Versus Battle Who is a better antagonist? Madara or Blackbeard?

R1:Who is a better antag?/R2:Who is a better character?/R3:Who is more iconic?/R4:Who u like more?


  • Total voters
    31

Jiihad

Survivors Guilt
β€Ž
#6
1. In all honesty, they’re both pretty fuxkin bad up till this point
2. Better Character: Madara, he’s actually a character and is finished. BlackBeard has borderline 0 characterization besides being a fat coward
3. Madara is laughably more iconic. Man legit damn near shut down tha innanet when he dropped
4. Personally I like Madara more, but that’s prolly cause he’s done as a character. You can actually say that he’s a character plus he has way way way more iconic shit/speeches etc
 
#8
Madara was a better character but not a better antagonist. Madara co-founded the leaf village so he's pretty much responsible for as much good as bad he caused.

If Blackbeard didn't get bitched out by WB he would be topshelf villian imo.
 

TheKnightOfTheSea

𝕷𝖔𝖗𝖉 𝖔𝖋 𝕸𝖔𝖔𝖓'π–˜ π•Ύπ–•π–†π–œπ–“
β€Ž
#9
1. Madara. Haven't seen enough from Teach, and as much as I like him, I don't have faith in Oda's writing.

2. Teach. I think he's a good character so far, though I find myself preferring pre time skip

3. Madara. I think OP villains in general are still less iconic than Naruto's villains.

4. Teach is my third favorite character in OP. I enjoyed Madara but never was a huge fan.
 
#11
1. Madara's vision is childish, he has no direct relation to the main protagonist and had the most garbage ending in fiction

2. Again Madara's character is non existant, he's just a cool guy.
Teach however is a pretty complex character with multiple sides to his demeanor, he has direct correlation with the mc with decent build up throughout the manga

3. No one is more iconic than Madara I'll give him that

4. The Marshall by far
 
#12
Usually I vote for Naruto against OP, but this time I'm voting for Teach. Madara was clown who believed in some written info instead believing his friend. Also his so called pefect world is bullshit. Plus he always was not strong enough,unlike Teach the man who had dream and real goal with a plan how accomplish it.
 
#16
Better antagonist : Blackbeard is better antagonist than Madara. He has goal set and doing all means to accomplish it. On other hand Madaras dream was half baked
Better Character : Blackbeard is better written than Madara.
Iconic : Madara was more iconic than BB.
Like Most : Overall i like Blackbeard more than Madara
 
#17
Madara as a character and drive for his antagonism

As a Villan you can argue BB is thoroughly defined by his orchestrated betrayal of WB
due for personal goals
 
#18
Antagonist: Madara. His motivation was dumb and stubborn and ultimately futile, but it made sense. BB is just greedy.

Character: BB has more personality

Iconic: Madara is that guy.

One I like more: I probably look forward to seeing BB appear in scenes more than I do Madara
 
Top