Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Day 5]

[KWEH]

bc indigo used the self destruction ability and i assume alexis was in his chat last night bc Alexis asked to be and also Alexis was super scummy role wise

It also says it kills everybody who played along with the become as gawds thing though. I haven't checked who went along and who should be dead and who isn't but proclaiming scum shot X player who died last night seems very unreliable to me?

 

[hime]

It also says it kills everybody who played along with the become as gawds thing though. I haven't checked who went along and who should be dead and who isn't but proclaiming scum shot X player who died last night seems very unreliable to me?

No it specifically says in the neighbor chat

 

[KWEH]

I think the logic is sketchy but hime is potentially self-resolving tonight so not gonna vote there anyway

@Crying bc no Cryo you mind running by me again why the people you listed are just about cleared mech-wise in your mind?

 

[KWEH]

No it specifically says in the neighbor chat

Oh my bad yeah okay

 

[The Orca]

3x Explosives - Once per night, you can target a player and detonate explosives at their location, destroying any passive kill protection they have and/or any active kill protection type ability used on them this cycle, rendering it ineffective that night.

To me this would signify, Hime or Kweh are scum. Mafia has protection

 

[Yoho]

Interrogated Flower of all people who's lock town to most, clappity clappity

All non-town who flipped so far have full fakes. Your character means nothing whatsoever.

I mean if we're talking about commanders, the central scum role (Red Girls) is yet to flip, that character being able to make grand proclamations to everybody oughta be somewhat within character? Heck maybe it's even meant to enable you to signal stuff to your future scummates?

🥱just cause the masses think she's town doesn't mean she is

🥱 for all I know you're the red girl

 

[KWEH]

To me this would signify, Hime or Kweh are scum. Mafia has protection

I think you oughta read that again. It says it destroys passive kill protection, which is something like a BP vest for example. I don't have that kind of protection. The other part of that role applies to everybody.

My protection is I activate the Commute and whoosh it's like I completely disappear from the game for one night, nothing can touch me. It's not passive though, it's x-shot and I gotta activate it

 

[KWEH]

🥱just cause the masses think she's town doesn't mean she is

🥱 for all I know you're the red girl

Feel free to - I'm gonna use a phrase y'all like very much over here - MAKE YOUR CASE then

 

[The Orca]

I think you oughta read that again. It says it destroys passive kill protection, which is something like a BP vest for example. I don't have that kind of protection. The other part of that role applies to everybody.

My protection is I activate the Commute and whoosh it's like I completely disappear from the game for one night, nothing can touch me. It's not passive though, it's x-shot and I gotta activate it

Says active protection as well. So do you think his role was all a negative to town? Or is it there to combat scum protections...either you or Hime?

 

[KWEH]

Says active protection as well. So do you think his role was all a negative to town? Or is it there to combat scum protections...either you or Hime?

It says any active protection used on them. So anybody who gets visited by any sort of protective role, not the one who uses them

 

[Yoho]

Feel free to - I'm gonna use a phrase y'all like very much over here - MAKE YOUR CASE then

My case is I'm innocent 😇

 

[KWEH]

My case is I'm innocent 😇

No further questions your honor

Yoho is innocent y'all, let's lynch someone else

 

[KWEH]

Preferably someone who's not innocent

I'm innocent as well btw so sorry but you can't lynch me

 

[York]

vote lynch Yoho

Commander White, as a character, is not innocent. She has plenty of blood on her hands. Therefore, Yoho cannot be Commander White. I rest my case

 

[Yoho]

vote lynch Yoho

Commander White, as a character, is not innocent. She has plenty of blood on her hands. Therefore, Yoho cannot be Commander White. I rest my case

Objection!

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

I think the logic is sketchy but hime is potentially self-resolving tonight so not gonna vote there anyway

@Crying bc no Cryo you mind running by me again why the people you listed are just about cleared mech-wise in your mind?

Yeah so Flower dueled the boss monster spawner. Orca reloaded Flower so idk why they would do that + why scum would be blocking day actions if Flower wasn’t successfully reloaded (no one else claims having day actions besides Hime). Hime has extended night which is exhausting for mafia AND has publicly announced boss monster protection and I doubt scum has a role that blocks itself. Yoho I believe the commander claim and mod messages are coming from them. He claims being able to speak with dead Yorha but that wasn’t confirmed.

Yoho is the only one I’m not confident in mech wise. And unless Flower and Orca lied about reloading (cuz there hasn’t been a 2nd duel and the blocked day actions could be used as an excuse for not dueling today) and unless Flower bussed Gadonk and Flower pretended to be a living machine at start of game and the “I have no partners” was Flower saying that they don’t have a scum chat then I doubt flower is mafia. That is really big tinfoil.

 

[Yoho]

Yeah so Flower dueled the boss monster spawner. Orca reloaded Flower so idk why they would do that + why scum would be blocking day actions if Flower wasn’t successfully reloaded (no one else claims having day actions besides Hime). Hime has extended night which is exhausting for mafia AND has publicly announced boss monster protection and I doubt scum has a role that blocks itself. Yoho I believe the commander claim and mod messages are coming from them. He claims being able to speak with dead Yorha but that wasn’t confirmed.

Yoho is the only one I’m not confident in mech wise. And unless Flower and Orca lied about reloading (cuz there hasn’t been a 2nd duel and the blocked day actions could be used as an excuse for not dueling today) and unless Flower bussed Gadonk and Flower pretended to be a living machine at start of game and the “I have no partners” was Flower saying that they don’t have a scum chat then I doubt flower is mafia. That is really big tinfoil.

I can't speak directly to the dead Yorha the dead Yorha leaves me messages that I receive to my servers one last message after they die

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

I’m ngl tho the fact that pretty much every wagon has been a runaway makes me think scum has L rizz and level 0 threadpull but it might be bc maj is on boo hoo

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

@KWEH why did u think rust wasn’t a problem until N2? Wasn’t rust mentioned / machines flipped showing rust was a problem?

 

[KWEH]

Yeah so Flower dueled the boss monster spawner. Orca reloaded Flower so idk why they would do that + why scum would be blocking day actions if Flower wasn’t successfully reloaded (no one else claims having day actions besides Hime). Hime has extended night which is exhausting for mafia AND has publicly announced boss monster protection and I doubt scum has a role that blocks itself. Yoho I believe the commander claim and mod messages are coming from them. He claims being able to speak with dead Yorha but that wasn’t confirmed.

Yoho is the only one I’m not confident in mech wise. And unless Flower and Orca lied about reloading (cuz there hasn’t been a 2nd duel and the blocked day actions could be used as an excuse for not dueling today) and unless Flower bussed Gadonk and Flower pretended to be a living machine at start of game and the “I have no partners” was Flower saying that they don’t have a scum chat then I doubt flower is mafia. That is really big tinfoil.

Mmm okay I don't agree with all of this but I do think your thought process tracks

We can't say for sure what the day action block is about, but I think it becomes significantly more sus after Flower refused to use her replenished duel yesterday. There's a few arrows starting to point her direction but I honestly don't wanna believe she dueled out her own teammate