[FNZ] Role Madness Naruto: Chunin Exam

[Ultra]

I know very well why you're pushing Pot, I'm saying why do you suddenly have them as null in the read list Flower gave you.

Because half of the player list is doing this

So he could be scum but I am not very affirmative on that but he certainly could be

I also think Pot named 3 players as town early on (Polar/Reloaded/Cal) and I'd probably say there's 1/3 there

 

[Ultra]

So im trying to figure out her claim and I can't.

Options would be

If scum bp
If sk bp
If town nothing, what role would you get told that you were protected, other than bp which doesn't fit as a town role in this small of a game

I'm strongly rethinking my read on Michelle now

What is Michelle's incentive for chirping up as non-town here

The only concievable one is she's Pot's buddy and trying to save him, but that seems ill informed

Every other scenario she's sticking her neck out for no reason

 

[Polar Bear]

What is Michelle's incentive for chirping up as non-town here

The only concievable one is she's Pot's buddy and trying to save him, but that seems ill informed

Every other scenario she's sticking her neck out for no reason

Haven't you noticed the people that stay silent about moves/abilities the longest are usually scum, it gives her something to add to the conversation and debate. Id lean towards Sk/cult for Michelle, bc I do agree, if she and pot are both scum it doesn't make sense. If she were sk/cult it would make sense or if she was scum and pot town it would make sense as well

 

[Ultra]

Haven't you noticed the people that stay silent about moves/abilities the longest are usually scum, it gives her something to add to the conversation and debate. Id lean towards Sk/cult for Michelle, bc I do agree, if she and pot are both scum it doesn't make sense. If she were sk/cult it would make sense or if she was scum and pot town it would make sense as well

If you think she's 3p, and she is Bulletproof, she's directly implicating herself when she has a perfectly good alibi if she says nothing.

If mafia happened to hit her with the factional kill they naturally assume she is 3p and she probably knows they know. So me coming out is a godsend, she'd have to be plumb dumb to say anything.

If she was scum and Pot is town she's interrupting framing us both for ???

So you got it backwards, giving Pot an alibi is probably the only motive she could possibly have

 

[Fujishiro]

Vote count 4 of the 2nd day

The Orca: Ultra
Flower: Pot Goblin > The Orca > Pot Goblin
Yoho: Ultra
RippedCal: The Orca > Pot Goblin
Mr. Reloaded: Polar Bear > Unvote > Pot Goblin
Indigo: Pot Goblin
Michelle: Polar Bear > The Orca > Pot Goblin > Unvote


Pot Goblin: 4
Ultra: 2

With 15 players alive it takes 8 to reach majority
Votes will not reflect their true value​

 

[Ultra]

The only thing that doesn't really make sense is her "knowing" she was protected

 

[Michelle]

I pinky promise I am town this game

That's useful ngl..

Yoho pls find something more useful to ask. No one will say they're scum.

Polar your logic doesn't look solid at all
I don't care that much about you changing your read on me, I am more worried you want to know exactly what happened, which is fishing for infos town doesn't need

 

[Ultra]

@Fujishiro threadmark your vote counts plz

 

[Michelle]

The only thing that doesn't really make sense is her "knowing" she was protected

Remember how and why you pushed Kiku, because her claim didn't fit your idea of a town role?
If you insist to solve by roles, that's an irrelevant thing for this game.

You say town can't have more than one protective role. One flipped, one protected me.
Can town have tracker and watcher. Yes. The truth is, one of them can be mafia and we don't know which one. But I am suspicious of Polar giving Red a mech help. Red, who does not care to play the game.

 

[Ultra]

Remember how and why you pushed Kiku, because her claim didn't fit your idea of a town role?
If you insist to solve by roles, that's an irrelevant thing for this game.

You say town can't have more than one protective role. One flipped, one protected me.
Can town have tracker and watcher. Yes. The truth is, one of them can be mafia and we don't know which one. But I am suspicious of Polar giving Red a mech help. Red, who does not care to play the game.

This is disingenious.

I know I have a protected role, so if I take your word that's three. I have no reason to take Pot's word already, and 4 is pushing it.

Is it possible you were visited by Guardian Angel? I see no reason for you to be informed of being protected.

 

[Ultra]

How are you going to sit there and say Watcher/Tracker probably has mafia between them

But there nothing suspect about 4 claimed roles of the same type

very silly

How are you not voting Pot Goblin

 

[Orwellian]

[Vote Lynch Pot]

Tbd this is the way

 

[Michelle]

Haven't you noticed the people that stay silent about moves/abilities the longest are usually scum, it gives her something to add to the conversation and debate. Id lean towards Sk/cult for Michelle, bc I do agree, if she and pot are both scum it doesn't make sense. If she were sk/cult it would make sense or if she was scum and pot town it would make sense as well

You pushed me today after I voted Orca, now you find another reason to doubt me.
Your scenario is totally false

This is disingenious.

I know I have a protected role, so if I take your word that's three. I have no reason to take Pot's word already, and 4 is pushing it.

Is it possible you were visited by Guardian Angel? I see no reason for you to be informed of being protected.

RB is not protective role, what are you talking about?

 

[Michelle]

But there nothing suspect about 4 claimed roles of the same type

What?
Are you for real?
RBer is mainly manipulative and informative, protection is just by chance.
What's the 4th?

 

[Michelle]

How are you not voting Pot Goblin

I don't want to hammer early

I want people to have time to play the day

 

[Michelle]

The lack of interest in this lynch is concerning.

Like Michelle you really think Fuji puts a doctor, a roleblocker, whatever is going on with you, and bus driver

On 4/12 townies

Cmon lol

And bus driver is a redirector, targeting 2 players at once.
How come you make it protective??

 

[Michelle]

Anyway I can help.

Please read the day and share your impressions

 

[Ultra]

You pushed me today after I voted Orca, now you find another reason to doubt me.
Your scenario is totally false

RB is not protective role, what are you talking about?

...yes it is? By definition?

 

[Michelle]

Where is @Flower?
What's your take?
I wasn't commuted, you watching me would be interesting to see
I think scum RBed you and tried to kill me.
Idk what to make of Ultra's RB thing

What I don't understand, from the 2 invest roles why would mafia target you for RB and let Polar to have a result? He could find mafia by his action.
More I think, more I suspect him.

 

[Ultra]

Bus Driver you can argue but you can end up backfiring a kill so it's even better