[FNZ] Role Madness Star Wars OT - Game Thread

[Ratchet]

Disagree on The Orca.

I mean I can see it. Any ideas for a 4th then?

 

[Polar Bear]

His play is slobby, when I read that post of his, i didn't think he scum read either of the 4 players he mentioned. As stated in his post, how I precieved it is that those 4 players give off townie vibes but he is reluctant on giving townie lean for them and elaborated on why on the reasons below, in his first thought/read list or whatever you wanna call it.

I can see how some players may view it or mistake it as he is scum reading if you look exclucively on his reasons.

Common thought process

-These guys feel town

-But here are the reasons holding me back from putting them fully into town

-(Leaves off the reasons why they feel town)

 

[SoulKiller]

Yeah a claim ain't gonna happen as it won't help solve my slot. Maybe a character claim but again, that won't change anything either lol

Why it won't help solve your slot? Shouldn't you be confident in your claim if it's not fake that is?

 

[Ratchet]

Out of these 4 slots, how many of them you think are actually scum? 2? I did see you play with the thought of reloaded and polar being partners.

Can you actually give me your scum list here?

3 out of 4. Ones left over are Yoho, Indigo. Haven't got a read on Red Night.

 

[Ratchet]

Common thought process

-These guys feel town

-But here are the reasons holding me back from putting them fully into town

-(Leaves off the reasons why they feel town)

Yeah that's a very natural point to start off from lol

 

[Fujishiro]

His play is slobby, when I read that post of his, i didn't think he scum read either of the 4 players he mentioned. As stated in his post, how I precieved it is that those 4 players give off townie vibes but he is reluctant on giving townie lean for them and elaborated on why on the reasons below, in his first thought/read list or whatever you wanna call it.

I can see how some players may view it or mistake it as he is scum reading if you look exclucively on his reasons.

This isnt the issue at all Soul, when I asked him if those were town leans because I was confused he said they were null reads. You should try and read my interraction with him if you didnt.

Now, I do think there is alot of holes in his arguments etc, and sometimes he contradicts himself. But to be quite frank with you, Polar does not strike me as the best guy when it comes to argument. This is me not defending the points he made, I think the way he been playing does not strike me as scum motivated. His play is slobby and some of his posts really made no sense. As I said, I think there is merit in pushing him and probably get a claim out of him. But If I had to bet money on his flip, he probably flips townie. Again, if I am wrong I am wrong. Just my own humble opinion on the matter.

So you think his play isnt scum motivated because its sloppy and some of his posts make no sense? How do you denote motivation from that couldnt it just be him screwing up?

@Polar Bear there is one thing also that is pinging me about your slot that is making me give you the benefit of the doubt here. I would like you to claim please if possible. If you are truly townie, I would like for us to put our effort and focus somewhere else. I don't think you left much room for yourself to not get out of this without claiming if I am honest with you.

What is pinging you?

 

[Fujishiro]

Common thought process

-These guys feel town

-But here are the reasons holding me back from putting them fully into town

-(Leaves off the reasons why they feel town)

I read it as Pokemon thought process kek.

 

[Fujishiro]

I mean I can see it. Any ideas for a 4th then?

Ill make a proper PoE when I finally get off bed lol.

 

[The Orca]

Players:
1. Alexis2282AE
2. Yoho
3. Fujishiro
4. Polar Bear
5. The Orca
6. Indigo
7. Ratchet
8. Naomi
9. SoulKiller
10. Emil
11. York
12. MangoSenpai
13. Red Night
14. Ultra
15. Dr. Watson
16. Mr. Reloaded

 

[Fujishiro]

Yeah a claim ain't gonna happen as it won't help solve my slot. Maybe a character claim but again, that won't change anything either lol

Huh lol.

 

[SoulKiller]

This isnt the issue at all Soul, when I asked him if those were town leans because I was confused he said they were null reads. You should try and read my interraction with him if you didnt.

Will give it another read whenever I get the time, but as I stated I don't think his arguments were really the best.

So you think his play isnt scum motivated because its sloppy and some of his posts make no sense? How do you denote motivation from that couldnt it just be him screwing up?

There is a chance of him screwing up, just think he made soo many butchers for my liking to be scum here. Him not wanting to claim and stating that it will not resolve his slot, is making me second guess myself ngl.

What is pinging you?

I want him to claim before I say anything.

 

[Fujishiro]

Why it won't help solve your slot? Shouldn't you be confident in your claim if it's not fake that is?

I guess maybe if its not a claim thats not obviously town it wont matter is how I understood it.

 

[Ultra]

Huh lol.

"Fuck I can't claim vanilla town"

 

[Fujishiro]

All claims should matter for example its hard for me to see a claim of a role that cant be town and then you see if anyone CCs it or whatever and decide if you want to trust or not @Polar Bear

 

[Fujishiro]

"Fuck I can't claim vanilla town"

Im pretty sure Melkor would give mafia fake claims so this is an interesting answer lol.

 

[Fujishiro]

Players:
1. Alexis2282AE
2. Yoho
3. Fujishiro
4. Polar Bear
5. The Orca
6. Indigo
7. Ratchet
8. Naomi
9. SoulKiller
10. Emil
11. York
12. MangoSenpai
13. Red Night
14. Ultra
15. Dr. Watson
16. Mr. Reloaded

Do you feel like Ratchet and Indigo are aligned? It doesnt feel like it to me lol.

 

[Polar Bear]

@Polar Bear there is one thing also that is pinging me about your slot that is making me give you the benefit of the doubt here. I would like you to claim please if possible. If you are truly townie, I would like for us to put our effort and focus somewhere else. I don't think you left much room for yourself to not get out of this without claiming if I am honest with you.

As I said, I can claim character but it won't change anything

I could also claim role but that definitely won't change anything so I won't be.

I'm content on the mislynch just to prove how stupid ultra is and why his cult followers may be worse (not saying they are in this game, but in general)

All of this bc I pushed ultra and he started gaslighting lol. Nothing I've done has contributed to this game state , its all been manufactured so I really don't care to play into it.

Like I said, character, anytime just say the word

 

[Ultra]

Think if Polar is town who talked himself into a hole here as well I would see more questions about his wagon and see some solving informed by that

Largely I think he's locking into positions he's given earlier in a way that's consistent with anti-spew

 

[Polar Bear]

Why it won't help solve your slot? Shouldn't you be confident in your claim if it's not fake that is?

Highly confident

Doesn't mean it will change anything.

The character is someone id put as a high probability that it could be fake and the role is NAI

 

[SoulKiller]

As I said, I can claim character but it won't change anything

I could also claim role but that definitely won't change anything so I won't be.

I'm content on the mislynch just to prove how stupid ultra is and why his cult followers may be worse (not saying they are in this game, but in general)

All of this bc I pushed ultra and he started gaslighting lol. Nothing I've done has contributed to this game state , its all been manufactured so I really don't care to play into it.

Like I said, character, anytime just say the word

I fail to see how you claiming would not change anything. But fair, claim your character please.