Who will be the Next Strawhat?


  • Total voters
    509
The straw hats did not go out to sea to become pirates, they went to live their Dreams. I doubt they’re staying together after their dreams are accomplished.

The straw hats disbanding doesn’t mean they’ll no longer be nakama. They’ll always be there to help one another out; but they aren’t going to live together on that ship and a two straw hats dreams kinda show us that.

1. Brooks dream is to return to Laboon, no way is Brook returning to him then saying bye again forever.

2. Sanji discovered the all blue because it’s a chefs dream to cook there. Why would he discover it then abandon it?

So towards your four points:
1. You don’t need to live with your family to still have one. You can move on with your life and still be connected. Look at the true ending of persona 5 royal as it has the same message of found family but living your own life.

2. Oda will find a way to complete namis dream before the story ends. That’s not going to be some post story detail.

3. Luffy can be free even without being carried by the crew cause the entire world will have his back by EOS he’ll be able to go anywhere because he’ll be happily accepted anywhere. He doesn’t need the Straw hats to stay together.

4. The crew wouldn’t be sent away rather they’ll live their life. They’ll move on but still be nakama.
Yeah, that's a possible interpretation, but being with the strawhats is much more important to characters like Robin Brook and Chopper than you're implying. Brook can see Laboon frequently just fine. The strawhats are still his found family. And how exactly does Nami's dream get completed before the final war? You can say "Oda will find a way" all you want, but it's actually impossible. How about a theory as to how that could work? And still I would ask, why would Luffy disband them? He's always going to want more adventures. You'll need to explain why Luffy would ever prefer to travel alone instead of with his crew to convince me.
 
Yeah, that's a possible interpretation, but being with the strawhats is much more important to characters like Robin Brook and Chopper than you're implying. Brook can see Laboon frequently just fine. The strawhats are still his found family. And how exactly does Nami's dream get completed before the final war? You can say "Oda will find a way" all you want, but it's actually impossible. How about a theory as to how that could work? And still I would ask, why would Luffy disband them? He's always going to want more adventures. You'll need to explain why Luffy would ever prefer to travel alone instead of with his crew to convince me.
The question is, will Luffy be alive at the end of the serie ?
 
Yeah, that's a possible interpretation, but being with the strawhats is much more important to characters like Robin Brook and Chopper than you're implying. Brook can see Laboon frequently just fine. The strawhats are still his found family. And how exactly does Nami's dream get completed before the final war? You can say "Oda will find a way" all you want, but it's actually impossible. How about a theory as to how that could work? And still I would ask, why would Luffy disband them? He's always going to want more adventures. You'll need to explain why Luffy would ever prefer to travel alone instead of with his crew to convince me.
The straw hats are a Found family but family doesn’t always live together.

And namis dream is to see the world with her own eyes and draw a map. I actually have a theory on this. Skypeia tells us how this could happen as Nami flew luffy up to the ark Maxim to fight god. This may very well happen on the world stage where Nami flies luffy up high in the sky atop Zeus to fight imu on his own flying death machine. This way Nami can physically see the entire world and map it while luffy fights imu giving resolution to her dream as well.

And luffy May not disband Them; but they could leave after accomplishing their dreams they all move in to fully live the life their dream gives them.
 
The straw hats are a Found family but family doesn’t always live together.

And namis dream is to see the world with her own eyes and draw a map. I actually have a theory on this. Skypeia tells us how this could happen as Nami flew luffy up to the ark Maxim to fight god. This may very well happen on the world stage where Nami flies luffy up high in the sky atop Zeus to fight imu on his own flying death machine. This way Nami can physically see the entire world and map it while luffy fights imu giving resolution to her dream as well.

And luffy May not disband Them; but they could leave after accomplishing their dreams they all move in to fully live the life their dream gives them.
Nami makes detailed sea charts. She's not seeing all that from that high up. Also, you are aware that the earth is round, yes? You can't see the whole thing no matter how far up you go.

Again, there needs to be a reason for them to leave. They're all happy on the Sunny. Just because they acomplished their dream doesn't mean they have to quit the crew.
 

Akai2

🆉🅾🆁🅾 🆃🅾🅾 🆂🆃🆁🅾🅽🅺!
It won't be a waifu. It will be slimy swampy man.
LOL Carrot bros are hoping she's hiding in the swamp.....you're telling me there's a chance?! :pepecopium:
B-but....I want SHP to have one more waifu :josad:
Me too. We're long overdue for a new female SH.
I think one of those two, Lilith, or Law. There's reasons to believe in all 4 of them. I haven't settled on one candidate to fully invest in yet.
I'm unsure on Lilith. She's cool but she's a part of the Punk group. I don't really see them separated. I think Bonney and Stussy are really good choices. But I think it's gonna be hard adding anyone to the main crew this late into the story.
 
LOL Carrot bros are hoping she's hiding in the swamp.....you're telling me there's a chance?! :pepecopium:

Me too. We're long overdue for a new female SH.

I'm unsure on Lilith. She's cool but she's a part of the Punk group. I don't really see them separated. I think Bonney and Stussy are really good choices. But I think it's gonna be hard adding anyone to the main crew this late into the story.
1) Bonney will go to the RA, now that she know all the truth about kuma and his reasons to be one of the founders of RA

2) Stussy doesnt give a shit to the strawhats and she has 0 interactions with luffy. She will just follow Vegapunk to protect him wherever he goes

3) I dont have much idea about Lilith, but I guess she (and york) will be the only survivor btw the satellites after egg head
 
Last edited:

Akai2

🆉🅾🆁🅾 🆃🅾🅾 🆂🆃🆁🅾🅽🅺!
1) Bonney will go to the RA. Now that she know all the truth about kuma and his reasons to be one of the founders of RA

2) Stussy dont give a shit to the strawhats and she has 0 interactions with luffy. She will just follow Vegapunk to protect him wherever he goes

3) I dont have much idea about Lilith, but I guess she (and york) will be the only survivor btw the satellites after egg head
Depending on how it develops with Kuma's arc, I see a scenario where Bonney would rather join the SHs to go to Laugh Tale. He's hinted to be connected to the special race. As for Stussy, we don't know much about her backstory yet. I always say Oda can make whoever he wants join the crew as long as he provides proper motivation from their past.
 
Depending on how it develops with Kuma's arc, I see a scenario where Bonney would rather join the SHs to go to Laugh Tale. He's hinted to be connected to the special race. As for Stussy, we don't know much about her backstory yet. I always say Oda can make whoever he wants join the crew as long as he provides proper motivation from their past.
The only chance of bonney be a strawhat is if kuma backstory is connected with nika stuff (and I think that this connection exist)

I thought stussy would have an interesting development after her revelation. But after chapter 1074, she has almost 0 focus. Unfortunately I dont have more hope of oda develop her
 
LOL Carrot bros are hoping she's hiding in the swamp.....you're telling me there's a chance?! :pepecopium:

Me too. We're long overdue for a new female SH.

I'm unsure on Lilith. She's cool but she's a part of the Punk group. I don't really see them separated. I think Bonney and Stussy are really good choices. But I think it's gonna be hard adding anyone to the main crew this late into the story.
The reason I have Lilith on the list is because I think the dream to find the eternal energy source is the most important thing for the next nakama. Lilith was the first one to mention that dream, and she's been talking about being excited to leave because she's never been away from Egghead.
 
Top