I understand the first point at the very least. The second point on it's own it's a very good comparison, isolated the post isn't very good for him however I don't think it's enough for me to change my stance.
The 3rd point is just silly though? He was saying he was lynch proof late game into D2 as a lolcat when he was outed. Here, he's saying he's Arceus; as a joke, and then claims Pikachu. Being intentionally obtuse with his claim is in his town meta