Anime Discussion Best Female Character Ranking
- Thread starter Mashiro Blue
- Start date
- Tags dot negdiffs
I'll announce results in a bit but after counting the votes Kana and Alya have actually 4 votes because one user didn't use all his votes.
So the ones going for the runner up contest
Will be these 3 with 5 votes
So the ones going for the runner up contest
Nadeko Sengoku - The Monogatari Series
Rin Nanakura - Pseudo Harem
Akane Kurokawa - Oshi no Ko
Rin Nanakura - Pseudo Harem
Akane Kurokawa - Oshi no Ko
One user voted them but didn't use all votes so they don't count.
The idea behind this is to prevent popular shows to have a concentration of votes in detriment of other less popular shows. Let's say 6 users see show A with character B on it. And 3 more users see show C with character D on it. Now naturally if there's no vote restrictions Character B has an advantage over character D and we're not really seeing which show/character has been seen by more users in a season. This would be unfair for character D even if eventually character D is a better character than character B and it would disproportionately be unbanlanced towards character B.
As an example the MAL seasonal contests restricts popular anime to be chosen precisely because everyone would choose them over less popular anime. In WG there was a best song contest where OP/Naruto songs etc were banned because otherwise everyone would vote for them only even if another song was better than from that popular show.
Instead of banning popular shows, the only thing I decided was for everyone to use their votes in full so as to prevent a conglomerate of votes on popular characters only. Naturally there's no perfect system because that would imply that everyone checks every anime every season which is unrealistic, so this small restriction is in place instead of the alternatives mentioned above.
[automerge]1727973018[/automerge]
Having said that if the majority wants to lift this restriction that's fine for me too
The idea behind this is to prevent popular shows to have a concentration of votes in detriment of other less popular shows. Let's say 6 users see show A with character B on it. And 3 more users see show C with character D on it. Now naturally if there's no vote restrictions Character B has an advantage over character D and we're not really seeing which show/character has been seen by more users in a season. This would be unfair for character D even if eventually character D is a better character than character B and it would disproportionately be unbanlanced towards character B.
As an example the MAL seasonal contests restricts popular anime to be chosen precisely because everyone would choose them over less popular anime. In WG there was a best song contest where OP/Naruto songs etc were banned because otherwise everyone would vote for them only even if another song was better than from that popular show.
Instead of banning popular shows, the only thing I decided was for everyone to use their votes in full so as to prevent a conglomerate of votes on popular characters only. Naturally there's no perfect system because that would imply that everyone checks every anime every season which is unrealistic, so this small restriction is in place instead of the alternatives mentioned above.
[automerge]1727973018[/automerge]
Having said that if the majority wants to lift this restriction that's fine for me too
@Mashiro Blue
Maybe make a poll, so users can vote whether they want that rule to stay or not.
Oh and if most vote yes, then maybe next time when the next contest comes, add that rule so users won't forget it.
Maybe make a poll, so users can vote whether they want that rule to stay or not.
Oh and if most vote yes, then maybe next time when the next contest comes, add that rule so users won't forget it.
