Status
Not open for further replies.

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
I listed Kon yesterday as IC. Like multiple times. For him to come to thread afterwards with IC claim as Central 46 of all shit is not good. Like, logically speaking you have to wonder why Fuji would implement Central 46 to be innocent. They are anything but innocent.

Why do you not consider KS btw? It was cast right off the bat.
I don't know what KS is. I also don't think it can be invoked to dismiss everything we see - that's scum-motivated.

You also need to establish why it's not good. Kon not being an IC simply means you were wrong - I would argue Kon works just as well as a Miller.

All of this is to say that speculation about the IC at this stage is pointless. We can, for the time being, consider him to be town, with the note that his play will remain subject to scrutiny.
 
I mean what would even be the role of Central 46?

Rukia was already sentenced to die.
The command has been issued to fight

Like that is what Centra 46 did before getting offed by Aizen
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
If you wanna hide something you hide it in plain sight.
Again, conjecture. You can't build scum cases off of theories - I could establish plausible scum motive to anyone in the game if I were so inclined. At best, it feeds confirmation bias. Which is why it's a poor argument.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
You are too dismissive
It's not about being dismissive, I take exception with people promoting poor arguments because that's my job as town - to identify the poor arguments and to ascertain the reason why they were made. You're circling around the point here - you can have your tinfoil, I simply won't allow you to present it as logical analysis when it is, at least at this stage, merely tinfoil.
 
It's not about being dismissive, I take exception with people promoting poor arguments because that's my job as town - to identify the poor arguments and to ascertain the reason why they were made. You're circling around the point here - you can have your tinfoil, I simply won't allow you to present it as logical analysis when it is, at least at this stage, merely tinfoil.
You just explained what dismissive is with extra steps and words
 

MUUGEN

呪のろいの王
I also think we should establish a second wagon, in case Pero is town and gets anti-claimed or there is some manipulation at play (there almost certainly will be on some level here).

To these ends, I'll throw a name in the ring: our dear friend @MUUGEN
OMGUS aye.

is this the best you could muster up after 12 hrs Rat?
 

Lindltaylor

There's no "Tina!"
And the order has already been issued to us.

Unless can Al can redirect people per his liking i don't see much to his role
That's why Fuji says that he can't vote or be helped/aided in anyway:

They posess no vote power, and cannot be aided in any way. They will be deliberating the happenings of this game deep underground.
Basically Al cannot be given positive actions (I think) and can't vote. So in a way, his role does limit him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top