Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Day 2]

[KWEH]

Why the fuck would he have a fake twin claim for his neighbor if they are both scum lol.

It's not a fake claim for his neighbor, it's for us lmao. Were they just supposed to come in here and go hi we're Adam and Eve?

 

[Luka]

You absolutely do. I've caught you on the basis of making progression too quickly when it was clear you were lurking and reading the thread before coming in and pretending you didnt

I told you post game multiple times that your logic was wrong and I don't do that. I'm not a compulsive liar when it doesn't matter.

 

[KWEH]

(Passive) Twin Androids - You will start the game in a permanent neighbor chat with your twin sister, Devola... or a human mimicking Machine posing as her...

Im assuming the other is Popolar or a human mimicking machine posing as her.

Adam and Eve are also human mimicking machines bro

 

[Fujishiro]

Fuji's play is reminding me of last game on OLF where as SK he doubled down into these really obscure mechanical arguments for why he was clear that were just big nothingburgers

Absolute retardation, Im not letting you lynch Luka and thats final. Deal with it, fuck outta here.

 

[Luka]

👎

Actually you might not even know who your mates are lmao

Do you want to state a reason to wolf read me yet or is that beneath you?

 

[Fujishiro]

Adam and Eve are also human mimicking machines bro

Cool so theyre both scum but have to trick each other with that passive for x reasons.

 

[Ultra]

Absolute retardation, Im not letting you lynch Luka and thats final. Deal with it, fuck outta here.

Oh you're just being retarded my bad

 

[Luka]

Im voting Yo Tan Wa.

I'm voting RA for flower but I'm v happy with this vote for the record. I'll switch before EOD if needed.

 

[Fujishiro]

I don't understand why you're providing Lukas defense for him tbh. Yeah you could argue it makes no sense for him to claim right now and that he could run out the clock until whenever he's actually forced to claim, but that's not what he did is it. You can always make the argument that player X could have played their situation differently if they were scum but the fact of the matter is people misplay all the time

Because I believe hes town, because I believed Butter was town but was too timid about my defense and she was mislynched. Im not letting that happen again lol.

 

[Luka]

I don't understand why you're providing Lukas defense for him tbh. Yeah you could argue it makes no sense for him to claim right now and that he could run out the clock until whenever he's actually forced to claim, but that's not what he did is it. You can always make the argument that player X could have played their situation differently if they were scum but the fact of the matter is people misplay all the time

Do you want to state a reason to wolf read me either?

 

[Fujishiro]

@Flower when do you win the duel?

 

[Fujishiro]

Oh you're just being retarded my bad

Im making perfect sense.

 

[Ultra]

Do you want to state a reason to wolf read me yet or is that beneath you?

1) You're not dumb and trying to paint this as something beneath you is suspect
2) You're leaning heavily into demanding I "wolf case" you, which explicitly plays to your strengths - namely that you weren't scum until very recently snd the info is mostly mechanical on nature. In other words, you posing this framing is wack

 

[KWEH]

Do you want to state a reason to wolf read me either?

I recall having you as scum d1 based on also correctly having you as scum d1 the game before, is that sufficient?

 

[Luka]

All of you guys are tinfoilers. You're pushing me on what's possible, not probable. I fully admit that I could potentially be wolf here, if I was IC I wouldve just claimed without baiting a NK. But the fact of the matter is that my claim isn't a reason to push me.

You can also look at the Aries game as an example of me just giving up as wolf when the mech is against me. I'm not giving up here since I know I'm not wolf.

 

[Luka]

1) You're not dumb and trying to paint this as something beneath you is suspect
2) You're leaning heavily into demanding I "wolf case" you, which explicitly plays to your strengths - namely that you weren't scum until very recently snd the info is mostly mechanical on nature. In other words, you posing this framing is wack

1) "something beneath you" was throwing shade at you. It's not suspext to be frustrated at being pushed for little reason.
2) What info is mechanical? You haven't even cased me on mech. Also, the majority of my play is D2. Stop acting like that means anything.!

 

[Ultra]

All of you guys are tinfoilers. You're pushing me on what's possible, not probable. I fully admit that I could potentially be wolf here, if I was IC I wouldve just claimed without baiting a NK. But the fact of the matter is that my claim isn't a reason to push me.

You can also look at the Aries game as an example of me just giving up as wolf when the mech is against me. I'm not giving up here since I know I'm not wolf.

Polar's ability triggered the conversion of Adam and Eve. HIS SINGLE ABILITY. You expect me to buy that Eve is not exactly the neighbor in this equation when Polar and (by what you've admitted) have most of your abilities explicitly linked to each other

You are nicked.

 

[Luka]

I recall having you as scum d1 based on also correctly having you as scum d1 the game before, is that sufficient?

No since:
1) If you're agreeing with Ultra's push (you are) I was town D1
2) You called the way I went about today towny earlier

Try a little harder.

 

[Luka]

Polar's ability triggered the conversion of Adam and Eve. HIS SINGLE ABILITY. You expect me to buy that Eve is not exactly the neighbor in this equation when Polar and (by what you've admitted) have most of your abilities explicitly linked to each other

You are nicked.

Yup! Because the role was clearly intended to fake, and my ability is a notably non lethal ability.

I do expect you to believe it 110%. That aside, Ekko isn't such a shitty host to have a role that outs their partner upon flip I would hope lol.

 

[Ultra]

Like let's take a step back here and assess how this game apparently works - according to Polar's flipped role there is a SINGLE SCUM (or at least it looks that way, maybe it's a split role) to start the game and you can surmise that othee scum are additional conversions by whatever means

So the demand Luka is placing on "bro just solve" is inherently disingenious. He's trying to play the "let's just play normal mafia ignore claims haha"

But this isn't the game we're playing, so it's dicks