Versus Battle Which manga is the best out of the Big 3?

R1: The best?/ R2: Which one do you like the best?/ R3: Most iconic?/R4: Best villains?/R5: Best MC?


  • Total voters
    54

Light D Lamperouge

๐–‚๐–๐–†๐–™ ๐•ฎ๐–”๐–š๐–‘๐–‰ ๐•ณ๐–†๐–›๐–Š ๐•ญ๐–Š๐–Š๐–“
โ€Ž
#1
Title.

Which series do you think is better and which one do you prefer? Which is the most iconic? Which has the best villains? Who is the best MC?

Some criteria:

-Plot
-Main characters
-Side characters
-Villains
-Character designs
-Power system
-Story arcs
-Incorporation of themes
-Art
-Imagery
-Panelling
-Originality
-World building
-Characterization
-Enjoyment
- Etc.


 

Apollo

The Sol King
โ€Ž
#5
-Plot: :saden: One Piece ?
-Main characters: :saden: One Piece ?
-Side characters: Naruto
-Villains: Naruto
-Character designs: Bleach
-Power system: One Piece
-Story arcs: One Piece
-Incorporation of themes: I'll give this to none of them
-Art: Bleach
-Panelling: Naruto
-Originality: One Piece
-World building: One Piece
-Characterization:Naruto
-Enjoyment: One Piece

OP-7 points
Naruto-4 points
Bleach- 2 points
 

Jaguark101

"Freedom is the right of all sentient beings"
โ€Žโ€Ž
#7
I love BLEACH but I gotta be objective,
R1: Probably One Piece as its got the most potential.
R2: My Personal Fav is Bleach.
R3: Naruto is the most iconic and is the most popular of the 3 in the west, TAC pretty much pointed out some of the reasons why.
R4: Naruto has the better villains out of the big 3 (Aizen, Ulquiorra, Grimmjow, Tsukishima and Yhwach still goats).
R5: Ichigo.
 
#10
The most iconic anime is Naruto (out of these 3). The heavy cringe the fandom brought to the public in the form of pre teens rasenganing each other or Naruto running >>> anything the other series can say
I think that applies to US/English speaking countries which were ruined for OP due to the shitty anime.
In a lot of countries, One Piece was the spiritual successor to Dragonball in terms of being the most popular anime/manga.

Anyway, One Piece for all questions. I liked Bleach for one arc, second arc was the same but worse, Naruto for two arcs or so.
 
#12
Unfortunately I never watched Bleach. Heard good things about it except for the ending but never got the chance to dive into it.
Post automatically merged:

I think that applies to US/English speaking countries which were ruined for OP due to the shitty anime.
In a lot of countries, One Piece was the spiritual successor to Dragonball in terms of being the most popular anime/manga.

Anyway, One Piece for all questions. I liked Bleach for one arc, second arc was the same but worse, Naruto for two arcs or so.
South America, nonenglish speaking countries, Naruto was king. One Piece is barely popular outside Japan where roughly 80% of it's sales are from Japan. Naruto was vice versa, it wasn't very popular in Japan but was very popular internationally.
 
Last edited:
#13
For me yes :kayneshrug:
Post automatically merged:

Unfortunately I never watched Bleach. Heard good things about it except for the ending but never got the chance to dive into it.
Post automatically merged:



South America, nonenglish speaking countries, Naruto was king. One Piece is barely popular outside Japan where roughly 80% of it's sales are from Japan. Naruto was vice versa, it wasn't very popular in Japan but was very popular internationally.
Yeah naruto reigns supreme outside of Japan even more so than DBZ
 
#14
-Plot
-Main characters
-Side characters
-Villains
-Character designs
-Power system
-Story arcs
-Incorporation of themes
-Art
-Imagery
-Panelling
-Originality
-World building
-Characterization
-Enjoyment
For me:

Plot: One Piece
Side Characters: One Piece/Bleach
Villains: Bleach
Character Designs: Bleach
Story Arcs: One Piece
Power System: Naruto/Bleach > One Piece (Haki is fkin trash)
Art: Bleach
Paneling: Bleach/Naruto
Originality: One Piece
World Building: One Piece
Enjoyment: Bleach
 
#19
Which series do you think is better and which one do you prefer?
I think it comes down to Peak Naruto or Peak One Piece, maybe One Piece was better. Definitely prefer Bleach despite all the flaws, low key exuded some uniqueness through its art and characters.
Which is the most iconic?
As a series, Naruto for sure. It is far more popular than the other two. I would argue for Bleachโ€™s characters being iconic, a lot people in the anime world know Bleach characters despite never seeing the series. I mean everyone knows Aizen for example, people have heard of characters like Kenpachi or seen characters like Grimmjow etc I mean even Yhwach is pretty well known in power scaling discussions for what it is worth lol.
Which has the best villains?
I would say Bleach and Naruto by far. Like between Pain, Madara, the Akatsuki, Aizen, the Espada and the Captains (in SS) what does One Piece have to show for that? Doflamingo, Lucci and Crocodile are the only 3 that come to mind. Kaido and Big Mom had the potential but both ended up being disastrous as villains.
Who is the best MC?
Naruto and One Piece take this one again. Between Luffy and Naruto I think Naruto is better. Ichigo is probably the most relatable character here and I would prefer him but he simply fails to compare as a Shonen MC. Ichigo didnโ€™t even consistently rank no.1 in Bleachโ€™s own popularity polls (I think he didnโ€™t even rank top 5 one year lmao), not that popularity polls dictate whoโ€™s better but it low key goes to show how much more impact the side characters had in pretty much carrying the show. Despite the missed opportunities, in a vacuum Ichigo is probably more tolerable than like half the MCs in modern Shonen personality wise but is lacking pretty much everything else.
Post automatically merged:

You know very well how Bleachโ€™s art >> Naruto and OP. Donโ€™t make people pull out the receipts :gosecon:
 
Top