Who will be the Next Strawhat?


  • Total voters
    496
I am pretty sure an ex-marine or someone who worked for the world government will join the straw hats.

Nika
Germa
Son of a yonko commander
Someone who can read ponegylphs
An animal
A cyborg
A walking skeleton
Ex-warlord also fishman

Someone who was working for the world government switching sides makes the crew even more outstanding, unique and crazy as it is already. It fits.

Who will it be? Idk

We have Lucci but he killed people.
Stussy but she gets no screentime.

My bet is Smoker.
Logia is missing in the crew.
He has a good heart and respects Luffy.
Unique weapon.
New hair color.
We know him for a very long time.
He is questioning things.
Kuzan would be a perfect match up against him.
Mysteriously absent in the story.

He will appear soon on Egghead. Smoker and Bonney double join and the crew is complete.
 
I am pretty sure an ex-marine or someone who worked for the world government will join the straw hats.

Nika
Germa
Son of a yonko commander
Someone who can read ponegylphs
An animal
A cyborg
A walking skeleton
Ex-warlord also fishman

Someone who was working for the world government switching sides makes the crew even more outstanding, unique and crazy as it is already. It fits.

Who will it be? Idk

We have Lucci but he killed people.
Stussy but she gets no screentime.

My bet is Smoker.
Logia is missing in the crew.
He has a good heart and respects Luffy.
Unique weapon.
New hair color.
We know him for a very long time.
He is questioning things.
Kuzan would be a perfect match up against him.
Mysteriously absent in the story.

He will appear soon on Egghead. Smoker and Bonney double join and the crew is complete.
Kizaru
 
I am pretty sure an ex-marine or someone who worked for the world government will join the straw hats.

Nika
Germa
Son of a yonko commander
Someone who can read ponegylphs
An animal
A cyborg
A walking skeleton
Ex-warlord also fishman
Its okay to admit Kizaru is joining. Theres no way Blackbeard is the only gigachad who gets an Admiral to join.

Edit:Forgot I had a post saved, how embarrassing.
 

Let's see for Kizaru

Kizari doesn't pass the 5 golden rules but lets assume he does

As for the pillars:

1- Fighting skill, Yup. 1 point.
2- Antagonistic introduction, Check. 2 Points
3- Multilayered characterization. None. 0 points
4- Symbolic reach. Half. 1 Points
5- Strong character arc. None. 0 Points
6- Hint of the 2 driving forces. None. 0 Points
7- The rescue. None. 0 Points
8- The Nakama need. None . 0 point
9- Post. Nothing. Nothing 0 points.
10- Shining Nakama action. Nothing. 0 points.

Kizaru wins 4 points


Let's sum up:

Kizaru wins 4 Points
Lucci wins 5 points
Lilith wins 12 points
Stussy wins 13 points
Smoker wins 15 Points
Bonney wins 24 Points
Yamato wins 25 Points
Carrot wins 36 Points
 
Last edited:
I am pretty sure an ex-marine or someone who worked for the world government will join the straw hats.

Nika
Germa
Son of a yonko commander
Someone who can read ponegylphs
An animal
A cyborg
A walking skeleton
Ex-warlord also fishman

Someone who was working for the world government switching sides makes the crew even more outstanding, unique and crazy as it is already. It fits.

Who will it be? Idk

We have Lucci but he killed people.
Stussy but she gets no screentime.

My bet is Smoker.
Logia is missing in the crew.
He has a good heart and respects Luffy.
Unique weapon.
New hair color.
We know him for a very long time.
He is questioning things.
Kuzan would be a perfect match up against him.
Mysteriously absent in the story.

He will appear soon on Egghead. Smoker and Bonney double join and the crew is complete.
Ex Revolutionary and the brother of a king of a WG affiliated Country Sabo
 
Ex Revolutionary and the brother of a king of a WG affiliated Country Sabo
Let's for Sabo:


Sabo doesn't pass the 5 golden rules but lets assume he does

As for the pillars:

1- Fighting skill, Ok. 1 point.
2- Antagonistic introduction, None. 2 Points
3- Multilayered characterization. Check. 3 points
4- Symbolic reach. Check. 4 Points
5- Strong character arc. Check. 5 Points
6- Hint of the 2 driving forces. Only half. 3 Points
7- The rescue. None. 0 Points
8- The Nakama need. None . 0 point
9- Post. Nothing. Nothing 0 points.
10- Shining Nakama action. Nothing. 0 points.

Sabo wins 18 points

Tied with Smoker:

Kizaru wins 4 Points
Lucci wins 5 points
Lilith wins 12 points
Stussy wins 13 points
Smoker wins 15 Points
Sabo wins 18 points
Bonney wins 24 Points
Yamato wins 25 Points
Carrot wins 36 Points
 
Last edited:
Let's for Sabo:


Sabo doesn't pass the 5 golden rules but lets assume he does

As for the pillars:

1- Fighting skill, Ok. 1 point.
2- Antagonistic introduction, None. 2 Points
3- Multilayered characterization. Check. 0 points
4- Symbolic reach. Check. 4 Points
5- Strong character arc. Check. 5 Points
6- Hint of the 2 driving forces. Only half. 3 Points
7- The rescue. None. 0 Points
8- The Nakama need. None . 0 point
9- Post. Nothing. Nothing 0 points.
10- Shining Nakama action. Nothing. 0 points.

Sabo wins 15 points

Tied with Smoker:

Kizaru wins 4 Points
Lucci wins 5 points
Lilith wins 12 points
Stussy wins 13 points
Smoker wins 15 Points
Sabo wins 15 points
Bonney wins 24 Points
Yamato wins 25 Points
Carrot wins 36 Points
What is This?
 
Sabo ''fighting skill:ok''
:lawsigh:
Ok, just means "check" lol


Can you link me to what the fuck this stuff means?
Here are the link of my blog for each sections:

Introduction of the 10 Pillars : HERE

1- Fighting skill HERE
2- Antagonistic introduction HERE
3- Multilayered characterization HERE
4- Symbolic reach. HERE
5- Strong character arc HERE
6- Hint of the 2 driving forces HERE
7- The rescue HERE
8- The Nakama need HERE
9- Post HERE
10- Shining Nakama action HERE

Conclusion about the 10 Pillars : HERE
 
Ok, just means "check" lol



Here are the link of my blog for each sections:

Introduction of the 10 Pillars : HERE

1- Fighting skill HERE
2- Antagonistic introduction HERE
3- Multilayered characterization HERE
4- Symbolic reach. HERE
5- Strong character arc HERE
6- Hint of the 2 driving forces HERE
7- The rescue HERE
8- The Nakama need HERE
9- Post HERE
10- Shining Nakama action HERE

Conclusion about the 10 Pillars : HERE
Glowing friendship activity? ?
 
Ok, just means "check" lol



Here are the link of my blog for each sections:

Introduction of the 10 Pillars : HERE

1- Fighting skill HERE
2- Antagonistic introduction HERE
3- Multilayered characterization HERE
4- Symbolic reach. HERE
5- Strong character arc HERE
6- Hint of the 2 driving forces HERE
7- The rescue HERE
8- The Nakama need HERE
9- Post HERE
10- Shining Nakama action HERE

Conclusion about the 10 Pillars : HERE
1. Fighting Skill - Both powerful and unique. Having a logia fruit along with a dragon imagery based fighting style fits - 1 Point

2. Antagonistic Introduction - Sabo was first introduced in a backstory where he along with Ace were antagonistic towards Luffy - 2 Points

3. Multilayered Personality - Youre actually nuts for not giving this to Sabo who has one of the deepest personalities we’ve seen. Did you skip the ASL backstory? Or did you skip dressrosa where were shown Sabo go through a range of emotions about fighting someone connected to Aces death, carrying his fire, and still being a strong big brother. - 3 Points

4. Symbolic Reach - The flame emperor/incarnation of revolution/Dragon altar ego/Sabos reminiscent of characters for Charles Dickens book Oliver Twist - 4 Points

5. Character Arc - Sabo has to understand the meaning of the D. As Ace gave him a D as a child and was saved by a good king in order to pass on a message about the D. - 5 Points

6. 2 driving forces - Sabo announced his dream as a child to write a book about his travels and his need is to be free away from the stuffiness and dirtiness of the ruling classes - 6 Points

7. The rescue - This happens arc characters join so could happen when Sabo returns

8. The Nakama Need - Sabo said multiple times that he’ll be there for luffy and took Luffys vivre card to help him if needed - 8 points

9. The Post - Luffy the sun god needs someone who will write the story to spread the word of how messed up the world actually is. Sabos book is precisely what that would do. Especially seeing as the world currently gets all their news from a biased source. Post name - Log Keeper same as his parallel from Rogers generation Oden - 9 points

10. Shining moment - Will happen when he returns.

Sabo current score: 38
 
Top