I always make an effort to parse information calmly.
I feel like any criticism I have to offer for your approach can probably go unsaid. The problem, obviously, is that you haven't put me in a position where I can work with you. For example, I think Prof is Town, but I don't *know* that, and this all could just as easily be a way to save face and backtrack from your previously stated position. I do think your thought progression is plausible, but then I have to accept that Flower, as town, willfully co-opted your lie. Also plausible, but you see I'm alredy several leaps deep here and I could certainly go further.
This is why, when Indie, if you're going to claim you need to just be straight up with it. I don't think I would ever lynch someone under the logic that they may link with scum... as opposed to just trying to lynch scum. Now we're so deep into this story it's hard to actually defend and justify any part of this. The best I can do here is accept it and leave it be. I won't be treating you as an extension of the town, but I won't sabotage your position either. I think that's about as fair-handed as I can be.
The lesson here, of course, is not to lie when the occassion doesn't call for it. As you will have seen - it quickly gets out of hand.
I feel like any criticism I have to offer for your approach can probably go unsaid. The problem, obviously, is that you haven't put me in a position where I can work with you. For example, I think Prof is Town, but I don't *know* that, and this all could just as easily be a way to save face and backtrack from your previously stated position. I do think your thought progression is plausible, but then I have to accept that Flower, as town, willfully co-opted your lie. Also plausible, but you see I'm alredy several leaps deep here and I could certainly go further.
This is why, when Indie, if you're going to claim you need to just be straight up with it. I don't think I would ever lynch someone under the logic that they may link with scum... as opposed to just trying to lynch scum. Now we're so deep into this story it's hard to actually defend and justify any part of this. The best I can do here is accept it and leave it be. I won't be treating you as an extension of the town, but I won't sabotage your position either. I think that's about as fair-handed as I can be.
The lesson here, of course, is not to lie when the occassion doesn't call for it. As you will have seen - it quickly gets out of hand.