General & Others STORYTELLING - Gear 5 is amazing
- Thread starter Logiko
- Start date
I want people who are trying to sh*t on the work of Gear 5 here to really take a
Nobody is preventing people to give their opinion. I'm just saying that giving a bad statement about an objective good technique is not legitimate. You can of course say "this is masterfull, but I don't really like it". It's perfectly cool.
That you can't erase reality ? Yup.
What ? On what ?
Nobody is preventing people to give their opinion. I'm just saying that giving a bad statement about an objective good technique is not legitimate. You can of course say "this is masterfull, but I don't really like it". It's perfectly cool.
That you can't erase reality ? Yup.
What ? On what ?
It is objective. Storytelling is a skill, there are things we can mesure.
And this plot twist was perfect from a storytelling standpoint. Objectively.
But you are completely in your right not to like the technique while understanding that it is masterfull.
Like I said, it's just like impressionism or expressionnism.. You can dislike it, but you must understand that those technique were groundbreaking stuff and amazing from an objective and technical point of view.
Oh ok.
But no, this is not a retcon. Gear 5 doesn't contradict the story in anyway. It only extend our knowledge of the world.
And this plot twist was perfect from a storytelling standpoint. Objectively.
But you are completely in your right not to like the technique while understanding that it is masterfull.
Like I said, it's just like impressionism or expressionnism.. You can dislike it, but you must understand that those technique were groundbreaking stuff and amazing from an objective and technical point of view.
Oh ok.
But no, this is not a retcon. Gear 5 doesn't contradict the story in anyway. It only extend our knowledge of the world.
And like we have tried to tell you, this is merely your idea about your supposed facts.
But I am not trying to convince you since is impossible convincing someone whose premise is "I am objectively right".
Obviously, you can very well think is the better plot twist even written. No hard feelings. In fact, I am happy for you.
But I am not trying to convince you since is impossible convincing someone whose premise is "I am objectively right".
Obviously, you can very well think is the better plot twist even written. No hard feelings. In fact, I am happy for you.
No. Storytelling is a skill just like when you play from an instrument.
But yeah of course, you can always give a violin to a kid for the first time and say that their music is amazing.. but I'll bet you won't stand in front of it for more than 1 hour lmao.
In storytelling there are rules, there is a way to create a good story, you can just come with a plot at random.
I don't need to be. This is not a case where an opinion is stated here. Its not like a theory. Its the basic analysis of a craft.
But yeah of course, you can always give a violin to a kid for the first time and say that their music is amazing.. but I'll bet you won't stand in front of it for more than 1 hour lmao.
In storytelling there are rules, there is a way to create a good story, you can just come with a plot at random.
I don't need to be. This is not a case where an opinion is stated here. Its not like a theory. Its the basic analysis of a craft.
We don't agree because, for us, you mistaken definitions for realty and the connections and analysis you think are true for facts, which are not.
To use your own example, to me you are indicating the Moon, not the Sun. And the Moon is not a star, but you would say that you are objectively indicating the Sun, at which we will respond that we see the Moon instead.
On and so on: infinite circle.
But I understand what you say. Problem is the premise. With the premise "I am right" one can't discuss anything.
To use your own example, to me you are indicating the Moon, not the Sun. And the Moon is not a star, but you would say that you are objectively indicating the Sun, at which we will respond that we see the Moon instead.
On and so on: infinite circle.
But I understand what you say. Problem is the premise. With the premise "I am right" one can't discuss anything.