Character Discussion Bonney won't join the SH.

[Sir Tuna Sandwich II]

For all the Bonney simps - fucking cry me a river!
Luffy called her "Bogey", Luffy never mess-up his crewmates names which mean she just an extra and will never join the core SH

I'm done.

 

[OGshine]

she'll be the new number 4 while current number 4 becomes number 5!

 

[Kerkovian]

Who in the world even thinks of Bonnry joining?

 

[MonsterKaido]

Vegafunk will

 

[Sir Tuna Sandwich II]

Who in the world even thinks of Bonnry joining?

Some hopeful simps

 

[Seatonnes]

You know whos on the ship and luffy calls by his name
CARIBOU

 

[Woozles]

For all the Bonney simps - fucking cry me a river!
Luffy called her "Bogey", Luffy never mess-up his crewmates names which mean she just an extra and will never join the core SH

I'm done.

I feel like people forget early OP arcs.

Like Luffy straight up, does not call Chopper his name for the entirety of Drum Island despite hearing it multiple times from Kureha, Nami and Sanji

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

She's another Law.

 

[Sir Tuna Sandwich II]

I feel like people forget early OP arcs.

Like Luffy straight up, does not call Chopper his name for the entirety of Drum Island despite hearing it multiple times from Kureha, Nami and Sanji

Goofy never gave Choppar a nickname stop lying

 

[Woozles]

Goofy never gave Choppar a nickname stop lying

He literally only calls him reindeer or reindeer stew throughout Drum Island despite knowing his name.

 

[Date]

Every time a new character Interact with the SHs, the fandom start to say he will be the new crewmate, and that never happen lol

 

[Sir Tuna Sandwich II]

He literally only calls him reindeer or reindeer stew throughout Drum Island despite knowing his name.

It's not a nickname.
If he call Sanjino a cook or Brook a skeleton it's just describing what/who they are.
Bogey? Completely diffrent.
Stop simping on Bogey she not real and even if she was real she wouldn't fuck you :holdthisl:

 

[Woozles]

It's not a nickname.
If he call Sanjino a cook or Brook a skeleton it's just describing what/who they are.
Bogey? Completely diffrent.
Stop simping on Bogey she not real and even if she was real she wouldn't fuck you :holdthisl:

Boss, I don't care if bonney joins or not. Your preposition is that Luffy doesn't fuck up his crew mates names. And just calls them by it. That's clearly not true. He's done it with Chopper by just calling him reindeer or stew and he even used to just Call Franky, Speedo.

It's no different than him calling Iceberg Ice-oji or Whitebeard Oji-san.

Luffy'll just say whatever comes to mind for people he's not close to, even if those people eventually become people he's close to.

 

[Kyou]

No

 

[NAMELESS]

For all the Bonney simps - fucking cry me a river!
Luffy called her "Bogey", Luffy never mess-up his crewmates names which mean she just an extra and will never join the core SH

I'm done.

yes.

 

[BOCCHI]

I would love to have Bonney as a SH, but no she won’t be a crew member.

 

[Peppercore]

i agree but dont use the nickname thing because luffy never messed up carrot name and look where that went

 

[Sir Tuna Sandwich II]

i agree but dont use the nickname thing because luffy never messed up carrot name and look where that went

Carrot who? The one who sneaked into the ship and was never invited? Lol

 

[ShinichiMugi]

Well in post-TS allies like Law or Kinemon get more screentime than SHs so Bonney's fans (like me) think its great she wont join! Haha

 

[Koro]

Yeah she won't