No, its not edgy because he fights like a fucking cartoon character. The fuck? Who gives a shit about colors?
Every single time people say that g5 Luffy is cool because he’s not edgy they always have some shitty tumblr/deviantart OC black form to post for comparisons.
Here’s the thing, an edgelord doesn’t mean someone cloaked in dark using blood/darkness as a weapon, by literal definition, an edgelord is someone that provokes with risqué behaviour, g5 Luffy uses “cartoon powers”, which allows him to ignore various form of pain and impose his will to others through his cartoon manipulation on enemies, all while making them look pathetic.
Making their opponents look like a joke, random psychotic laughs during their attacks, antisocial and anti authority behaviour, but still liked and worshipped by everyone that’s the best type of cocktail for an edgelord kid to self insert, and you come around with the cartoon bullshit, rofl, guess what Moonman is a cartoon, he’s white, has shades, antiauthority, antisemitic and if you were old enough to know about YTMND lore, you’d know he had toonforce too