ONE PIECE Live Action - Episodes Discussion Thread

[Logiko]

poor taste cause my criticism goes against your view point??

according to this notion I could say the same

however I didn't did I??

you're free to have your takes

And that's okay. You have your taste, I have mine. Nobody is forcing anything on the other, all is good in the world :)

 

[Dark-Abel]

I don't understand what the fuck they are doing with Garp's character though.

You will after episode 8

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

C4N a bigger backstabber than I ever could be

 

[Lor D. Coast]

Crazy how in 8 episodes Zoro didn't do a single Onigiri, Oda could learn something from the showrunners.

 

[Logiko]

You will after episode 8

Clever to take that water seven plot, very good choice. It creates a good rythm

 

[Uriyahn]

This is so weird... It respects the source material, but adapts it in such a bad way... Luffy is really giving me live action Radical Ed vibes...

 

[U c 4 up da idly]

Just finished episode 6, two to go
Buggy is the best character so far for me
Enjoying Zoro and Nami (i liked that they added some action scenes with her bo staff) the most out of the crew, just wish Zoro emoted more like he used to in East Blue. Sanji good but not enough screentime yet.
Usopp fine but he feels he just feels he kinda there, even in Syrup arc he didn't have much moments. In the manga I remember him punching Kuro and used his sharpshooting skills to get Jango (who was not present here) and save Kaya.
As I thought Luffy is by far the most difficult character to adapt into a live action, but I think not doing a 1:1 copy of the character was the wise choice.

I don't understand what the fuck they are doing with Garp's character though.

They did Garp so dirty when he met mihawk

 

[Logiko]

C4N a bigger backstabber than I ever could be

Nah, I'm just true to my words. I said that I would stop fighting for Carrot if my theory was proven false.

 

[RebelliousSoma]

Zoro, Mihawk, Nami and Buggy carried the season

Luffy, Sanji, Buggy, Garp, Koby, Helmepo were all great. Listing negatives would be quicker than listing the positives.

I am just wondering can we expect a good Chopper CGI? I can't get over how bad Arlong was, wtf was that shit? Also no Hachi. CGI Arlong might have been better. Also the sword fight with Hachi would have been amazing.

 

[Dark-Abel]

Crazy how in 8 episodes Zoro didn't do a single Onigiri, Oda could learn something from the showrunners.

he uses 3 sword style only twice in the entire season

 

[RebelliousSoma]

They did Garp so dirty when he met mihawk

In what way? I thought it was an ok interaction.

 

[DKI]

1 of the Strawhats gets a kiss

And that was definetly unexpected!
Then one episode later two strawhats starts arguing because she is mad he is going to risk his life for a foolish reason, and him asks to her "why do you give a shit about me?!" and I was like wow wait a minute... and then she answers "... cause you are my friend!" and I was like ok damn that was close :O
That was a great scene and props also to the actors!

 

[Indigo]

Luffy, Sanji, Buggy, Garp, Koby, Helmepo were all great. Listing negatives would be quicker than listing the positives.

I am just wondering can we expect a good Chopper CGI? I can't get over how bad Arlong was, wtf was that shit? Also no Hachi. CGI Arlong might have been better. Also the sword fight with Hachi would have been amazing.

Garp was great? are you crazy?

his characterization was completely off, his character made no sense in this live action

the dude was acting like a villain, Koby was scared and uncomfortable around him the entire season, instead of being an inspiring figure like in the manga / anime

Didn't like this "Chad" Helmepo, sorry mate

Inãki has Luffy's spirit, but his acting is all over the place

and Sanji was good, but the changes in Baratie really fucked his character introduction

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

They did Garp so dirty when he met mihawk

#NotMyGarp

 

[DKI]

Luffy, Sanji, Buggy, Garp, Koby, Helmepo were all great. Listing negatives would be quicker than listing the positives.

I am just wondering can we expect a good Chopper CGI? I can't get over how bad Arlong was, wtf was that shit? Also no Hachi. CGI Arlong might have been better. Also the sword fight with Hachi would have been amazing.

Arlong unfortunately do look a bit too much like a power rangers villain kekw

 

[Monkey D Al]

They did Garp so dirty when he met mihawk

Agree 100% especially since Garp could smoke him

 

[RebelliousSoma]

Garp was great? are you crazy?

his characterization was completely off, his character made no sense in this live action

the dude was acting like a villain, Koby was scared and uncomfortable around him the entire season, instead of being an inspiring figure like in the manga / anime

Didn't like this "Chad" Helmepo, sorry mate

Inãki has Luffy's spirit, but his acting is all over the place

and Sanji was good, but the changes in Baratie really fucked his character introduction

Shitty way to start the counter-argument with. How dare I have an opinion? Do I need someone else's approval?

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

this LA confirmed one pairing involving a straw hat since Oda must give his OK for stuff like this.
Congrats to Usopp x Kaya fans!

Spoiler

 

[Lor D. Coast]

he uses 3 sword style only twice in the entire season

And that's a good thing, they showed how good of a martial artist Zoro is, samurai are trained in multiple forms of combat.

 

[Indigo]

Shitty way to start the counter-argument with. How dare I have an opinion? Do I need someone else's approval?

I'm not even trying to argue with you lol

It's a straight fact

Series Garp is not Garp at all, this character makes no sense compared to what Garp is and stand for in the manga / anime