[FNZ] Role Madness Hell's Paradise Mafia #1 [Game Ended - Mafia + Survivor Win]

[Ratchet]

Luka/Polar/Cake/???

 

[Michelle]

I have a theory.
If we (by miracle) kill all mafia there will be a serial who inherits the factional kill from them. There may be multiple seials (2?) , but they don't have (yet) killing power

This doesn't mean we shouldn't kill mafia. But if that's true then the serial(s) have also survivor powers which fits with Luka's game play and fail of actions.

I still think we should kill Cake and Polar first.

What's everyone's opinion on this?

 

[Ratchet]

I have a theory.
If we (by miracle) kill all mafia there will be a serial who inherits the factional kill from them. There may be multiple seials (2?) , but they don't have (yet) killing power

This doesn't mean we shouldn't kill mafia. But if that's true then the serial(s) have also survivor powers which fits with Luka's game play and fail of actions.

I still think we should kill Cake and Polar first.

What's everyone's opinion on this?

I can't make a team of Mafia that's plausible without Luka.

 

[Michelle]

I can't make a team of Mafia that's plausible without Luka.

Makes sense, however yday we had Kiku on scum reads and we were wrong and we couldn't take her out of the Poe.
I think we can talk more about the Poe, with arguments.

 

[Charlie]

She was caught lying about host info to try and shade me...
That plus refusing to actually refill anyone all game.
She aint gonna flip town.

Implying she was a Refiller to begin with.
Unless she has been refilling scum.
Trying to refill someone with unlimited shots and then trying to refill a passive.

:laughmoji:

I could see Rej's comment as him being mad for being bringed up in discussion, regardless of what he did or didn't say. It's just "don't use me in arguments" imo. Just a side note.

About what?

Refill Gate.

 

[Red Night]

I have a theory.
If we (by miracle) kill all mafia there will be a serial who inherits the factional kill from them. There may be multiple seials (2?) , but they don't have (yet) killing power

This doesn't mean we shouldn't kill mafia. But if that's true then the serial(s) have also survivor powers which fits with Luka's game play and fail of actions.

I still think we should kill Cake and Polar first.

What's everyone's opinion on this?

2 serials? There is already me as a survivor.

 

[Charlie]

I have a theory.
If we (by miracle) kill all mafia there will be a serial who inherits the factional kill from them. There may be multiple seials (2?) , but they don't have (yet) killing power

This doesn't mean we shouldn't kill mafia. But if that's true then the serial(s) have also survivor powers which fits with Luka's game play and fail of actions.

I still think we should kill Cake and Polar first.

What's everyone's opinion on this?

Tbh serial should have kills anyway and if they're not dumb they should just go for mafia before they reach majority.

I could see Cake and Polar being team tbh. Cake being team with Luka just doesn't work for me. Unless "real" vote count on Kiku last dp was higher/on Luka was lower for some reason and Cake wasn't afraid Luka will be lynched anyway.

I can't make a team of Mafia that's plausible without Luka.

What's his equity though. I mean with who. I personally don't like how easily votes on him stacked overnight. He's scummy looking at mech but maybe he's serial

 

[Charlie]

2 serials? There is already me as a survivor.

Alwaysmind's ability (i think) mentions "serials", plural. Could be just way to avoid giving away there's just one but it's hard to brush it off

 

[Michelle]

What's your Poe Charlie, and why?

I think I answered at the question about refill gate

 

[Ratchet]

Tbh serial should have kills anyway and if they're not dumb they should just go for mafia before they reach majority.

I could see Cake and Polar being team tbh. Cake being team with Luka just doesn't work for me. Unless "real" vote count on Kiku last dp was higher/on Luka was lower for some reason and Cake wasn't afraid Luka will be lynched anyway.



What's his equity though. I mean with who. I personally don't like how easily votes on him stacked overnight. He's scummy looking at mech but maybe he's serial

Alright well make yourself useful and you solve it then.

 

[Red Night]

Alwaysmind's ability (i think) mentions "serials", plural. Could be just way to avoid giving away there's just one but it's hard to brush it off

What if my Redacted Tao Form makes me a serial?

 

[Ratchet]

We have no concrete evidence of a serial killer. No extra kills. The only thing present is a role sheet mentioning "Mafias as Serials" which honestly could be interpreted as a poorly-worded sheet (the correct wording could be "anti-town"). We can stop with the "but serial" spec.

 

[Red Night]

We have no concrete evidence of a serial killer. No extra kills. The only thing present is a role sheet mentioning "Mafias as Serials" which honestly could be interpreted as a poorly-worded sheet (the correct wording could be "anti-town"). We can stop with the "but serial" spec.

So what's your opinion on Luka then?

 

[Charlie]

What's your Poe Charlie, and why?

I think I answered at the question about refill gate

Cake - mostly due to refill gate. I can't believe she'd mess up like this twice. And it's not like we need +3vp rn to begin with. Town still has majority. I could see that as fake claim.

Polar - don't like his PoE, tbh it might be omgus on my part, no claim either

Kiku 2.0 - going after nibel rn makes zero sense, i don't like her explanation either

Luka - both kill and investigation failed one way or another


Yeah, i wanted to make sure i'm not tunneling cake too much

 

[Michelle]

Being the possibility of them not being aligned I wouldn't lynch Luka before Cake

 

[Michelle]

Vote lynch CakeWalker

 

[Charlie]

Alright well make yourself useful and you solve it then.

Ratchet, have i done something outside the game? Like, i don't get what's your problem. Haven't seen you making these comments towards other people.

We have no concrete evidence of a serial killer. No extra kills. The only thing present is a role sheet mentioning "Mafias as Serials" which honestly could be interpreted as a poorly-worded sheet (the correct wording could be "anti-town"). We can stop with the "but serial" spec.

Serial could be poisoner or arsonist.

What if my Redacted Tao Form makes me a serial?

That would be going against your current wincon then. I don't think so.

 

[Red Night]

Vote lynch CakeWalker

I will follow the townie
Vote Lynch CakeWalker

 

[Charlie]

I'd say Cake or Polar and if Cake flips something like (your vote doesn't count on your teammates) and/or Polar with more than 1 vp, it's safe to go after Luka i think.

 

[Charlie]

Vote Lynch CakeWalker