Super Role Madness Cinematic Mafia: Into the DC Verse

[Ratchet]

In spite of this I do not really think Charlie is scum. Had a quick look over and I saw Orca, Polar and York dump shade there, with Yaseen potentially adding to the fire. Some of this is going to be explained fairly easily but I think York/Polar/Yaseen could all be possible scum from this. Orca at least tracks logically with his positions.

I would expect some undue defence too but the problem I'm going to have is that if scum are looking to get ahead and look good off of it, they're inherently going to look more reasonable to me because they're arguing things that I think others should have argued. So not am easy angle for me to solve from.

I would say the ones who were around but said nothing about it probably would be the most scummy, but I cba checking lol

 

[Ratchet]

anyway is flower getting modkilled now for blatantly hinting this or how did we know she's flash? there shud be no tolerance policy for this

That's entirely up to Aries. I would argue that it's not really reasonable to expect players to essentially sit on info but that's a call he and he alone gets to make.

 

[The Orca]

i think darkseid directly targeted flower possibly if shes indeed flash. if darkseid's ability just takes control of the next town action it'd have taken control of batman or manhunter's action

anyway is flower getting modkilled now for blatantly hinting this or how did we know she's flash? there shud be no tolerance policy for this

In spite of this I do not really think Charlie is scum. Had a quick look over and I saw Orca, Polar and York dump shade there, with Yaseen potentially adding to the fire. Some of this is going to be explained fairly easily but I think York/Polar/Yaseen could all be possible scum from this. Orca at least tracks logically with his positions.

I would expect some undue defence too but the problem I'm going to have is that if scum are looking to get ahead and look good off of it, they're inherently going to look more reasonable to me because they're arguing things that I think others should have argued. So not am easy angle for me to solve from.

I would say the ones who were around but said nothing about it probably would be the most scummy, but I cba checking lol

 

[Emil]

I would expect some undue defence too but the problem I'm going to have is that if scum are looking to get ahead and look good off of it, they're inherently going to look more reasonable to me because they're arguing things that I think others should have argued. So not am easy angle for me to solve from.

is this directed toward anyone specifically?

 

[Ratchet]

is this directed toward anyone specifically?

Not really, the only ones I saw were Pot, Fuji and maybe Soul and I dunno if there is scum in there.

 

[Charlie]

This is not an answer. It doesn't address my question at all. I'm not asking for the motivation, or the possible value, of any of these abilities. I'm asking why, as a default assumption, was the ability working upon visit assumed before... anything else of the myriad other explanations that exist. If your argument is that the first town ability used is too powerful, I would counter by saying it's not really given that you would have no idea what you're stopping, and that there is a lot of precedent to draw upon for abilities working this way in these games.

welp, it's been presented this way and we all just sheeped

So my follow up is, why did this theory gain any traction when it's based on a premise that by your own admission, is too good to be true?

because we want results and when we got something, we weren't thinking too much

 

[Fujishiro]

i think darkseid directly targeted flower possibly if shes indeed flash. if darkseid's ability just takes control of the next town action it'd have taken control of batman or manhunter's action

anyway is flower getting modkilled now for blatantly hinting this or how did we know she's flash? there shud be no tolerance policy for this

I dont think its modkill worthy lol.

 

[Fujishiro]

Not really, the only ones I saw were Pot, Fuji and maybe Soul and I dunno if there is scum in there.

Pot maybe lol.

 

[Ratchet]

welp, it's been presented this way and we all just sheeped

because we want results and when we got something, we weren't thinking too much

I mean, when you put it that way, I guess it makes sense lmao.

 

[Ratchet]

I think York fits the bill of scum that wanted to position towards there without actually committing to anything.

 

[Fujishiro]

I think York fits the bill of scum that wanted to position towards there without actually committing to anything.

How so?

 

[Ratchet]

How so?

I'm basing off a quick iso here but she seemed to lean towards that direction without voting me. Basically adding her stock into it without taking any mechanical action which I typically attribute to scum. I'm not saying it's a slam dunk or she should be kynched or anything, just, if you ask me to find a slot that fits as scum around that, York's would be it.

 

[jinri]

I'M HERE

 

[jinri]

FUJI JUST TOLD ME IN ANOTHER GAME THAT THIS ONE STARTED

 

[Fujishiro]

I'm basing off a quick iso here but she seemed to lean towards that direction without voting me. Basically adding her stock into it without taking any mechanical action which I typically attribute to scum. I'm not saying it's a slam dunk or she should be kynched or anything, just, if you ask me to find a slot that fits as scum around that, York's would be it.

She seemed upset about the way we circumvented role claiming, felt townie idk.

 

[Fujishiro]

FUJI JUST TOLD ME IN ANOTHER GAME THAT THIS ONE STARTED

Lol welcome.

 

[Ratchet]

She seemed upset about the way we circumvented role claiming, felt townie idk.

I think that could go either way to be honest.

 

[jinri]

This is super role madness I was tricked into playing this!

I'll read the last few pages. I can't promise more than that...

 

[Yoho]

i think darkseid directly targeted flower possibly if shes indeed flash. if darkseid's ability just takes control of the next town action it'd have taken control of batman or manhunter's action

anyway is flower getting modkilled now for blatantly hinting this or how did we know she's flash? there shud be no tolerance policy for this

How did you come to the conclusion she's flash ? Did I miss something?

 

[Polar Bear]

Had a quick look over and I saw Orca, Polar and York dump shade there, with Yaseen potentially adding to the fire

Please explain