GTH I'd say Soul is more likely to be scum here than Ratchet if Polar flips town, I think Soul has been pretty weak about pushing his perspective forward and a lot of his defense of Polar I could see from a TMI perspective. I don't see as much of a strategic angle from Ratchet's play.
As I stated before, you are not willing to look at polar from different angle here to see why he is townie. One would say you are too tunneled in your own narrative here.