Top 50 strongest characters alive 2022 Poll Semi Finals!
- Thread starter Veku
- Start date
- Status
So I'm failing to see how this is an ordered top 50 list. In order to do that you would have to have 50 separate polls/threads, and appoint a place to the winner, so 1 character from each thread/poll. Now I'm not sure you can add 50 characters to a single poll. So this is where this event makes sense, to narrow down the top 10 slot, the next 20 so on so forth so that they can be placed in the relevant polls based on this event.
Is that what you had in mind?
Is that what you had in mind?
Polls are unfortunately restriced to 25 subjects.
Not sure if I understand what you mean correctly, but I was going into this event knowing this method won't lead to a 100% accurate result....However, if you take the top 10 for example, to figure out the order I just go by the amount of votes each character received.
Like I mentioned, I'm aware that it's not entirely accurate, because the votes are applied based on the people choosing their top 5 and not because they arrange their personal top 10 (which is not possible with this method anyway)- but the amount of votes each characters receives comparatively, is a good indicator to figure out the approximate placement for each character.....
Not sure if I understand what you mean correctly, but I was going into this event knowing this method won't lead to a 100% accurate result....However, if you take the top 10 for example, to figure out the order I just go by the amount of votes each character received.
Like I mentioned, I'm aware that it's not entirely accurate, because the votes are applied based on the people choosing their top 5 and not because they arrange their personal top 10 (which is not possible with this method anyway)- but the amount of votes each characters receives comparatively, is a good indicator to figure out the approximate placement for each character.....
Ok let me propose a top 30 then or even 25, cause 50 might be excessive for this. ~30 might still include fan favourites like Sanji the Warlords and commanders. 50 starts getting into irrelevant status and might stretch the event longer than desired. Keep in mind this current event would have served a purpose either way.
-The idea is to vote in order, so start a thread to vote for the strongest character, and work your way down to the 30th.
-Take the top 10 list from this poll, have everyone vote for 1 character only. Who they think is the strongest.
-Then in the following thread exclude the winner of the previous poll so there are only 9 remaining options in the current poll (or you can take the 11th character or more and toss them in). And everyone votes for who they think is the strongest among these 9 (again lock to 1 vote per person). Winner of that poll would be ranked 2nd.
Rince and repeat. So you would have 30 threads of this kind, placing each character in a slot (honestly you can adjust the number as you see fit, even if you want to do just a top 10 for example). And this current event would have served it's purpose for setting up polls for the ranking event (but if it's 25 characters at a time, that allows for more freedom anyway, you can simply have the top 25 in each thread removing the previous winner everytime).
Imo that would be much cooler and much more competitive, it would give you an accurate assessment of this communities top 30 characters. The way it is set up now we don't have a clear idea, basically we're just voting to see who is top 1.
Also the extended event would be convenient for pinging people since there would only be 1 thread up at a time.
-The idea is to vote in order, so start a thread to vote for the strongest character, and work your way down to the 30th.
-Take the top 10 list from this poll, have everyone vote for 1 character only. Who they think is the strongest.
-Then in the following thread exclude the winner of the previous poll so there are only 9 remaining options in the current poll (or you can take the 11th character or more and toss them in). And everyone votes for who they think is the strongest among these 9 (again lock to 1 vote per person). Winner of that poll would be ranked 2nd.
Rince and repeat. So you would have 30 threads of this kind, placing each character in a slot (honestly you can adjust the number as you see fit, even if you want to do just a top 10 for example). And this current event would have served it's purpose for setting up polls for the ranking event (but if it's 25 characters at a time, that allows for more freedom anyway, you can simply have the top 25 in each thread removing the previous winner everytime).
Imo that would be much cooler and much more competitive, it would give you an accurate assessment of this communities top 30 characters. The way it is set up now we don't have a clear idea, basically we're just voting to see who is top 1.
Also the extended event would be convenient for pinging people since there would only be 1 thread up at a time.
S
Yeah this is a good idea in theory, definitely would lead to a accurate result, but another 10-30 threads? You know the attention span and patience user have here
To make it easier for you, since its 25 characters per poll. Just start with the top 25 from this event and keep excluding 1 character each subsequent thread (unless the top 30 has some big fan faves then just add them in once the top 5 is settled).
I guess the top 1 wouldn't need to be made since this event will cover that. You can start with #2.
At worst, you can revisit this in a few months or something. To actually rank characters, cause this is not much of a ranking. It's a grouping.
Idk I think that would be fun, we'd get characters like Zoro, Law, Rayleigh, then King, Doffy, Kat, Sanji etc. in tight contests for placement. And it would cement where WG ranks these characters at that point in time.
If that still seems like too much, you can honestly just make one for top 10-15 characters.
- Status