Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Night 6]

[Butterscotch Sundae]

honestly, yeah xd

<3

Okay, you can be a villager.

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

Suffice to say though I think Butter's is clearly at a player level where she is not passing aptitude checks for normal town play - her aggressive positioning around the most vocal player slots and lack of town reading just about anyone doesn't seem like she's trying to take advantage of an unfamiliar play environment by throwing hands with everyone and assuming she'll be town read for it. Also is giving weird and cagey vibes.

Her town games im reading don't seem much like this but also hard to make 1-1 comparison in games where she's playing with more familiar people.

Still feels very phoney though

I tend to give villager leans more carefully than most people do and less early. Falsely accusing a villager is an error, but not a game losing one. Falsely clearing a villager is a mistake of epic proportions. If I have a bunch of villagers too early on, I'm probably wolfing and struggling to find people to accuse.

 

[Flower]

Flower's claim is actually very problematic and I wouldn't be at ALL surprised if she's an overpowered 3p.

Biggest bullshit I've heard today.

 

[Flower]

@Ultra I'm reading that other game later.

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

Biggest bullshit I've heard today.

Okay, then vote me. Oh, you already are. I guess you could try voting me MOAR?

 

[Fujishiro]

I also find it informative that shortly after I said this to Fuji, Ultra started trying in earnest to yeet me.

Possible world:

Wolf:
Fuji
Ultra
Luka (based on the fact that it's unlikely an entire wolf team would accuse one player, and Luka had already defended me but appears to have largely dropped that)

Which would mean probable village:
Flower
Indigo

Other possible world:

Wolf
Charlie
Random Asshole

Not sure if a wolf team of Fuji, Ultra, Luka, Charlie, Random Asshole would make sense. I kind of feel like it wouldn't--that there would be at least one more under the radar wolf in place of the more active posters.

Why am I wolf lol.

 

[Flower]

LHF Flower

Since when am I a LHF?

 

[Flower]

Why am I wolf lol.

Sundae's scum.

 

[Ultra]

I tend to give villager leans more carefully than most people do and less early. Falsely accusing a villager is an error, but not a game losing one. Falsely clearing a villager is a mistake of epic proportions. If I have a bunch of villagers too early on, I'm probably wolfing and struggling to find people to accuse.

I feel like you accused half the game of being scum while barely giving anyone a nod at being good which is nominally bad play. The fact that you're clearly an experienced player is enforcing my suspicion here because I think the town case for you would be that you're just paranoid and suspect of everything. But your lack of nuance in your play isn't really matching what I've been looking at...

 

[Flower]

If Sundae is scum, the team probably doesn't have people who would tell her not to go after me as I'm an OMGUSer.

So might be largely afk team in that case.

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

I feel like you accused half the game of being scum while barely giving anyone a nod at being good which is nominally bad play. The fact that you're clearly an experienced player is enforcing my suspicion here because I think the town case for you would be that you're just paranoid and suspect of everything. But your lack of nuance in your play isn't really matching what I've been looking at...

Accused half the game?

I don't even know what to do with that. You really, really, really need to die.

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

If Sundae is scum, the team probably doesn't have people who would tell her not to go after me as I'm an OMGUSer.

So might be largely afk team in that case.

I'm sorry to disappoint you, but I don't have private chat with my team. What you see in this thread is all there is. It's okay if you guys want to kill me, but somebody needs to start being an obvious villager so I can will them my mad skillz.

 

[Ultra]

Accused half the game?



I don't even know what to do with that. You really, really, really need to die.

Well you said Fuji's scum, Flower is scum, I'm scummy, Cryo's scum, Polar's scum, Home's scum, then you did your rehash of the game thread and concluded there's probable scum in the low activity players...not really that far off.

You gonna ever answer my question on Home or just take that one to the grave? Last call before I ask for your claim

 

[Flower]

I'm sorry to disappoint you, but I don't have private chat with my team. What you see in this thread is all there is. It's okay if you guys want to kill me, but somebody needs to start being an obvious villager so I can will them my mad skillz.

The most obvious Town in the game is literally just talking to you.

 

[Flower]

Kek.

Think Charlie is fairly obv Town, too.

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

The most obvious Town in the game is literally just talking to you.

Yeah, I'm not willing my powers to someone who doesn't share my win condition. Sorry, not sorry.

 

[lemon.de]

I've seen you semi active as like a SK on another site

Inactive a few times as scum here and inactive maybe a time or two as scum.

I am tired of folks skating by as scum being inactive and for someone I know that can be active and is supposedly good I won't let it slide anymore. Thus have you in the red from the start

I've seen what I want to see from you to remove you from the red. Just don't slink back into being inactive

Also FYI everyone started in the game as orange

SK on another site?

I feel you though not wanting to let scum just do nothing

 

[The Orca]

Flower's claim is actually very problematic and I wouldn't be at ALL surprised if she's an overpowered 3p.

Can you explain how its problematic and what makes you think its 3p. I might be able to help you disregard that and move along

 

[Fujishiro]

Sundae's scum.

Idk I think she can be town lol.

 

[Fujishiro]

Flower's claim is actually very problematic and I wouldn't be at ALL surprised if she's an overpowered 3p.

Why lol. I said lore wise she fits as a good person and she claimed duelist.