Okay I decided to go back and reread the interaction
Got some early vibes that aren't quite jelling with what I would expect strong vibes would feel like.
Ultra
Soulkiller
Fuji
Naomi
All have overarching vibes of town but don't quite get there.
Naomi feels not as loosy goosy, more uptight (i still love ya) like the one scum game from her.....but her posts are in the town range
Soulkiller went into a tunnel and I was like wtf that didn't make sense and came out of nowhere....buy unlike his scum games he is trying to control the thread proactively and not reactively
Fuji being overly defensive feels like an indy but starts to vibe as town
Ultra posts feel town but he has had no resolve that I could tell and his interaction around soulkiller feels honestly like a mirror image of one he made on me when we were both scum
What are the odds both Polar/Orca independently decide to scum read Naomi at random by the way lol
Here Polar states that those 4 players Ultra, SK, Fuji, Naomi are townie, but not really townie. Kinda don't wanna commit to giving them a town lean which is weird, when you look at the explanation he provided for each on why we didn't make it to the townie list, it does look like the dude is scum reading us if you look exclusively at the reasons he provided without looking at the context before it ngl.
Ultra here makes this statement saying that Polar/Orca here scum read naomi. Now initially when I first read this, I didn't realy think Polar was scum reading those 4 players per say, but that he wanna town read us, but does not wanna commit to the town read for the following reasons he provided.
Ultra accuses Polar of why he is scum reading naomi, polar responded with something along the lines that he did not post a scum read list, and will the back and forth continued from there.
So let me get this straight
You put Soul on your ""scum"" list, then you move him to your town list, now you're saying he's my scum partner
I do recall while catching up seeing ultra make this statement and thinking to myself that I did not recall Polar ever scum reading me, so where is this really coming from? But turned out that it stemmed with the reasoning polar gave on why ultra gives townie vibes but not really townie in his read list.
Now to be fair, later into the game polar decided to scum read me or as he says my town read on him weakened because I missed one of his posts. Now this is weird, because the post I missed that fuji is also scum reading polar besides me at the time. Now, why does me not seeing that or missing that is scumy? only god knows. But I thought that was odd and brings unecessary attention to himself. Either way, he brings up me and ultra connection back into the table supposedly.
When I question him about it, he states
I'm starting to soften some on my town lean of soulkiller.
I mean I literally quoted him and told him you had me as scum as well, is he just reading your posts only now....
Brings back into play the Ultra/Soulkiller connection imo
The way ultra went from "considering you town" to magically scum reading you was eerily similar to what he did when I was scum with him and he got me lynched d1.
And I don't think you are scum with ultra, like does anyone freaking read my words.
I said it brings it back into play. I still have you as town but that read is weakening by the minute
Dude clearly contradicting himself here.
But to be fair with you peeps, I can see a world where polar is townie here and how it would be easy to make a case on him here and it really wouldn't be hard for certain players to run circles and push the guy.