General & Others People are confused about the Fourth Ponegylph

[kumae]

Big mom took it after invanding fishmen island she didn't take it to wci but she hided it somewhere else..

 

[NAMELESS]

Well,things are being set up to take place in Elbaf.So the last one is probably there.

 

[PortgasDMor]

How will he find out about it if nobody told him? He literally freed wano of Kaido, I think Marco own him that at the very least

First of all Robin is in charge of collecting the Poneglyphs, not Luffy.
I think he will find it when he finally clashes with Blackbeard. This is a battle that has to happen eventually.

 

[Warine]

First of all Robin is in charge of collecting the Poneglyphs, not Luffy.
I think he will find it when he finally clashes with Blackbeard. This is a battle that has to happen eventually.

That has to happen on a narrative stand point, it's not the same discussion anymore at this point. If we look into it in an in world perspective, Marco own him that

 

[PortgasDMor]

That has to happen on a narrative stand point, it's not the same discussion anymore at this point. If we look into it in an in world perspective, Marco own him that

Why? what debt does he owe Luffy? He helped him twice, not the other way around.

 

[Warine]

Why? what debt does he owe Luffy? He helped him twice, not the other way around.

He achieved what whitebeard couldn't

 

[PortgasDMor]

He achieved what whitebeard couldn't

Couldn't? or didn't want to? Whitebeard's goal was to have a family, not to become the pirate king.

 

[Warine]

Couldn't? or didn't want to? Whitebeard's goal was to have a family, not to become the pirate king.

Whitebeard wanted to free wano but he abandonned that project because it would kill to many people, Luffy didn't freed wano to become the PK anyway

 

[PortgasDMor]

Whitebeard wanted to free wano but he abandonned that project because it would kill to many people, Luffy didn't freed wano to become the PK anyway

So? How does all that contradict my theory that Blackbeard has the 4th poneglyph?

 

[Herrera95]

It's probably in Elbaf imo.

Forget Elbaf. We are not going there.

 

[Warine]

So? How does all that contradict my theory that Blackbeard has the 4th poneglyph?

Because surely, Marco would tell him if it was the case

 

[PortgasDMor]

Because surely, Marco would tell him if it was the case

Ok, you are entitled to your opinion. I'm not going back in circles to answer what I already have. I don't see this as contradictory.