Cool garp was also a friend to rodger. He eve said he liked rodger. And rodger trusted the dude with his kid lol
Frenemy. They built that trust through countless battles and confrontations. They fought together to beat Rocks just like smoker and luffy have fought together. Roger trusted the kid to him cause he knew that even though Garp was his enemy and a marine, Garp didn't belive a child was responsible for his fathers crimes. And also maybe Buggy and shanks when they were kids might have been found by Roger and Garp in god valley. Friendship has almost nothing to do with it.
 
No. You have to realize when to let go. Coby ain't it man. He is designed to perpetually be luffys friend in the marines. That was not what Roger and Garp had. He has never once actually tried to capture luffy. Smoker has multiple times. Smoker is the new Garp if there is such a thing.
Mute point.

1. Garp was never shown trying to capture rodger when he was in his teens

2. Coby is doing what garp did to fight chinjao leveling up before facing luffy.
 
Frenemy. They built that trust through countless battles and confrontations. They fought together to beat Rocks just like smoker and luffy have fought together. Roger trusted the kid to him cause he knew that even though Garp was his enemy and a marine, Garp didn't belive a child was responsible for his fathers crimes. And also maybe Buggy and shanks when they were kids might have been found by Roger and Garp in god valley. Friendship has almost nothing to do with it.
Cool

Garp says he liked rodger. Check

Worked with him in God valley. If coby and luffy do the same with bb it will be check

Both are the same age or close. Check.

Both refer to each other by name. Check

Smoker is the furthest from being luffys garp since luffy doesn't even call smoker by name. He doesn't respect him enough. While he called coby BY name. Every single time.

Again luffys garp is not someone almost 20 years older than him. That makes no sense
 
Mute point.

1. Garp was never shown trying to capture rodger when he was in his teens
We don't know that lol. Also, Luffy will reach Roger's level in his teens. So of course smoker would chase him in his teens. Garp chased Roger before he became Pirate king too lol.
2. Coby is doing what garp did to fight chinjao leveling up before facing luffy.
Coby is most likely imprisoned by BB...
 
Cool

Garp says he liked rodger. Check

Worked with him in God valley. If coby and luffy do the same with bb it will be check

Both are the same age or close. Check.

Both refer to each other by name. Check

Smoker is the furthest from being luffys garp since luffy doesn't even call smoker by name. He doesn't respect him enough. While he called coby BY name. Every single time.

Again luffys garp is not someone almost 20 years older than him. That makes no sense
Garp Respected Roger. Not liked. Just as Smoker respects him.

That can be Smoker too. He's really close to Egghead after all.

Age doesn't matter at all. Portrayal does.

Doesn't matter. Roger didn't have a nick name as far as we know.

Coby is Luffy's friend dude. Always has been. Always will be. At best, they will have a friendly fight in the epilogue, when coby is an admiral just as they promised.
 
Top