Speculations RHP/Cross Guild matchups

#1
I think the final yonkos the SHs will take on will be Shanks and Buggy. Shanks said he wanted to go to Laugh Tale with buggy back in the Oden flashback, so imo they will eventually ally with each other. If Kaido and BM’s alliance was the return of the Rocks Pirates, Shanks and Buggy will be the return of the Roger pirates. A fitting final challenge for Luffy before he becomes PK.

The obvious ones will be:
Luffy vs Shanks
Zoro vs Mihawk

my take for the remaining matchups:

Sanji vs Katakuri
- I think Kata will join Cross Guild along with the BMP.
- Kata, as BM’s successor, would be the rightful owner of BM’s special homies: Napoleon, Hera, and Prometheus. With these in his possession, Kata will return as a bona fide top tier. He could also gain the ability to use ACoC

Jinbe vs Crocodile
- Shichibukai vs Shichibukai

Yamato vs Weevil
- son of Kaido vs son of WB

Franky vs Cracker

Robin vs Smoothie

Chopper vs Snack

Nami vs Compote

Brook vs Streusen

Usopp vs Yasopp

Koby and SWORD vs Alvida and Cross Guild fodder
- Koby stomps Alvida, but we still see him capture her as he always said he would.

Kid and Killer vs Beckman, Roo, and remaining RHP fighters
- apart from Yasopp and Shanks, I don’t think any member of the RHP is important or noteworthy enough to get a real 1v1 with the SHs. While they might be strong, I think Oda will just let Kid and Killer destroy them off screen.
 
F

Foul Legacy

#2
Crocodile too strong.


Oda will never put luffy against a swordsman.


Sanji vs Katakuri
- I think Kata will join Cross Guild along with the BMP.
- Kata, as BM’s successor, would be the rightful owner of BM’s special homies: Napoleon, Hera, and Prometheus. With these in his possession, Kata will return as a bona fide top tier. He could also gain the ability to use ACoC
AdCoC to beat Sanji?
Hakiless attacks are already more than enough.


No


Tf no , Robin will die.


Debatable


Koby and SWORD vs Alvida and Cross Guild fodder
- Koby stomps Alvida, but we still see him capture her as he always said he would
Peak piece is here.


Kid and Killer vs Beckman, Roo, and remaining RHP fighters
Again?
 
#3
Crocodile too strong.



Oda will never put luffy against a swordsman.



AdCoC to beat Sanji?
Hakiless attacks are already more than enough.



No



Tf no , Robin will die.



Debatable



Peak piece is here.



Again?
Luffy vs Shanks will probably happen imo. Shanks has always been Luffy’s milestone to becoming PK.

Sanji, Jinbe, and Robin will probably all be far stronger by the time they face off against Shanks and Cross Guild.

Kid vs RHP commanders will probably be an off screen thing. Kid needs some victory against the RHP after everything and none of the RHP commanders bar Yasopp are really important. They may be strong, but they aren’t really important.

Like at this point, the SHs are probably already comparable to the RHP. The SHs don’t need to face the RHP commanders. Cross Guild tho will be different. Buggy’s going to be the rocks 2.0 by assembling the strongest crew.
 

MUUGEN

呪のろいの王
#4
I think the final yonkos the SHs will take on will be Shanks and Buggy. Shanks said he wanted to go to Laugh Tale with buggy back in the Oden flashback, so imo they will eventually ally with each other. If Kaido and BM’s alliance was the return of the Rocks Pirates, Shanks and Buggy will be the return of the Roger pirates. A fitting final challenge for Luffy before he becomes PK.

The obvious ones will be:
Luffy vs Shanks
Zoro vs Mihawk

my take for the remaining matchups:

Sanji vs Katakuri
- I think Kata will join Cross Guild along with the BMP.
- Kata, as BM’s successor, would be the rightful owner of BM’s special homies: Napoleon, Hera, and Prometheus. With these in his possession, Kata will return as a bona fide top tier. He could also gain the ability to use ACoC

Jinbe vs Crocodile
- Shichibukai vs Shichibukai

Yamato vs Weevil
- son of Kaido vs son of WB

Franky vs Cracker

Robin vs Smoothie

Chopper vs Snack

Nami vs Compote

Brook vs Streusen

Usopp vs Yasopp

Koby and SWORD vs Alvida and Cross Guild fodder
- Koby stomps Alvida, but we still see him capture her as he always said he would.

Kid and Killer vs Beckman, Roo, and remaining RHP fighters
- apart from Yasopp and Shanks, I don’t think any member of the RHP is important or noteworthy enough to get a real 1v1 with the SHs. While they might be strong, I think Oda will just let Kid and Killer destroy them off screen.
Buggy v Shanks

Croc v Beckman

Mihawk v Monster
 
#7
mihawk and imu are tied together by their eyes and by being the final opponents of strawhat captain and vice captain. strawhats won't fight rhp. bbp will beat rhp and then sh beat bbp and thus, through transitivity, will have also proven that they are stronger than rhp. usopp won't defeat yasopp, he will defeat the one who defeated yasopp (augur), to trump his father. his crossguild opponent is obviously buggy.
 
#9
Buggy isn’t allying with shanks. He already refused shanks 22 years ago cause he and shanks have different ambitions. Why on earth would he ally with him now?
 
#13
Mihawk left his loyal monkeys
the way they were crowding those windows while he was packing his stuff.... heartbreaking :catcry:

but i refuse to be part of buggy slander :hurry: he's not 'some clown', he carries roger's will and is the only honest rival of joyboy (i.e. luffy), he's much too good for crocolisa and apehawk. they don't deserve to bask in his glory
 
Top