Role Madness Harry Potter: A World Of Wizardry Game Thread

[Charlie]

Sure

Claiming unprompted when fake claims usually can be switched around within scum team? Nah

 

[Yoho]

🤔🤔

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Ultra acting highly sus since he’s trying to keep the town from cooperating. Sure there’s risk but if everyone was keeping their locations hidden it’ll be much easier for scum to lie and manipulate the town.

i mean i like the dice roll too.
it's just kind of hard to verify.
feels like Ultra is trying to come up with some form of solution but ppl arent buying it.
Pros of random:
scum dont have perfect info on where ppl are going
it's easy to just roll a dice

cons of random:
town has no clue where dead ppl went
town doesnt have perfect info on where it visits
we aren't guaranteed to search the entire castle

 

[Ultra]

Why not lynching people going by RNG too

Ekko endorsed your plan Charles. Time to start asking questions...

 

[Charlie]

Why tho? I could just say this if Hermione is a fake claim of my team, have my team mates janitor kill me and the Hermione fake claim would ride the free clear for all eternity.

Ofc I know that I‘m Town, but if that’s your reason that’s easy to do as scum.

I mean, at some point we're going to figure out everyone's role and if there's no Hermione by now, you're basically outed so if you're scum, i don't think it's fake claim

 

[Ultra]

Claiming unprompted when fake claims usually can be switched around within scum team? Nah

Why are you assuming Alwaysmind is a calculated and thoughtful scum player?

 

[Sir Yasheen]

i mean i like the dice roll too.
it's just kind of hard to verify.
feels like Ultra is trying to come up with some form of solution but ppl arent buying it.
Pros of random:
scum dont have perfect info on where ppl are going
it's easy to just roll a dice

cons of random:
town has no clue where dead ppl went
town doesnt have perfect info on where it visits
we aren't guaranteed to search the entire castle

The issue is it’s impossible to verify and a game where scum are going to be lying to us constantly; not being able to verify any information means they can lie all they want.

Us having a method of getting trustworthy information and making it that scum will need to be careful with what lies they say is way more important to me

 

[Charlie]

Ekko endorsed your plan Charles. Time to start asking questions...

And Luka endorsed yours. Earlier today you responded to CW listing him as scum saying it's general consensus. Wdyt?

 

[Charlie]

Why are you assuming Alwaysmind is a calculated and thoughtful scum player?

He would have teammates who would say "dude, don't claim unprompted, we could need this claim later" in his pms

 

[Yoho]

If we're still talking about the location thing

If everyone just goes to a place that connects to their character we're more likely to cover more ground and find the horcruxes and if everyone follows this plan we can trace the location back to their character and figure out if they're scum or not

 

[Ultra]

Why would AM, who consistently makes a fuss about never claiming as town, telegraph his role Day 1 for no benefit

In fact it makes more sense for him to do this as scum

 

[Ultra]

He would have teammates who would say "dude, don't claim unprompted, we could need this claim later" in his pms

Very generous assumption of the average amount of scum coordination and competence

 

[Ultra]

It's like you've never played with Alwaysmind before. He is notoriously reticent about claiming his roles even in the face of death. He's always talking about how he was burned one time claiming and getting lynched anyway and so he never does it. Hello?

 

[Charlie]

Very generous assumption of the average amount of scum coordination and competence

Wasn't scum for like a year but it's optimistic af to think they're so clueless and uncoordinated imo.

 

[Charlie]

It's like you've never played with Alwaysmind before. He is notoriously reticent about claiming his roles even in the face of death. He's always talking about how he was burned one time claiming and getting lynched anyway and so he never does it. Hello?

Technically he hasn't claimed

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Why would AM, who consistently makes a fuss about never claiming as town, telegraph his role Day 1 for no benefit

In fact it makes more sense for him to do this as scum

last game AM was a scumbo who refusled to claim. but yeah that is weird that someone who doesn't like to claim is claiming

 

[Ultra]

Wasn't scum for like a year but it's optimistic af to think they're so clueless and uncoordinated imo.

Hahahaha

 

[Charlie]

last game AM was a scumbo who refusled to claim. but yeah that is weird that someone who doesn't like to claim is claiming

We will probably have a way to check it through mech anyway. Like, if someone could check whether he's Arthur Weasley or not, would be great. If not, i don't think he's Town.

 

[Flower]

Wasn't scum for like a year but it's optimistic af to think they're so clueless and uncoordinated imo.

Wait, was your most recent scum Game srsly HxH?

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

i personally like the idea of a buddy system and if it takes too long then move on to individual.

also idk why Mr. Reloaded claimed Voldemort if theyre town outside of trolling