Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Game End - Indie Victory]

oh boo hoo i am not the neighbor and i am not eve.

it seems like we really do have 2 towns

also idk if "scum shot Polar" theory holds water bc why does Polar have an ability that converts himself to scum from machine? if the idea is that Polar converted himself to scum and got shot by scum in the same night then why does he have a role that converts himself to scum in the first place?
 
oh boo hoo i am not the neighbor and i am not eve.

it seems like we really do have 2 towns

also idk if "scum shot Polar" theory holds water bc why does Polar have an ability that converts himself to scum from machine? if the idea is that Polar converted himself to scum and got shot by scum in the same night then why does he have a role that converts himself to scum in the first place?
You think the more likely explanation is that he kills himself lol

Polar had a shortlist of suspects including Gad and Pot who are probably scum so likely he got faction killed
 
i mean it still could be lemon

York
Yo Tan Wa
Butterscotch Sundae

Charlie

Flower
Crying bc no Cryo
lemon
Gad = 5 (Fuji, Orca, Alexis, Crying, Polar)


It's probably one of his town reads.

Could be YTW, ain't me, could be flower or could be lemon. I'd guess lemon because like, there's no good reason to have him that high on town read list unless i've missed something
 
i mean it still could be lemon



Gad = 5 (Fuji, Orca, Alexis, Crying, Polar)


It's probably one of his town reads.

Could be YTW, ain't me, could be flower or could be lemon. I'd guess lemon because like, there's no good reason to have him that high on town read list unless i've missed something
Why are you ruling out crying. Because he said so?

It's probably not lemon, he was chewing him out publicly earlier in the game and suspecting him in a way that wouldn't be likely if they could chat behind closed doors.

I also don't think it's Orca
 
Why are you ruling out crying. Because he said so?

It's probably not lemon, he was chewing him out publicly earlier in the game and suspecting him in a way that wouldn't be likely if they could chat behind closed doors.

I also don't think it's Orca
because if he was neighbour, gad would have 6 votes (extra 0.5 from crying and polar), he had 5
 
Top