[FNZ] Role Madness One Piece Whole Cake Island

[ConquistadoR]

You were so confident Watson was wolf and now that we're starting to get into a tight situation, you think it's wise to bite your tongue. Like you just said, you've been transparent all game about your usage, and now you decide to clam up, when you were so confident about a mislynch? That reeks

Literally everyone was confident Watson was scum.
Don't pin that shit on me - as i said go read her own Indie claim lynch bait when Rej (Luffy) was on the chopping block.\
And then surviving an Amped Vig Shot from LANJI.

You are just making a "fake" scene here about me being confident that Watson was scum - when you've mislynched people for less (TwO RoLeBLoCkErS) this very game.

This just screams like shading from a Scummy slot.

 

[Lord Melkor]

If there is anything I'm paranoid about it's that
I find a single vanilla in this game to be really out of place and it should be acknowledged

There was a single vanilla in Fuji's Dresrosa game than was on NF, I do not think you played it?

Though if I were mod I would propably make a twist this game, but fake claiming vanilla would be a very bold move.

 

[Pot Goblin]

There was a single vanilla in Fuji's Dresrosa game than was on NF, I do not think you played it?

Though if I were mod I would propably make a twist this game, but fake claiming vanilla would be a very bold move.

I have not

 

[ConquistadoR]

I don't think that outright proves her as she could be able to activate abilities in the day or simply abstained that night
Don't blindly wave off Nat as that allows her in the back door if she really is some kind of scum

She is Town.

I am pretty sure of it this game.

 

[ConquistadoR]

A scum slot wont go to the lengths Nat went to defend SakazOuki when he was being Mislynched.

 

[ConquistadoR]

Anyway, we're flipping one out of Dest or Melkor this day.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Anyway, we're flipping one out of Dest or Melkor this day.

I may go with Dest, but this phase may be crucial so I want for everyone to speak.

Do not vote end early people!

 

[Pot Goblin]

Anyway, we're flipping one out of Dest or Melkor this day.

Talk to me about the Melkor lynch I'm curious about somethin

 

[Lord Melkor]

Also, Fuji confirmed my Revenger kill would be day kill, could scum be able to mess with it or not?

 

[ConquistadoR]

Talk to me about the Melkor lynch I'm curious about somethin

Was placed as a "Strong Town" slot by Cake even before he had contributed anything of note to the game - when he hadnt revealed Flavor or Ability or Result.
That pinged me right after Cake's flip.

He has done little to convince me otherwise after that and his Claim feels too fake to me, a very convenient post Death role for Scum to claim.

 

[Pot Goblin]

Was placed as a "Strong Town" slot by Cake even before he had contributed anything of note to the game - when he hadnt revealed Flavor or Ability or Result.
That pinged me right after Cake's flip.

He has done little to convince me otherwise after that and his Claim feels too fake to me, a very convenient post Death role for Scum to claim.

Yea that claim is concerning to me if real
We're at a point now where we can't play around with that with us losing 2 last night and Charlie poisoned today
If we flip him and it's real and he shoots a town with it we'll be at LyLo if scum lands their kill that night

 

[ConquistadoR]

If we flip him and it's real and he shoots a town with it we'll be at LyLo if scum lands their kill that night

If he's scum, i dont think he'd able to kill from the Grave.
An option would be to lynch him and ask him to shoot Dest if in the offchance Melkor is actually town.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Was placed as a "Strong Town" slot by Cake even before he had contributed anything of note to the game - when he hadnt revealed Flavor or Ability or Result.
That pinged me right after Cake's flip.

He has done little to convince me otherwise after that and his Claim feels too fake to me, a very convenient post Death role for Scum to claim.

As I have told you several times, if I were scum, why would I claim that my revenge kill works in a lynch scenario, giving further incentive to town to lynch me?

 

[ConquistadoR]

As I have told you several times, if I were scum, why would I claim that my revenge kill works in a lynch scenario, giving further incentive to town to lynch me?

Who do you think are scum this game?
Can you give your reads of each player left alive please?

 

[Pot Goblin]

If he's scum, i dont think he'd able to kill from the Grave.
An option would be to lynch him and ask him to shoot Dest if in the offchance Melkor is actually town.

The scratch with that option is that we can't force the fella to shoot who we want to shoot
He could say one thing but end up takin a hero shot when the time comes, it's completely out of our hands lmao
Kinda wish we had a rolecrush cause that would give us the safe path we need

 

[Charlie]

so these are roles

town

You are Charlotte Katakuri!
Even Nights Roleblocker X3
Odd Nights Vigilante X3 X2
Night 1 Bulletproof

You are Charlotte Basskarte!
X2 Amplifier: Target a player and upgrade their next ability

You are Charlotte Cracker!
X3 Doctor: Target someone at night and protect them, can self target.

You are Charlotte Perospero!
X2 Rolecrusher

You are Charlotte Moscatto!
X3 Odd nights Watcher: On Odd Nights ( IE Night 1,3,5,etc) you may target a player and learn of who visits them.

You are Charlotte Counter!
X3 Roleblocker: Target a player and prevent them from using abilities for the night.

You are Charlotte Brulee!
X1 Commuter: You may commute yourself at night, rendering yourself untargettable.

You are Joscarpone! ( Right)
Mason: You are Masons with Mascarpone and share a permanent chat!
Cemented Vote: Your vote power cannot be stolen or silenced!

You are Charlotte Compotte!
X2 Bodyguard: Target a player and guard them, if they are targetted by a kill take the shot and die instead.

----
scum

You are Nami!
X3 Redirector
X3 Rolecrusher

You are Monkey D. Luffy!
X4 Roleblocker
X1 Bulletproof
X1 Strongman
X1 Nexus

You are Sanji Vinsmoke!
X1 Hider
X2 Messenger
X1 Neighborer
Flavor cop

---

thoughts based on claims only

Lord Melkor - Amande - bomb - i don't like it tbh, sounds bit like scum ability to me
Mitch/Chuck - Mascarpone - mason
Pot Goblin - ??? - healer - town imo, like i said earlier
TheAncientCenturion - Struessen - 3x refill - i'd expect town to have refiller if we have something like amplifier
Destroya - Big Mom - 1x lie detect, 1x bulletproof - meeeeeeeeh, idk about that, but luffy was already bulletproof, right? if it's fake, it could be indie
T-Pein™ - Opera - shots destroyer - a lot depends on targets i guess, but i'd rather expect scum to have this kind of ability, but then again there are lots of towns and they need different abilities, so maaaaybe? depends on targets probably
MonochromeYoru - ??? - redirect - looks good with nami being redirector
Natalija - Bobbins - vanilla - i'm willing to believe that, i remember vanillas in Dressrosa game
Kagu Nyan - Pudding - innocent child
ConquistadoR - ??? - jailor - do we need jailor with what flipped already? probably not, but i don't have strong feelings about it

---

so basically
me/pot/tac/mono/nat/kagu i wouldn't like voted out
conq/dest is maybe
pein/lm i don't like tbh

 

[Charlie]

@T-Pein™

hello, can you tell me who did you target with your ability? and when?

 

[Destroya]

To be fair Watson's play was utter shit. She claimed non-town and then only came yesterday to troll.

I will wait for @Natalija to come and give her thoughts, maybe she will be more open minded today.

Also why would Rej try to out Natalija as indie if she was his team?

Why are you asking such basic questions, Melkor? You know how to play this game. Maybe you're just trying to protect your mates here.

 

[Destroya]

Literally everyone was confident Watson was scum.
Don't pin that shit on me - as i said go read her own Indie claim lynch bait when Rej (Luffy) was on the chopping block.\
And then surviving an Amped Vig Shot from LANJI.

You are just making a "fake" scene here about me being confident that Watson was scum - when you've mislynched people for less (TwO RoLeBLoCkErS) this very game.

This just screams like shading from a Scummy slot.

I'm not pinning shit at all on you, I'm saying you being vocally confident Watson was flipping wolf, to all of a sudden being tight lipped around your usage, especially after you've been open with it all game, is pingy as fuck.

What's fake about this? If everyone thought Watson was wolf, that means everyone was wrong and should be doing at least some small rethinking about their POE. You've done none of that, instead tossing a vote on me and just moving forward blindly, and now refusing to give out information you're did before. That doesn't sit well with me.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Who do you think are scum this game?
Can you give your reads of each player left alive please?

From the order of most to least town read right now:

Kagura - confirmed innocent child. Pity she is not more active, but this is not bastard game, so I think we should treat her as confirmed.

Mitch/now Charlie - confirmed, he was mason with Joygirl, they were twins and knew each other's roles.

Mono -maybe biggest town lean of non-confirmed people, I town read his tone and I doubt he would claim redirector so easily, as there was redirector scum role.

Natalija - I do not think she is mafia because of lack of equity with Cake and Rej, but she is really stubborn this game. Could be indie if there is one left in the game.

Pot- his claim is pretty strong, otherwise he has been pretty null for me in terms of play.

You - I am not sure you are town, propably someone should ISO.

TAC- slight town read based on tone, his play has been very irregular though. His claim does not clear him fully. Refiller could be used for cred.

TPein- was mostly inactive entire game, only thing in his favour is the bold way he claimed.

Destroya - his reaction around Cake's antics and true tell was bad, also many dead townies scum read him.