[FNZ] Super Role Madness World Of Warcraft: Legion
- Thread starter Fujishiro
- Start date
- Status
I think it's important to note the context here - he responded to my reads list saying Gad can be an asterisk in my PoE list, which means town. The Ekko post you're pulling up there is outlining a scenario where Gad could be scum, and saying that it's plausible. It's not accurate to say he's reaching for a scum read, he's simply taking my read and testing if it works.
As for why I am not sold on Gad, well in part I've observed him taking exception to town reads on a couple of slots, where the town reads are a bit more contentious. After discussing with him, I walked this back a tad, but only a tad, and I also feel like there isn't really a wider solving intent from him. I went through it a bit earlier, there was a succession if posts some pages back.
As for why I am not sold on Gad, well in part I've observed him taking exception to town reads on a couple of slots, where the town reads are a bit more contentious. After discussing with him, I walked this back a tad, but only a tad, and I also feel like there isn't really a wider solving intent from him. I went through it a bit earlier, there was a succession if posts some pages back.
Given most of the claims are volunteered, I don't have much paranoia over it. I do still think getting them all to claim would be best but that can be laid to rest at this point. If I received exactly 5 claims from them I'd probably just take it at face value though and leave it be there, I don't think any of those players are likely to try and pull off a fake in that way.
First, I'm not pursuing Yoho. Stop making it look like I've locked him as scum. I explained what I don't like about him and will certainly push if given the opportunity but it's D1 and I know I don't have the best reads this early.
Second, the only one I can kinda give reads on is Pot. Did the others even post enough to warrant asking me for reads?
Second, the only one I can kinda give reads on is Pot. Did the others even post enough to warrant asking me for reads?
Not really, it's not a strong scum read because I'm only taking one element of your game without having really dived into everything you've done. If you think I'm scum, why does this even bother you? I mean I'm scum right, so why are you concerned about my conviction, it's just fake outright isn't it?
The term "shade" inherently carries scum motivation, but I'm convinced if this is genuine a lot of you just don't understand nuance. If I have an issue with some elements of someone's play, I'm going to raise them, that doesn't mean I want to lynch them off the back of it. This expectation that you either go all in or it just doesn't count is very very silly.
If you're scum then carry on of course.
If you're scum then carry on of course.
None of what I said there assumes emotion. You said earlier you had a read on me, a good read actually, and when I responded that it wasn't a good read if it were a scum one, your reply indicated that it was a scum one, and you were shrugging off my comment that it wasn't a good read. Now that we've addressed your semantic contention, let me proceed.
Nowhere there did I say you were bothered, flustered, emotional or anything like that. I'm saying that if you have me as scum, which you admit you do, then it doesn't make any sense for you to be responding to a post that was explaining my issue with your slot to a third party with it being shade, because why does that matter? If you think I'm scum, then my read on you will obviously not be genuine, but your response did not really carry that assumption with it.
QED you, once again, don't seem to be tying your reads to an holistic and congruent view of the game. That's an issue for me, because I believe all townies inherently carry this with them because their beliefs are genuine, and it's one of the hardest things to fake as scum. Me not being able to see it in your posts raises alarm bells for me.
Nowhere there did I say you were bothered, flustered, emotional or anything like that. I'm saying that if you have me as scum, which you admit you do, then it doesn't make any sense for you to be responding to a post that was explaining my issue with your slot to a third party with it being shade, because why does that matter? If you think I'm scum, then my read on you will obviously not be genuine, but your response did not really carry that assumption with it.
QED you, once again, don't seem to be tying your reads to an holistic and congruent view of the game. That's an issue for me, because I believe all townies inherently carry this with them because their beliefs are genuine, and it's one of the hardest things to fake as scum. Me not being able to see it in your posts raises alarm bells for me.
Well -
I'm conceding it in part. Not in full, correct, because you haven't addressed my posts around why I have Yoho as town, which makes the idea that you're actually interested in the reads on the slot a little hard for me to buy into, but I do acknowledge that you don't start talking about Yoho because of the town reads he has from a handful of players.
It absolutely still stands with CakeWalker though, and isn't completely gone with Yoho as per the above, so my observation isn't something I'm ready to withdraw, moreso I'm developing my read after further interaction with you because I'm trying to figure out your alignment and I'm not seeing certain things that help me find you town.
I'm conceding it in part. Not in full, correct, because you haven't addressed my posts around why I have Yoho as town, which makes the idea that you're actually interested in the reads on the slot a little hard for me to buy into, but I do acknowledge that you don't start talking about Yoho because of the town reads he has from a handful of players.
It absolutely still stands with CakeWalker though, and isn't completely gone with Yoho as per the above, so my observation isn't something I'm ready to withdraw, moreso I'm developing my read after further interaction with you because I'm trying to figure out your alignment and I'm not seeing certain things that help me find you town.
- Status