Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Day 2]

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Ultra, who are BS's partners if youre convinced theyre scum? also if youre convinced that bs is scum then why are u expecting quick and correct answers / for your questions to be answered at all? also just for the sake of completeness, who is scum if bs is town?

your aggression is clearly upsetting BS and in the world where BS is town youre making the game significantly less fun for them so i think we should take this brief detour and discuss partners / alternatives boo hoo

 

[Polar Bear]

And why would she be an "easy target"? As opposed to, say, Alwaysmind?

Pushing flower, pushing the copy paste argument, sticking to it for way too long, not moving off her initial thought despite the confusion being explained, etc.

 

[Polar Bear]

Pushing flower, pushing the copy paste argument, sticking to it for way too long, not moving off her initial thought despite the confusion being explained, etc.

**Pushing flower for her initial posts

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

To what end?

I would also like you to answer this question, Flower. What would be the point of me faking irritation with Ultra there? Especially since he's being so very irritating.

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

Why is Butter's a low hanging fruit? Kind of an odd thing to say.

Well, for one thing, it's my first game here. I'm low hanging fruit by definition.

You HAVE played mafia before, right?

 

[Ultra]

I also find it informative that shortly after I said this to Fuji, Ultra started trying in earnest to yeet me.

Wolf:
Fuji
Ultra
Luka (based on the fact that it's unlikely an entire wolf team would accuse one player, and Luka had already defended me but appears to have largely dropped that)

Which would mean probable village:
Flower
Indigo

Other possible world:

Wolf
Charlie
Random Asshole

Not sure if a wolf team of Fuji, Ultra, Luka, Charlie, Random Asshole would make sense. I kind of feel like it wouldn't--that there would be at least one more under the radar wolf in place of the more active posters.

Actually, I starter to want to lynch you after your responses to Flower. You are deflecting from my actually stated reasons and are now bringing up my earlier posts for some reason, when you didn't have a problem with them before!

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

Pushing flower, pushing the copy paste argument, sticking to it for way too long, not moving off her initial thought despite the confusion being explained, etc.

What Polar Bear is too gracious to say is that they've played with me before and I'm just stubborn about stuff.

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

who are android people? fuji, ytw (saying machines are bad) and who?

*raises hand* Android person here. Fuck Apple all the way.

 

[The Orca]

Well, for one thing, it's my first game here. I'm low hanging fruit by definition.

You HAVE played mafia before, right?

 

[Ultra]

Ultra, who are BS's partners if youre convinced theyre scum? also if youre convinced that bs is scum then why are u expecting quick and correct answers / for your questions to be answered at all? also just for the sake of completeness, who is scum if bs is town?

your aggression is clearly upsetting BS and in the world where BS is town youre making the game significantly less fun for them so i think we should take this brief detour and discuss partners / alternatives boo hoo

I expect her to answer why she doesn't wanna lynch Hime for her contributions when Hime has done nothing. Pretty reasonable?

I'm sorry but I think a lot of her behavior is performative, and I also don't think she was averse to aggressively questioning people herself earlier, so no bueno. Not even being that aggressive, just have a whole lot of questions about her play.

 

[Ultra]

Pushing flower, pushing the copy paste argument, sticking to it for way too long, not moving off her initial thought despite the confusion being explained, etc.

So you think that I came in and played the good guy card when she started accusing Flower. I can actually see that. I still don't accept that she's LHF any more than likely 75% of the players here.

Well, for one thing, it's my first game here. I'm low hanging fruit by definition.

You HAVE played mafia before, right?

Posturing.

What Polar Bear is too gracious to say is that they've played with me before and I'm just stubborn about stuff.

Funny you mention that

https://www.mafiauniverse.com/forums/threads/46188-Witch-Hunt-VI-Semi-Invitational

@Flower Do you see any similarities in her play here? I think I do lol.

 

[Charlie]

I can only conclude that they were put on the list with Alwaysmind and hime to form the magic number of three players.

honestly, yeah xd

 

[Charlie]

I also find it informative that shortly after I said this to Fuji, Ultra started trying in earnest to yeet me.

Possible world:

Wolf:
Fuji
Ultra
Luka (based on the fact that it's unlikely an entire wolf team would accuse one player, and Luka had already defended me but appears to have largely dropped that)

Which would mean probable village:
Flower
Indigo

Other possible world:

Wolf
Charlie
Random Asshole

Not sure if a wolf team of Fuji, Ultra, Luka, Charlie, Random Asshole would make sense. I kind of feel like it wouldn't--that there would be at least one more under the radar wolf in place of the more active posters.

not a fan of any of these tbh :/ fuji i'd say is town with how he handled flower situation and i'm pretty sure i'm not scum, altho if idk all machines turn hostile or sth on day 5, i guess i'm screwed

 

[Ultra]

Not exactly 1-1 though, seems a bit more phoned in here, but there are posts from that game which seem fairly similar to here, maybe ill pull them up

Or maybe this is the time where I yank my collar back before I get N1'd again

 

[The Orca]

I think Flower and Fuji being the first to discuss the alignments and the killer robot crew probably wouldn't come from scum, too bold at the start of the game even if they have fake claims. This would put them firmly as town for me

 

[Charlie]

I think Flower and Fuji being the first to discuss the alignments and the killer robot crew probably wouldn't come from scum, too bold at the start of the game even if they have fake claims. This would put them firmly as town for me

from my pov

flower is basically cleared because she came up confused af with all this "secret alignment" shet since the same thing happened to me
fuji as scum could at least try to make her look bad based on it, idk

so basically yeah

wdyt of butter vs ultra?

 

[Polar Bear]

I think Flower and Fuji being the first to discuss the alignments and the killer robot crew probably wouldn't come from scum, too bold at the start of the game even if they have fake claims. This would put them firmly as town for me

Reading back through, Charlie felt town in his pseudo claim

 

[Ultra]

Suffice to say though I think Butter's is clearly at a player level where she is not passing aptitude checks for normal town play - her aggressive positioning around the most vocal player slots and lack of town reading just about anyone doesn't seem like she's trying to take advantage of an unfamiliar play environment by throwing hands with everyone and assuming she'll be town read for it. Also is giving weird and cagey vibes.

Her town games im reading don't seem much like this but also hard to make 1-1 comparison in games where she's playing with more familiar people.

Still feels very phoney though

 

[The Orca]

from my pov

flower is basically cleared because she came up confused af with all this "secret alignment" shet since the same thing happened to me
fuji as scum could at least try to make her look bad based on it, idk

so basically yeah

wdyt of butter vs ultra?

There is definitely an aspect of it where I do think Sundae was LHF, but the thoughts about her play all around I agree with. Especially how she is pushing Flower and Fuji on "fake" reasons or performance as Ultra says. I think though there is a world where Sundae is town/indy and Ultra is town/indy. I also agree I wouldn't have thought Ultra would try and run down the ice cream with some of these thoughts, but I had the same ideas run through my head at times. It scares me that I am having similar thoughts this game to Ultra and Flower in regards to Sundae

Starting to think Sundae might not be mafia

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

I think Flower and Fuji being the first to discuss the alignments and the killer robot crew probably wouldn't come from scum, too bold at the start of the game even if they have fake claims. This would put them firmly as town for me

Flower's claim is actually very problematic and I wouldn't be at ALL surprised if she's an overpowered 3p.