Who receives the official MVP?


  • Total voters
    15
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Is that one of the quotes that stood out to you most?

Who do you read as town ATM?
@Michelle

You thinking what I'm thinking?

Also
Would Ultra name his teammates to distance or would he just throw town under the bus to make them look bad iyo
If you think as scum I decide to fake claim something that's flagrantly designed to fail to confirm something then that's on you, too. It's a poor reas of my ethos as scum - I stick close to the truth because that enables me to "confirm" my role easier without actually doing so. The janitor part is a demerit that prevents me from being confirmed upon my revival.

I've already gone over why I shot Orwellian. If it were because I was "questioned" then you're going to have to explain why you and Al are not dead too. Your survival should indicate to you that it has nothing to do with that, I shot him because I believed he had plausible scum equity with Ultra, and I felt that in the event he was town, he would not be very helpful in solving the game due to his tendency to argue in bad faith/lie to backfill his reasoning. You can disagree but whether you agree or disagree is not the point - it's whether you think it's a genuine process of thought from me or not.

As for the last point, you simultaneously argue that my role looks fake, but also it's too strong. I think that makes my argument for me, the lack of credibility the claim has evidences why it oans out for a town role.

I don't expect any of this to change your mind to be honest. It's probably more productive if you ask me about specific players so I can go over them tomorrow, otherwise you already know where I'm at positionally with the game so there isn't really much more input for me to offer.
i mean, pairing polar with orca but rather going for orca could be attempt to distance himself

i'm too tired for that tbh


Kiku
T-Pein
Hayumi/Charlie
Sallucion/Al Sama

CakeWalker

Nibel/Red Night

Indigo
Naomi
Luka
Fujishiro/Doc Watson


Mr. Reloaded
Ratchet


Seatonnes
Michelle

Polar Bear
Kinda wanna see what it does to me when playing Mafia while simultaneously doing productive shit

Mad science experiment or no?
T-Pein is solid this game. This is the first time in my mafia career that I'd vouch for T-Pein
just lynch me already, end this suffering
scum team already won this
Feels a bit OTT. Game isn't over.
@Nibel Heal Mr Reloaded. No excuses.
Do we really have a chance though?

we got townies killed left and right

and we're jumping between wagons like headless chicken

unless Seatonnes shows up with some good ass info

we're about to mislynch, lose Reloaded to poison, and then two more kills during the NP
Huh, forgot to add my quotes. It was in response to Charlie saying T Pein was inactive and Polar putting T Pein as scum
HARD TOWN
CakeWalker
Flower [DEAD - FLIPPED TOWN]
T-Pein [formerly - SOFT TOWN]
Orwellian [DEAD - FLIPPED TOWN]
The Orca [DEAD - FLIPPED FOWN]



SOFT TOWN
Alwaysmind [DEAD - FLIPPED TOWN]
Ultra [DEAD - FLIPPED SCUM]
Charlie
Seatonnes [formerly - NEUTRAL]
Naomi [formerly - SCUM POTENTIAL]
Kiku [formerly - NEUTRAL]

HeWhoHasNoEqual [DEAD - FLIPPED TOWN]


NEUTRAL
MangoSenpai [DEAD - FLIPPED TOWN]
Dr. Watson [Replaced D1]
Al Sama
Mr. Reloaded [formerly - SCUM Potential]
Ratchet [formerly - NEUTRAL]
Indigo [formerly - HARD TOWN]


SCUM POTENTIAL
Luka [formerly - NEUTRAL]
Michelle [formerly - NEUTRAL]
Polar Bear [formerly - SOFT TOWN]


ANTI TOWN INDIE
Nibel [formerly - NEUTRAL]

HARD SCUM
Ekkologix [DEAD - FLIPPED TOWN]
wait...can survivor have healing abilities???
Yeah I got the biggest set of balls on me. So in your feeling i bussed ultra hard on d1 and then offed Orca n1, where and how do you rectify the pure stupidity in that play?
would still rather chuck Luka off a bridge that Polar though atm

VOTE: LUKA
We should probably look into what Flower was cooking tho.
She was sus af so killing her before the bodyguard, the cop, the blocker, the "vig" is strange.
I think i was Flower's biggest scum read

I also read Flower as scum
You already know you can't put me into town generalities lol and thats why I like being on the outside looking at all the conforming drones bumbling away
if Polar isn't mafia, they will follow me in lynching Luka.
if im wrong about Luka - then i can deal with it.
Votes:
Michelle > Cakewalker > Ratchet > Charlie
Naomi > Cakewalker > Ratchet
Mr. Reloaded > Cakewalker > -
Cakewalker > Indigo > - > Polar Bear > Luka
Indigo > Cakewalker > Naomi > Polar Bear > Charlie
AL Sama > Ratchet
Luka > Kiku
Ratchet > Polar Bear
T-Pein > Indigo

Votecount:
Ratchet: 2
Charlie: 2
Kiku: 1
Polar Bear: 1
Luka: 1
Indigo: 1
Kiku vanilla-??
Hayumi [@Charlie] [Replaced D3] body guard
T-Pein™ not claimed
Naomi vanilla start-vig
Ratchet vig/self janitor if killed.
Mr. Reloaded -poisoned
Fujishiro @Dr. Watson [Replaced D1] miller claim
Red Night-survivor/healer
Polar Bear not claimed
CakeWalker refiller
Seatonnes invest

Indigo
Luka

Michelle not claimed
Sallucion @AL sama [Replaced D3] not claimed.
I'm a roleblocker, i can roleblock one person every night

I roleblocked CakeWalker, HWHNE and Nibel
update

Kiku vanilla-??
Hayumi [@Charlie] [Replaced D3] body guard

T-Pein™ triple voter
Naomi vanilla start-vig
Ratchet vig/self janitor if killed.
Mr. Reloaded -poisoned
Fujishiro Dr. Watson [Replaced D1] miller claim
Red Night-survivor/healer
Polar Bear not claimed
CakeWalker refiller
Seatonnes invest
Indigo-role blocker

Luka -not claimed, said invest but maybe trolling.
Michelle not claimed
Sallucion AL sama [Replaced D3] not claimed
Kiku/Red Night/Polar Bear/Luka/Charlie

There is my solve I think, I'm struggling to find anyone else as hard scum given their play.
CakeWalker
T-Pein
Naomi
Polar
Kiku

Scum is here

Nibel is indie anti-town

This is my legacy
I really doubt scum would have an ability like that and it be more than a one shot. That gives them a hell of a lot of lynch control, I could only really justify that if the scum team is quite small maybe but I don't really see it - it's very swingy design.

If there is any scum I've missed it's probably CakeWalker, so I should revise my PoE as follows

Kiku/Charlie/Polar/Luka/CakeWalker/Red Night
hmm something like this

luka
polar
cake
nibel
watson/you

no particular order

also I m not insulting your play
alright
i investigated luka, it failed
this is just the most disappointing shit ever
:josad:
@Ratchet @Naomi @Michelle don't you think tonnes's results are too convenient??
@Indigo's Lament flower tracked kiku and she didn't visit N1 anyone right??

I doubt mafia has goons so kiku got blocked or abstained, she isn't mafia at the very least
Seatonnes usage on Luka confuses me - like if I was cop I would check Luka. But at no point did he even vote Luka.
Also Cop and Tracker.

You hook Tracker and Kill Cop.
You dont hook cop and kill tracker
we are at day 4 now. they went for tracker over invest? :suresure:
if mafia have a strongman - you just strongman the cop.
that what it looked like

heals
hide
surivor


even vig role sounds op that ratchet has

sounds like made up lies.

but it does look like scum grave robbed ekko ability or scum poisoner poison reload. never seen reloaded like as town.
fixed-----Never seen reloaded lie as town
T-Pein
Michelle - Lynched ultra
Hayumi/Charlie - Bodyguard
Fujishiro/Doc Watson - Miller

Seatonnes - Cop
Naomi - Vig
CakeWalker - ??
Kiku - ??

Luka - ??
Sallucion/Al Sama - ??

Polar Bear - ??
Mr. Reloaded - ??
Indigo - Roleblock

Nibel/Red Night - Broken survivor
Ratchet - Weird reviving killer



Mainly mech clearing but seems legit to me anyways.
Roleblock seems scummy.
mich could be deep wolfing I doubt it tho

btw what has luka done so far??
you were scum leaning me a while ago

so what changed your mind??
Naomi, Polar Bear, T-Pein and Kiku

:beckmoji:

found you
cant have been impactful enough to rmember
Lurka
Cake

Starting to have doubts about Indigo too :josad:
T-Pein
Michelle - Lynched ultra
Hayumi/Charlie - Bodyguard
Fujishiro/Doc Watson - Miller

Seatonnes - Cop
Naomi - Vig
CakeWalker - Refiller
Kiku - ??

Luka - ??
Sallucion/Al Sama - ??

Polar Bear - ??
Mr. Reloaded - ??
Indigo - Roleblock

Nibel/Red Night - Broken survivor
Ratchet - Weird reviving killer



Mainly mech clearing but seems legit to me anyways.
Roleblock seems scummy.


oh yeah cake claims to have refilled indigo....
I have been very loud from the moment I subbed in tho
remember why i was scum reading you for whatever it was
so you refilled indigo because you thought mafia was gonna kill the cop, doc and tracker?
i assumed they would kill on of those three, but RBer wouldn't be touched. And even if RBer was blocked, they would see an extra usage being given
While I am loath to abide your inability to read what is clearly obvious odd behavior from her throughout just about every single day phase, I will graciously deign to provide you with specifics

...later, because I'm too busy for that right now. For now you'll just have to wait in rapt anticipation
Votes:
Michelle > Cakewalker > Ratchet > Charlie
Naomi > Cakewalker > Ratchet
Mr. Reloaded > Cakewalker > -
Cakewalker > Indigo > - > Polar Bear > Luka
Indigo > Cakewalker > Naomi > Polar Bear > Charlie > T-Pein > Kiku > Luka
AL Sama > Ratchet
Luka > Kiku
Ratchet > Polar Bear > Kiku
T-Pein > Indigo
Seatonnes > Indigo

Votecount:
Indigo: 2
Kiku: 2
Ratchet: 2
Luka: 2
Charlie: 1
After rereading her posts I have decided to table my suspicion of Cake for today, because
1. Idk I like her more recent thoughts more and
2. Refiller is a potentially provable role


So instead I say we go for... uh... idk yet. I'll figure something out
@Dr. Watson if Ultra played only in antispew, then it can go both ways for both Luka and Polar. The votes are more important in this case, however when he knew he will be afk he could ask for bussing in scum chat and then even the voters are hard to parse

@AL sama the results of the first nights are convenient, the last one is dissapointing.

cop got blocked.
Town and scum never have the same role
he is scum.
simple.
I have a theory that Seatonnes wasn't blocked but Luka has immunity from scans or was jailed

Kiku has a track record of proven scum hunting, even when wrong does it logically. I understand why I might be scum read, and they haven't done what Ekko did - by creating some false meta bs.
Stop shading dead townies please. Ekko shared his view on your play, he didn't meant any harm.
 
Hi, up to page 290

Before you do, who did you supposedly protect bc 2 died and reloaded is claiming to be poisoned. Not liking Hayumi/you and your claim/execution
Seastones. I'm 99% sure he wasn't attacked. It was 2-shot so i'm vanilla until i unlock tao form.

Claimed vanilla right? Should have been able to "level up" by now. Seems like a big lie imo. Easy to fake by just doing nothing lol.
I haven't leveled up either. There's 63% chance you'll unlock it D4, so it's not that weird. 89% for next DP do i'm hopeful.

Huh, forgot to add my quotes. It was in response to Charlie saying T Pein was inactive and Polar putting T Pein as scum
He was when i subbed in. Kiku was there to talk with me. I like Pein this DP though. Cutting people from making wrong assumptions, clearing things up and stuff.

We should be trying to lynch scum and not the SK today.
That's actually a good point. Even if Ratchet is SK, he'd scum problem rn.

I'm still worried about his claim of being unlimited RBer.

Kiku giving me very similar vibes to Mario. Charlie I have no idea (is Charlies Charles101?)
@Ratchet @Naomi @Michelle don't you think tonnes's results are too convenient??
 
seatone not even rb, or killed.. just like the vig who revives.....:gonope:
How do you know he wasn't blocked? His action failed. That would be either rb of some kind or Luca being immune.

for real, can you guys flip me?

i can't self vote this game

and i wanna see the reactions to my flip
If you're town, god damn indigo. How many games we've had with townies dying on purpose to shettalk in dead chat?

and i'm being called scum since D1
I'm called scum before i posted.

cop got blocked.
Town and scum never have the same role
he is scum.
simple.
To be fair, Luca could be immune. Or Seastones was rolecrushed.

There was a reason why i was gonna be the Votecounter / Spectator

but wanted to help Rej get more players, so joined, there was a slowdown with sign ups
You're making me feel bad ._.

so basically scum is eating dead people soup, and getting there abilities?


Welp, could be. Ekko died N2 and there's poison N3. Maybe they get one-shots of people they killed.
 
Good morning!

I don't believe these people filling the game with gifs, and Kiku backtracking from the scum read on Cake without giving any other read.
I will answer at pings first
If I read back and I find myself changing my mind it is only natural that I need time to reexamine the way I am viewing other reads as well
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top