Sounds like this Greater Albania propaganda that postulates that all lands once inhabitated by Albanians should be annexed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_Albania
But Albania already exists

I'm not saying Israel should have all the land it wants, just that it should exist.
Post automatically merged:

No. Scottish people don't have their own state, neither do the Basques, and so many others.
Haven't those people had elections and chosen to remain part of their respective countries?

I know that's at least the case for the scottish, idk about the Basques.
 
Except the europeans have a home of their own...europe

The jews didn't have that, which is why they created Israel. Also keep in mind, the zionist movement started in the late 1800s, the state of Israel was created in 1948, between that time a lot of jews migrated to that area.

So come post world war II, Israel honestly made the most sense for the creation of a jewish state. There was already a large jewish population in the region, plus jews had historic ties to the land.
Historic ties to lands doesn't give you claims for said lands.

If that is so then Mongolia could claim entire world, Germany could claim entire Europe, Croatia could claim Bosnia and parts of Serbia. World doesn't work like that

Isreal is and always will be pity reward given to Jews by Allies post ww2 on the blood cost of Muslim population of the area
 
Many ethnic minorities in Europe don't have a country.....
Well I think if they want one, they should have the right to have one.
Post automatically merged:

If that is so then Mongolia could claim entire world, Germany could claim entire Europe, Croatia could claim Bosnia and parts of Serbia. World doesn't work like that
yeah I’m not arguing that israel should have all the land it wants, just that it should exist.


Isreal is and always will be pity reward given to Jews by Allies post ww2 on the blood cost of Muslim population of the area
The Arabs never wanted compromise. They wanted to have all of the land to themselves even though Israel had a rightful claim.

They could have just accepted the partition, but they wanted a war and they lost. Boo hoo.
 
Last edited:
The Arabs never wanted compromise. They wanted to have all of the land to themselves even though Israel had a rightful claim.

They could have just accepted the partition, but they wanted a war and they lost. Boo hoo.
Wow, mask off moment. I find it especially pathetic since you're a wanna be with no real ties to Israel. Way to go with justifying genocide.
 
Last edited:
ethnostates shouldn't be a thing.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Partition_Plan_for_Palestine

it literally wasn’t an ethnostate. They were going to give the Jews a state that had just a 55% majority, with a 45% Palestinian population.

That was the shit the Arabs disagreed with

The Jews just didn’t want to be a minority so they could have self determination
Wow, mask off moment. I find it especially pathetic since you're a wanna be with no real ties to Israel. Way to go with justifying genocide.
No dude, y’all are being antisemitic acting like the mere existence of a Jewish state in any capacity is a crime.

As if all the violence is 100% the Jews fault for merely wanting to have control of their future in a state of their own.

The nakba was awful, the Israelis did awful things in that war, but the Arabs aren’t fucking victims when they chose not to compromise and wanted the war.
 
Top