1. 2 months is the right time frame for judge and Caesar’s reunion
2. Why kidnap CP agents? Same, reason they’d spill about Vegapunks Poneglyph research, turn the WG against him
3. Caesar has hallucinatory gas, if it can make kata fight his family, he can make him and judge look like a Vegapunk.
4. Because they literally just said that they realized that Vegapunk is in their way. They’re way more likely than the BB pirates and it doesn’t seem like any Vegapunk is doing it
No offense but everything you said just feels forced and dumb.
I highly doubt the third reason would even work.
Your theory reminds me of those dumb Carrot or Inu/Neko traitor theories where some of those people would make so many bs reasons to prove that they were the traitor when in reality it made no sense.
It's the same thing with your Judge and Caesar theory, everything you are saying just feels forced and makes no sense.
It only makes sense to you because you actually believe it but when you really think about it, it doesn't make sense at all.
Also I know you are only forcing this theory because you want Judge to play a role during this arc because of Sanji.