[FNZ] Role Madness Metal Gear Mafia - Game Over: Patriots Win [Michelle Only Player Alive]

Would you take part in part two using the same universe?


  • Total voters
    8
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
I said Watson "could" be better and that hopefully she would show up with a better post before day ended
Yeah, you'd mentioned her in a couple other posts as well, that I quoted eariler. More than Orca. Add on that I'm more familiar with Vodka, I just chose her over Orca. I really didn't put much thought into it saw you suggest Dr Watson after I asked for the exact line, and she'd been mentioned by you in that build up before.

She came back, and that made my ability seem useless. If she didn't come back that day, and confirms next day, it wouldn't have been
 
Here are the claims
Reviving this gem

Which would mean Reloaded, in that case. No, Reloaded, unless there's town that refuse to go with it, you really serve more as a placeholder vote.

I want Yoru today, it just looks horrific in hindsight.
Still unresolved--nothing but weak excuses and him underestimating his own play and admitting to sheeping. Unless he's indie, all these little things stack up against him.

Now the question is: did scum feel Mr. Reloaded was in a secure position that they didn't consider an alternate scenario, like possibly breadcrumbing to increase the difficulty? Or has Reloaded been chilling since he hasn't fought back against the challenges against him other than saying "you're wrong, I'm town"?
Like, what's this guy's goal here?

I don't know who looks worse in hindsight if we're keeping RA as a potential lynch candidate. Iunno about RA, it's tough.
But here's the thing: there's no way we can confirm that this was the intent and endgoal. Some ISO's need to be made for Hime's interactions with Reloaded, Orca and RA and we need to pull her votes as well.
 

Pot Goblin

Heisenbunny
Reviving this gem


Still unresolved--nothing but weak excuses and him underestimating his own play and admitting to sheeping. Unless he's indie, all these little things stack up against him.

Now the question is: did scum feel Mr. Reloaded was in a secure position that they didn't consider an alternate scenario, like possibly breadcrumbing to increase the difficulty? Or has Reloaded been chilling since he hasn't fought back against the challenges against him other than saying "you're wrong, I'm town"?
Like, what's this guy's goal here?

I don't know who looks worse in hindsight if we're keeping RA as a potential lynch candidate. Iunno about RA, it's tough.
But here's the thing: there's no way we can confirm that this was the intent and endgoal. Some ISO's need to be made for Hime's interactions with Reloaded, Orca and RA and we need to pull her votes as well.
I'll grab her votes real quick
 
I went back to see your reads to see whether you locked me in as Town since Orca's theory might have very solid credibility

Town indie implies you weren't sure of me, which means you didn't know my alignment prior. Possibly no TMI. +1

However, you had hime as null, Yoru as scum from this list.

So this is how it looks to me, viewing you through the lens as scum:
• hime places you in a position where you're essentially resolved of any accountability for your read on her.
• Yoru placed as a slight scum read. Yoru looked bad, mind you, and I give lenience to everyone except Reloaded given the context.
• It bugs me you also placed Orwellian as scum with the null on Hime.
• Rej doesn't have enough content for me to gauge his alignment. Care to explain this read?

The flip side where the accusations of you and hime being connected could be false:
• Someone in here is trying to press the possibility that hime and you set this up so either of you could flip. That doesn't make sense to me for a couple of reasons. . Your lie detect on me, again, is a missed opportunity if you are scum. Scum could literally undo me and play mind games with Pot despite the Town reads on me.
• You're being done dirty. I'll vouch for you again: we talked and you drank an Old fashioned in my honor and then got hella drunk you woke up in Mongolia. It's kind of a dirty tactic because she to your absence, it's easy to angleshoot this and that. I know it's a tactic. I've always disliked it unless it's in a scum team against one another for distancing purposes.
• Your reads are lacking because you've been busy and you're generally not as active as others to begin with, which is NAI for you.
Rej Town read was more a gut read from his play on Saturday and Sunday, he was more active from what I read, questioning etc. Didn't feel like Scum Rej to me.

Fang can't read me well and I can't read Fang well, so I scum read him a lot more than I should lol.

Tbh if I was scum, I would have used the Lie Detect on just the Hime as Big Boss is indie line, instead of trying to reveal all of it, and using it on you, if I even bothered to mention I had a lie detector in the thread. What likely would have happened is Hime would have asked me to Lie Detect something in the Scum chat, and Town would never know what I actually got as I'd claim another item. Or likely just ignore any posts asking what Item I got.

And again, Polar Bear wouldn't have been who was killed, when you're openly Solid Snake. If I was scum we'd be having Super Mods in the scum chat, for I'd be raising enough hell about their kill priority to resemble Rion vs Marvel in scum chats.
 

Pot Goblin

Heisenbunny
Vote lynch Midnight
Middy on Page 10, in fact this was her 2nd post

Idk y the AM wagon built up so much? He seemed fine?? Didn't see any case on him either
Vote lynch Reloaded
Voted Reloaded because the Alwaysmind wagon built up quickly

I am so dead, just got all my wisdom teeth removed catded

Think I feel ok abt this
Vote lynch Kiku
Voted for Kiku while Pein was the leading wagon at 4

Vote lynch Joygirl

Honestly could see her be the one behind ekko being silenced
The fact that she is against the idea of thinking silencing is a scum ability and scum reads ppl for coming to that assumption is really sus
Plus she kept saying kiku is being framed but has failed to prove how in any way
Voted JG as she thought she was behind silencing Ekko and thought the silence was a scum ability
Also stated she failed to prove Kiku was framed.

lets break down polar's "mega case" on me


anyone who has experience with t-pein can attest to this
hes said it several times^


its not scummy when i did find a direct contradiction
u can say its scummy if i try to make a case for other reasons but i literally found a 100% lie from @Polar Bear lol


i dont see the problem with this, if he is town in the end im telling him to remove u who i think is scum


agn, explaining how polar lied bc fuji asked


it is quite different
lying about reads is 1 thing bc u can see how other ppl respond plus reads change so its more justifiable
ability usage lies, esp lying abt being vanilla or not, is done primarily by scum


i dont see any issue with this post and idk y u quoted it
i feel like u r just trying to quote as much stuff as possible


given that u directly lied, i felt more comfortable abt u being scum plus the net loss was smaller
lynch u and lose up to 1 town worst case (best case scum which i believed)
lynch t-pein and lose up to 2 town worst case (if u flipped scum first and then we did a t-pein lynch, even if he were town, it would be less likely he take out town bc kiku would be semi-cleared in this scenario)


he was stubborn and i didnt care for it since it seemed like he was against killing u cuz u were his scummate


cuz t-pein wasnt being lynched and midnight claimed using something on him dp1?? how is this related to anything


y would i be opposed to lynching someone else i scum read when the current lynch is simply not working and going towards no lynch?


wasnt around eod for dp1, dont exactly remember everything
but afterwards i said it was likely he was probs bussed anyway
Vote lynch Polar bear
Made a case on Polar

For the sake of transparency at the risk of getting me killed I also am vanilla until someone dies

But for me I get the role of the first Hero with Powers who dies(what exactly constitutes as Powers is unknown to me at this time but AlwaysMind's 2x vote power didn't count)
This feels like it's just gravedigger lol
Vote lynch Kiku
Voted Kiku for their claim sayin it was a gravedigger.

Today I'd be fine voting u, kiku, and reloaded
Tbh wouldn't mind rhea lynch either, she seems to be ready to spread weird theories around too
JG voted her back and Hime said this

Vote lynch Reloaded
Voted for Reloaded when Pein was the leading wagon once again.

ugh
Vote lynch Polar
Voted Polar when Pein was the main lynch

whatever, t-pein probs just scum with polar atp
Vote lynch T-Pein
Voted Pein after fooj called her out

Vote lynch T-Pein
Voted Pein again after the button was pushed which let people vote normally

Vote lynch Midnight
Don't mind this, but at the same time both options fit here so someone needs to start talking

Vote Pero
Voted middy when Pero asked her to pressure him which lead to his mason claim
It's worth pointing out that Orca voted Pero here to pressure his claim instead

Voted me here lmao idk why

Vote lynch Pero

Midnight should be asleep, stop stalling
Voted Pero

Vote lynch Pero
Just in case
Voted Pero again

it wont count, if 2 ppl can unvote that would help
Vote lynch Mono
Voted Mono

oh wtf
Vote lynch Mono
Voted Mono again after the time warp

@Dr. Watson
 

Pot Goblin

Heisenbunny
Rej Town read was more a gut read from his play on Saturday and Sunday, he was more active from what I read, questioning etc. Didn't feel like Scum Rej to me.

Fang can't read me well and I can't read Fang well, so I scum read him a lot more than I should lol.

Tbh if I was scum, I would have used the Lie Detect on just the Hime as Big Boss is indie line, instead of trying to reveal all of it, and using it on you, if I even bothered to mention I had a lie detector in the thread. What likely would have happened is Hime would have asked me to Lie Detect something in the Scum chat, and Town would never know what I actually got as I'd claim another item. Or likely just ignore any posts asking what Item I got.

And again, Polar Bear wouldn't have been who was killed, when you're openly Solid Snake. If I was scum we'd be having Super Mods in the scum chat, for I'd be raising enough hell about their kill priority to resemble Rion vs Marvel in scum chats.
I do think a point in your favor is that you didn't even need to claim a lie detect at all
Would've been very easy to lie about what you got
 
Here are the claims
Pay attention to the below posts taking the claims under consideration:
For those in the know. Its posts like this that make me highly suspect reloaded
I'm starting to think it's straight up unbalanced lmao

or our coats is hime's wincon
Except Polar who is town via mechs and Watson town read I have to think at everyone else. Hime's indy claim makes sense (emotion showed for SRs looked genuine)

I feel that VC12 of D1 who had Pero with a wagon of 5 votes iirc is a good start to analyze the living players in the old mafia way. Glad we have a scum flip there now.

Flavour solving is meh fmpov and gives scum the chance to escape

No hammer please, I want to play tomorrow, now is 11:30 pm and I have to sleep
Michelle's last statement implies she's encouraging solving and wants a chance to give input later.

Well then [Vote Lynch Reloaded]
RA's vote - I noticed this secondary wagon didn't gain traction, I need to ISO that separately.
Mono [4] - Orca, Pot Goblin, Reloaded, Indigo
Reloaded [1] - Random Asshole
7 Votes Hammer
Well, look what we have here

That's exactly what's got me concerned
And we have this

I see I am the wagon today :feelsokeman:


I am town. And all I can do is blame my exceptionally terrible game for this whole travesty.


Anyway, I could claim. But it will probably only make it more complicated.


If y'all want me to claim, say so.

Do not hammer early. :pepebuggy:
Parroting Michelle, seems town are more likely to want to not hammer early.
Role fishing
No.

I gotta say reloaded, if you rolled scum. Kudos.
Yoru on his ass
What do you mean by this?
:choppawhat:
You just keep looking more scummy with each post lmao
Rip Yoru
Then you're gonna really like my claim :pepebuggy:
Minor role fishing, I give it a pass because yet again Reloaded comes across as worse than what I think you might be doing and there's proof just from his posts and other's calling out a potential agenda
Holly White [Hero aligned]


I only have a passive.

The bomb - the person who hammers me will die from the bomb attached to my chest.



Anyway, make a consensus for the person who should hammer me and make them do it.

If I'm scum, my claim should be complete bogus as T pein already had a very similar ability.
So no risk in making the person who the thread feels is scum hammer me.

If I'm town, I'm just saying the truth.

I know that's wifom. But it's the truth.



It's up to y'all to decide.


I assure you that I'm town. So please think for like 5 minutes before a towny decides to hammer me. That's probably game over for town.

I have no desire to get out of my lynch atp. So don't jump into the first conclusion that comes into your mind and think "he wants to avoid his lynch so he's threatening us with a bomb".

Surely the host would have provided me with a better claim than a recycled role of Tpein? (Again wifom but :kayneshrug: )

So, discuss and reach a consensus for the person who will get the honor of hammering me.


:joker:
Yoru made a good point, I shat the bed on that one, sorry
Rej - Afk/low activity. Same as wci game where he was scum.

Orca - what have they done actually? Can't say anything stands out. Same as me tbh. Maybe I'm missing whatever they have done. But seems cwac.


RA - again super low activity. Has done nothing.


Indigo - I sussed conq at the start because of his reactions towards a joke I made about him being inactiscum. But then he subbed out. Indigo has been forthcoming so far. But there can't be that many vanilla roles as many of you have also noted.


Reloaded - maybe I was wrong about him. Mayhe he is the mastermind of the scum team. Maybe all his fluff and gifs until this game all lead to the reveal he was always a 4d chess level player. Pure paranoid read tbh.



My thoughts should be irrelevant actually. I haven't paid attention to the game at all evident by my LVP level play.

And if you think you're gonna get any hints/info regarding my scum mates from my scum read by analyzing who I distance and stuff like that
in the chance that I'm scum, you wouldn't. Cause I'm town.
Indeed
DAY FIVE VOTE COUNT #2

MonochromeYoru [4] - The Orca, Pot Goblin, Mr. Reloaded, Indigo
Mr. Reloaded [1] - Random Asshole


With twelve alive - seven votes are required for a lynch to occur.

Countdown Timer – Countdown to 5 Sep 2023 01:00 in London, England (timeanddate.com)
Majorly significant here

Do you sound like someone who hasn't read or paid attention lmao
Yeah i read the eod mostly?

I didn't read most of the rest of the thread and skimmed lol. You can check my level of activity and see for yourself.


Is this cause I have you as scum? Come on you guys are winning this. So no need to shade :kriwhat:
Yoru perceiving Orca's comment as shame, dunno, don't disagree or agree
Or maybe make one of Reloaded or Indigo do it. Maybe town gets an ability for a vanilla role from that.
I'm actually glad in hindsight Indigo sacrificed himself in the end - it's ironically helped clear some things up
Top of the list would be

Rej
Reloaded
Polar's reads, think scum started shaking in their boots assuming his read was very close

Which reminds me - I also want to go and see what exactly happened with the hime lynch and everyone's exchanges, I'll do that in a few
Lore wise this sounds like a scum passive and something the people aligned with The Patriots did against Big Boss/Naked Snake and Miller + the Diamond Dogs.
Spec that needs to be taken under consideration now
Incorrect, it's the opposite. I'm having trouble with Reloaded's.

Do you need me to explain why I'm vouching for your towniness and why I think you're not pulling one over on us?
why the hell would a towny have an ability like that?
Incorrect assumption, because I suppose this would be explained by Your essentially being Pein's counterpart. An extra note: many of us thought Orwellian's ability was far too OP as scum and Town, but there were restrictions in place by making the wagon burn a 2x.
I don't have the patience nor the ability to convince townies that I am town. It's only over for town if a towny hammers me and town loses two players at once.

If town can manage to make a scum read hammer me, town is still in the game.


So you think scum had basically two roles that can take a towny with them when they get lynched?

I was being memey cause I was laughing at my own incompetence.

I was only delaying the claim cause I was contemplating whether to claim this at all or not.

If I didn't claim, there was a chance that scum would have hammered me. But there was a greater chance that town would do it. So, I decided to claim in the end.




Take this as omgus or whatever you will, but.

Your play this game reminded me of "the melkor" Play the vets here mention often.

Basically, opposing/questioning stuff that would get you a town lean.

Like,

Inviting attention towards the fact that one of the coats flipping shouldn't Confirm the rest of you

Or offering yourself up as a sacrifice

Etc...


Just a gut feeling but those seem like attempts at getting towny points by putting the sus or danger up on yourself. That seems like a classic scum tactic from what I understand.


You could be genuine with it too. But that's how I feel.

If you think my ability is real but I'm scum, I think the hammer should be either you or Rej atp.
More of Yoru's thoughts
Wifoming a bit here but I could see this as T-Pein's fake claim that was saves for later as if he had claimed it he would've been lynched even harder than if he simply claimed vig
Poranoia
Could you potentially do the noble thing for town and set yourself up to get incinerated by Mono's potential bomb?
:endthis:
If it comes to that, I will do what I must :endthis:
Spoiler alert: he did not, he essentially allowed Pot to eat the bomb. Bad boy.
We should lynch regardless
Weird focus imo, whatever
Read my claim and tell us your thoughts on it.

Who do you think should hammer me?
Wondering if the cautious play should be Mono hammering himself
Good insight ngl, although there's some things that make Orca look less good - I wanna see if Pot is on the same wavelength here in regards to this first tho, then I can elaborate
Damn

i completely forgot that voting for yourself is a part of the game

and even detailed so in the game's opening post

absolute genius level insight
Yourself of course
Etc
I'm taking notes for this type of statement - it's not enough to add to any argument against you because it's semantic cherrypicking at its finest, it's just food for thought. I'm only really side eyeing this because that's a strong emphasis that you went out of your way to to draw attention to.
"It's the least I can do" suggests genuine intention, whereas stating this along with your alignmet does not really seem to suggest noble intent at all.

I may be dead wrong, so this can't really be a point against you by itself. Thinking out loud and writing down a mental note if I am for future games.
Previous ping
Wasn't sure where we were at with the votes.

Incredibly interesting.
VC above was quoted. Still interesting.
Pein's vote on Orwellian doesn't look partner-y, I like Random's vote, the explanation is logical from a low poster.

Note that I also coloured Bear in green as mech cleared and Watson in blue as my own TR, also Hime in violet in the VC 12 (forgot about the indies in the last one )

Back to work, brb asap
Imo, good point with viewing it through the lens of someone that's low activity and struggles to keep up. Yoru struggled with this himself.
MonochromeYoru [5] - The Orca, Pot Goblin, Mr. Reloaded, Indigo, Orwellian
Mr. Reloaded [1] - Random Asshole
Back to Yoru's lynch here (out of order, sorry)
 
Rej Town read was more a gut read from his play on Saturday and Sunday, he was more active from what I read, questioning etc. Didn't feel like Scum Rej to me.

Fang can't read me well and I can't read Fang well, so I scum read him a lot more than I should lol.

Tbh if I was scum, I would have used the Lie Detect on just the Hime as Big Boss is indie line, instead of trying to reveal all of it, and using it on you, if I even bothered to mention I had a lie detector in the thread. What likely would have happened is Hime would have asked me to Lie Detect something in the Scum chat, and Town would never know what I actually got as I'd claim another item. Or likely just ignore any posts asking what Item I got.

And again, Polar Bear wouldn't have been who was killed, when you're openly Solid Snake. If I was scum we'd be having Super Mods in the scum chat, for I'd be raising enough hell about their kill priority to resemble Rion vs Marvel in scum chats.
Gotta say, I don't like you assuming such precise scum tactics with these scenarios in mind, but that's fair

Can you explain the PB thing, sorry, I'm stupid
 
Middy on Page 10, in fact this was her 2nd post



Voted Reloaded because the Alwaysmind wagon built up quickly


Voted for Kiku while Pein was the leading wagon at 4


Voted JG as she thought she was behind silencing Ekko and thought the silence was a scum ability
Also stated she failed to prove Kiku was framed.



Made a case on Polar




Voted Kiku for their claim sayin it was a gravedigger.


JG voted her back and Hime said this


Voted for Reloaded when Pein was the leading wagon once again.


Voted Polar when Pein was the main lynch



Voted Pein after fooj called her out


Voted Pein again after the button was pushed which let people vote normally



Voted middy when Pero asked her to pressure him which lead to his mason claim
It's worth pointing out that Orca voted Pero here to pressure his claim instead


Voted me here lmao idk why


Voted Pero


Voted Pero again


Voted Mono


Voted Mono again after the time warp

@Dr. Watson
Now let's put this in the context of Reloaded maybe being her scummate - how's he starting to look now iyo?

Btw, I forget, when she placed her vote on JG, was JG faction killed that night?
 
So:
-distanced from Pero (scum)
-bussed T (scum)
-voted away from the main wagon via Reloaded (unknown)
-pushed wagon on Yoru (town)

Did she push Reloaded in particular; was there any explanation for her vote on her part?
 

Pot Goblin

Heisenbunny
Good insight ngl, although there's some things that make Orca look less good - I wanna see if Pot is on the same wavelength here in regards to this first tho, then I can elaborate
Is this because it was after Reloaded offered himself to be the detonator to the bomb
From what I gather from that post is that Reloaded and Orca might be the path correct?

From those VCs you posted they voted first as well so they were safe from the bomb
 
Reading your previous post, will answer in a bit


She placed that vote on D2, N2 is when fooj died. N3 is when JG died
So this means her quarrels with flipped town have motive for her team and her to send a faction kill on them, which means they were too close and right on the money.
They went after the stronger players first, I see.

If you recall (or if anyone does) - this is what I mean when I talk about motive when it comes to faction kills. There's definite motive there, we just have to find out specifically why imo, and see what makes the most sense.
(Questions like: was the scumteam trying to weaken town? Was JG, Kiki, and Fuji close to not only her but her scummates? And so on)
 

Pot Goblin

Heisenbunny
So:
-distanced from Pero (scum)
-bussed T (scum)
-voted away from the main wagon via Reloaded (unknown)
-pushed wagon on Yoru (town)

Did she push Reloaded in particular; was there any explanation for her vote on her part?
Seems like it was because Alwaysmind was becoming the main lynch and she didn't want to vote there
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top