Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Game End - Indie Victory]

red girls wasn't in the chat?
I don't have to be in the chat to see that Luka is Eve after Adam flipped and confirmed Eve is in the game. Matter of fact I figured it out just by looking at the flip. Fuji was all over the place telling people Luka was lock town, if Ultra and I are any less insistent on going Luka then Fuji probably doesn't give in.
 
Btw I still insist Polar knew he was gonna turn scum and he had me as one of his top scum reads, anybody feel like commenting on that or is it just one of those things people wanna sweep under the rug because it's inconvenient to the agenda?
 
The death mark is a scum role though, we know this. If I'm indy I still have no control over who's getting marked so in that case the fact both of us survived last night truly clears me from being mafia
u said ppl considered u town, that's not true
if u r mafia and being sussed as indie, either way u gotta find a way to clear urself

it makes zero sense for the real mark to be on u over me unless ur red girls and r trying to clear urself imo bc u were being sussed
scum needs to throw away a potential mislynch and keep me around instead who was more townread during that time

it logically doesnt make sense at all
 

Yoho

✌𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓢𝓲𝓶𝓹𝓵𝓲𝓬𝓲𝓽𝔂 𝓸𝓯 𝓛𝓲𝓯𝓮✌
Btw I still insist Polar knew he was gonna turn scum and he had me as one of his top scum reads, anybody feel like commenting on that or is it just one of those things people wanna sweep under the rug because it's inconvenient to the agenda?
State your case what makes you think he knew? Did his role say something that indicated that?
 
u said ppl considered u town, that's not true
if u r mafia and being sussed as indie, either way u gotta find a way to clear urself

it makes zero sense for the real mark to be on u over me unless ur red girls and r trying to clear urself imo bc u were being sussed
scum needs to throw away a potential mislynch and keep me around instead who was more townread during that time

it logically doesnt make sense at all
And what if people visit you and it looks like you were cured while Tweet looks sus af and it's assumed he had the fake mark? Makes no sense.
 
u said ppl considered u town, that's not true
if u r mafia and being sussed as indie, either way u gotta find a way to clear urself

it makes zero sense for the real mark to be on u over me unless ur red girls and r trying to clear urself imo bc u were being sussed
scum needs to throw away a potential mislynch and keep me around instead who was more townread during that time

it logically doesnt make sense at all
You were more townread than me before d5

My kinda humor right there lmfao
 
State your case what makes you think he knew? Did his role say something that indicated that?
His PM talks about transformation that can't be halted, and there's also a part of his role PM that is redacted. I kinda assume that if something in your role PM gets redacted upon flip, that clues you in on the fact that something suspicious is about to go down with you. If you also add the bit of flavor knowledge where those machines are fought - which in all fairness idk if Polar had that knowledge - then I for one upon seeing that role PM would follow, alright I'm town for now but probably not forever. If you know you're ultimately gonna be scum, you play scum from the start, you can't fool yourself by thinking but herp derp it says I'm town right now so I can just play town.
 
And what if people visit you and it looks like you were cured while Tweet looks sus af and it's assumed he had the fake mark? Makes no sense.
no one could visit me tho

ytw was faction killed
orca was out of shots
York was infected
RA was the lynch
kweh was going to commute
indigo was going to use his last shot the night before
Alexis visiting me would probs have the opposite effect cuz of his ability

the only person who wouldve been able to visit me last night was kweh and RA if he wasnt lynched
kweh already knows he wouldn't tho
 
I think I oughta try and look at things from a different perspective

It's kinda weird because I know now the real death mark was on me, meaning scum want me dead

But then there's also people in this thread who more or less randomly decided at the start of the phase where we got those marks inflicted on us that I'm suspicious

Does that mean the scum who tried to kill me isn't among those wanting to lynch me or what
 

Yoho

✌𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓢𝓲𝓶𝓹𝓵𝓲𝓬𝓲𝓽𝔂 𝓸𝓯 𝓛𝓲𝓯𝓮✌
His PM talks about transformation that can't be halted, and there's also a part of his role PM that is redacted. I kinda assume that if something in your role PM gets redacted upon flip, that clues you in on the fact that something suspicious is about to go down with you. If you also add the bit of flavor knowledge where those machines are fought - which in all fairness idk if Polar had that knowledge - then I for one upon seeing that role PM would follow, alright I'm town for now but probably not forever. If you know you're ultimately gonna be scum, you play scum from the start, you can't fool yourself by thinking but herp derp it says I'm town right now so I can just play town.
Hmm it's certainly something to think about
 
I cannot explain, probably a mistake?
Day 3 - Final Vote Count


Votes:
Yoho -> Gad
Charlie -> Gad > Pot
Tepig -> Gad > Pot
Crying -> AM > Alexis
Orca -> Tepig > Pot
Kweh -> RA > Pot
Ultra -> Flower > Yoho > Pot
Hime -> Pot
Indigo -> Yoho > Pot
Flower -> Pot
RA -> Pot
AM -> Pot


Count:
Pot = 9
(Charlie, Tepig, Hime, Orca, Ultra, Flower, Indigo, RA, AM, Kweh)
Gad = 1 (Yoho)
Alexis = 1 (Crying)


Sand Trail 3 Kick Out:
Rej = 0
No Kick = 4
(Charlie, Flower, Pot, Orca)


Duel Winner:
Flower = 14 (Tepig, Yoho, Pot, Indigo, Charlie, York, Flower, RA, Crying, Orca, Ultra, Alexis, Kweh, Hime)
Gad = 0




Please let me know if I made any mistakes.

Day 3 has ended. Everyone please stop posting.


Living Players [18/23]
  1. @Yoho
  2. @Alexis2282AE
  3. @Yo Tan Wa
  4. @Alwaysmind
  5. @York
  6. @The Orca
  7. @KWEH
  8. @Flower
  9. @Red Night @tepig19283
  10. @Random Asshole
  11. @Charlie
  12. @Pot Goblin
  13. @Ultra
  14. @Indigo
  15. @T-Pein™ @Rej
  16. @Crying bc no Cryo
  17. @Gadonkadonk
  18. @hime
Dead Players [5/23]
  1. @Butterscotch Sundae - YoRHA No. 9 Type S (9S) - YoRHa aligned - Lynched Day 1
  2. @Polar Bear - Adam - Machine Network aligned - Died Night 1
  3. @Luka - Eve - Machine Network aligned - Lynched Day 2
  4. @lemon.de - The Logic Virus - Machine Network aligned - Died Night 2
  5. @Fujishiro - ??? - YoRHa aligned - Consumed by Simone Day 3
Subs
  1. @Lord Melkor
  2. @Worst
  3. @Ratchet
  4. @Orwellian
Yep it was a mistake, puts me back to firmly leaning Hime
 
I say lemme toss all this role bullcrap aside and look at play again

Flower dueled out Gad, it's not her

Flower also made the point that Himes frustration at the modlynch yesterday seemed real so that's probably also a dead end

York made similar remarks. I kinda can't help but notice literally nobody is talking about them? Does everybody just randomly agree they're town because they are? (Not necessarily disagreeing but just someone tell me what that's about lmao)

Crying I had as town for reasons at multiple points along the way. Rn I can't remember what those points were but I know they had merit when I knew what they were. Plus the sudden realization that not every role claimed has to be town seemed real

Yoho... idk man, the role has town utility out the ass but there's just nothing there play-wise

Frankly the same goes for Orca

Long story short I wanna go Yoho or Orca today
 
Top