Role Madness Harry Potter: A World Of Wizardry Game Thread

[Luka]

Hmmm.

I have some info, but I don't really know if it's worth claiming over.

@Indigo You have any ideas?

You were tamper immune last night ftr

 

[Charlie]

This is the problem with 2024 Mafia - I'm not being defensive. I'm outlining why your statement doesn't make sense to me. The intent is to have you defend your statement by outlining your thought process - not by playing it down. Whatever you read me as, you're going to need to explain why I as Mafia play around Polar that way, and I don't think anyone is going to be able to come up with a compelling angle. And if you can't, then it follows that I should be a town read, or at least, explicitly not Mafia.

Welp, I've seen other people saying this claim is na straight away. And scummate could hope for more people to back off by expressing doubt there. For example

 

[Charlie]

na

Bs

 

[Ultra]

Vote lynch Jag

Since Janitor is dead I want to get claims out of the inactive and scummier players, given the sheer volume wouldn't mind getting like 5 or so even if that's what it takes and there's no other info/leads. I think this is a pretty good start.

 

[Michelle]

Idk if the gamestate would allow any defense of the top wagon because it wouldn't be effective.

 

[Charlie]

smh Harry Potter is poison central you'd think there'd be a healer out there

If there wasn't healer, message wouldn't say he's going to die unless he's healed.

 

[Yoho]

Who are they?

Idk how much I defended Polar, I rather suspected Ultra from what I know but maybe you see things differently?

Ah I get yah, it's not that you were necessarily defending polar, you where just hard against Ultra?

 

[Michelle]

Vote lynch Jag

And probably going to sleep asap

 

[Yoho]

Vote lynch Jag

And probably going to sleep asap

Sleep well Michelle

 

[Michelle]

Ah I get yah, it's not that you were necessarily defending polar, you where just hard against Ultra?

Yes and mistrusted him

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

He's town tho

Mech?

 

[Michelle]

What the dead townies pushed?

 

[Luka]

Mech?

No, meta
He would have a higher presense as wolf imho, and play the game in a less content driven way. As well as being less confrontational

 

[Pot Goblin]

Vote Lynch Jaguark101

Red Night would be a good secondary if you want to put some votes on that @Mr. Reloaded

 

[Michelle]

I think a Mafia and a Serial make sense as the ones doing the kills. And I think Ekko actually fits the profile of Serial better - staying under the radar, not really solving, and the aforementioned kills. As Mafia, I would expect him to be a hit more careful in how he positions around Polar Bear, and generally take more care in his positions at large.

If we are not sure abt toDay's wagon we can always push Eķko

 

[Ultra]

Xlaw
Red Night
Seraphoenix
Jaguark101
Random Asshole

I'll narrow it down to these players specifically who I don't really have reservations about the potential value of their roles or whatever. Even if there's 3 or so town here it's whatever.

 

[Ratchet]

Welp, I've seen other people saying this claim is na straight away. And scummate could hope for more people to back off by expressing doubt there. For example

A Tracker isn't a claim that can just be dismissed out of hand. Generally, lynching investigative roles before they've had any investigations is suboptimal play, because if you're wrong, you lose information, and if you're right, you're not losing much by giving them a night, and their choice of targets could be informative.

And while it's true that a scum mate certainly could be doing that, I point to the fact that this claim came so late in the day that it was running the risk of not mastering, and indeed, did not matter in the end. If I'm going to look for a way to pivot off my mate, then I'm going to ask him to claim soon enough so I can do so. And if he doesn't, then I have no reason to move off of him. Eventually, it becomes untenable. Now you might not agree that I would always play it that way, but you have played enough games with me to know that I'm not a bad scum player- my actions as scum are going to be geared towards engineering an advantageous position for my team. So unless you can argue a plausible angle in which my actions were as such yesterday, then I think at the very least, any read on me should be "more likely town than scum".

 

[Charlie]

What the dead townies pushed?

For Yasheen it's Ultra and Alexis but tbh it wasn't anything specific. I'm not sure but he's one of candidates for triwizard Tournament. Not sure if he made it in. If so, maybe someone wanted to get his spot? Going to check York now

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Vote Red Night

 

[Ultra]

@Luka Why didn't you prove your messenger ability?