Super Role Madness HST Mafia I: One Piece

[Lord Melkor]

Fuji is Shanks, pro Town
Yoho is Enel, anti Town but says he needs to kill mafia too so we keep him around
Ultra is a tree stump used by Blackbeard necro cult
Naomi and Watson are Town or at least pro Town
Flower says she's survivour, subbed in for role 35
AM is most likely Town, Jinbei

Re. Naomi and Watson, while i also town read them, is is mechanics based?

 

[lemon.de]

He wants you to be dead

/shrug

not a issue tbh

 

[Worst]

Fuji is Shanks, pro Town
Yoho is Enel, anti Town but says he needs to kill mafia too so we keep him around
Ultra is a tree stump used by Blackbeard necro cult
Naomi and Watson are Town or at least pro Town
Flower says she's survivour, subbed in for role 35
AM is most likely Town, Jinbei

Nice so are we going after CoC & Reloaded asses once and for all

?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Do we have mech on AM being town? My assumption was the ability was fake colour but was used to save him. Haven't read the past however many pages so if someone has claimed it then sure. Otherwise he's probably where my vote is going today.

Looks like I was blocked, nothing of mine showed up last night

Person that saved AM (Jimbei) cannot claim as claiming is prohibitted in this game. Are you not aware of this?

 

[lemon.de]

But yeah dunno the role set too much but 60% you're wolf charlie soo do with that as you will

 

[Fujishiro]

How's the PoE looking ? Have Reloaded and CoC been outed already ?

Welcome back Ape brother, what do you think about Reloaded and CoC?

 

[lemon.de]

or atleast something that's not town

maybe neutral maybe mafia faction idk

 

[Fujishiro]

But yeah dunno the role set too much but 60% you're wolf charlie soo do with that as you will

So its not mech?

 

[Fujishiro]

I am pretty sure that was modkil. Akainu was used to modkill someone in original game.

Charlie said that Akainu was a role lol.

 

[Lord Melkor]

pretty sure it's his ability

only other option i could see is him being from Beast Pirates who used janitored fake WU but that would require them having Jinbei as fake claim which I don't think Ariess gives to scum

Yes, this game is no claiming so Jimbei is unlikely to he fake claim.

Occam's Razor is that AM is just Jimbei and town, IMO.

 

[lemon.de]

actuallyyyy is that true?

mmmmm

it'd be a extremely low chance for that to be the case tbh

 

[Worst]

Welcome back Ape brother, what do you think about Reloaded and CoC?

Well last time i said there was a scheme going on between them & ultra....ultra turned out to be King which i took out exactly like they did in the manga......so i'm sure i was on the right track

 

[Lord Melkor]

Charlie said that Akainu was a role lol.

Interesting, but host controlled maybe?

I am reconsidering my scum read on Charlie, what do you make of him?

 

[Fujishiro]

Fuji is Shanks, pro Town
Yoho is Enel, anti Town but says he needs to kill mafia too so we keep him around
Ultra is a tree stump used by Blackbeard necro cult
Naomi and Watson are Town or at least pro Town
Flower says she's survivour, subbed in for role 35
AM is most likely Town, Jinbei

AlwaysMind might not be Jimbei, Crowned Witch said that someone else hinted at being Jimbei.

 

[lemon.de]

So its not mech?

i'm uncertain on the mech because of the role set being unknown to me, but like it'd have to be 3 coincidences in a row for him to be town

 

[Fujishiro]

Well last time i said there was a scheme going on between them & ultra....ultra turned out to be King which i took out exactly like they did in the manga......so i'm sure i was on the right track

I was sad that Zoro died. Anyways honestly we are running around like headless chicken here.

It doesnt seem like we have invest roles so far.

 

[lemon.de]

occums razor, probably just anti town

but rolemadness so shrug maybe something crazy exists

 

[Lord Melkor]

Add Ratchet to Town as well.

Qualify this please. You think he would be less clueless as scum?

 

[Fujishiro]

Interesting, but host controlled maybe?

I am reconsidering my scum read on Charlie, what do you make of him?

No clue lol, he could go either ways.

 

[Worst]

I was sad that Zoro died. Anyways honestly we are running around like headless chicken here.

Well have they contributed to anything so far ?

It doesnt seem like we have invest roles so far.

We'll do it the old fashioned way