Anime & Manga Ryofui Vs Riboku: How To Write Superb Manga Dialogue (And Why Luffy Vs Kaido Sucks)

[Seth]

A good manga would be at least somewhat understandable even to people who haven't read much of it.

Sure. To know if the manga is good or not you'd first have to read it before talking about it

You read One Piece and know it left and right for better or worse.

You didn't read Kingdom and don't know the setup, what led to the meeting, and what type of figures those guys are in this world.


Makes sense to compare the two with such knowledge

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Sure. To know if the manga is good or not you'd first have to read it before talking about it

You read One Piece and know it left and right for better or worse.

You didn't read Kingdom and don't know the setup, what led to the meeting, and what type of figures those guys are in this world.


Makes sense to compare the two with such knowledge

Not my fault. Who's the one coming to an OP forum to talk about Kingdom?

 

[Seth]

Not my fault. Who's the one coming to an OP forum to talk about Kingdom?

WG is dead when there is no chapter.

+ I was thinking at first that I blame Lee for posting it outside the Kingdom section but then again it's a comparison thread in the multiverse section lmfao.

 

[RayanOO]

And if you want to know what happens next, well I’m afraid you’ll just have to join the GOAT fandom and read Kingdom.

Lol that level of blueballing

 

[Owl Ki]

I don't need to know it all. They're literally spoonfeeding the names of the characters to the readers as if the readers don't know their fucking names lol.

It is a diplomatic setting where they each state each other's titles in the first time they have met. This would be expected in such a setting.

You are acting like there is a literal name box that has popped up for the third time in an arc. Lol.

 

[Elder Lee Hung]

I wish thread creators had the ability to block certain people from replying to their threads…

 

[Owl Ki]

@Elder Lee Hung Kingdom dialogue is indeed top notch. It is a series where some of my favourite moments are pure dialogue and I am as hyped for chapters of talking as I am chapters of fighting. Lol.

I will say for Kaido and Luffy that comparing them to Riboku and Ryofui is a bit unfair since the latter two are a different kind of character altogether. They are intellectual, learned individuals that thrive in matters of deception and intrigue while Kaido and Luffy are meant to be far more straightforward and blunt characters.

Straightforward and blunt characters can still have depth and be observational however. So to compare like-to-like and still use Kingdom as an example then the Kingdom character that probably most resembles Kaido would be Gaimou.

Gaimou 100% blows Kaido out of the water even with the limited screen time he has had. Lol.
https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/is-gaimou-correct.39860/

Which is funny cause Gaimou was a character with zero build up. The bloke just appeared and started ploughing through shit like a sentient wrecking ball.

Compare that to Kaido having a decade of build up in advance just to be a character so poorly received that even the casuals in a Popularity Poll vote Bepo the feckin Bear over Kaido in the middle of his own damn arc is just extra LEL.

 

[FutureWarrior123]

The timing is impeccable with this analysis and what we got with the most recent chapter. Really curious to hear your thoughts on it.

 

[MarineHQ]

I get a little triggered seeing Kingdom and Shit piece panels in the same post ngl.


Great analysis of their conversation. Ryofui's on panel presence was unmatched for a non-general. To be in a room with Moubu and SHK but still being portrayed as the most dominant and threatening is an insane feat.

 

[Apollo]

I have to say, this is a very unfair comparison.

Kingdom is one of those mangas that can convey politics and politicians of the story in a realistic and intellectual way. The number of manga capable of doing that is very small. This comparison is unfair, as I do not think any manga can portray politics in the way of Kingdom. In my opinion, its even better than the warfare parts of the manga on average

I don't expect Oda to give dialogue as deep as Kingdom's, all I want is good dialogue and cutting out unnecessary fodder-reaction panels.

There are only two points which I will contest in this post:

Riboku, at the time this scene takes place, is considered the strongest General in all China, because he just defeated and killed the previous strongest General in all China.

Riboku is the greatest general in all of China

 

[Sandai Kitetsu]

"Big punch goes brrrr" - probably Kaido
Your average OP fan would read Ryofui and Sei's showdown and think they're on the same side.

Lmao you’re not smarter for reading that shitty ass poorly drawn chinese manga, you’re not reading high fiction you’re reading a comic strip, These retards kill me LMFAO

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

One day I'll read Lingdom just so I can understand @Greatest Agenda General of the Heavens's memes

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

I think its bit of stretch because Kingdom is more centered around real life characters and its centered around Qin regime.

Politics and war is centeral theme of kingdom and One piece is centered towards freedom and ambition of luffy.

One piece definately has backdrop where oda fails to give end narrative but as whole his storybuilding is brilliant last few chapters are absolute masterpiece i can totally forgive wano arc.

Kingdom is brilliant as well but lets face it it can get repeatative at times riboku is literally shown as god level startegist and Shin also gets plot shield .

Both are not perfect.

Post automatically merged: Jun 13, 2023

I have to say, this is a very unfair comparison.

Kingdom is one of those mangas that can convey politics and politicians of the story in a realistic and intellectual way. The number of manga capable of doing that is very small. This comparison is unfair, as I do not think any manga can portray politics in the way of Kingdom. In my opinion, its even better than the warfare parts of the manga on average

I don't expect Oda to give dialogue as deep as Kingdom's, all I want is good dialogue and cutting out unnecessary fodder-reaction panels.

There are only two points which I will contest in this post:

One piece is for kids , oda will never make the manga serious and dialogue centeric. I wont be surprised Imu and gorosei have ridiculous design .

Kingdom is for adults comparing theme i think its unfair to compare tbh. Oda can write serious manga considering he was assistant working for kenshin manga.