how Homelander would scale against hax abilities. Shigaraki especially seems unavoidable once he touches you.
I’m still doubtful about that nuke thing.
And frankly AM max power shouldn’t be far below or below a Nuke. AM striking strength is great. It’s
But Yeah Shiggy hax would win against Homelander. Shiggy is fast durable and strong enough to go closer and decay him.