Role Madness Harry Potter: A World Of Wizardry Game Thread

Destroya

Destroya

‎
#3,121
#3,121
Ultra said:
Vote Dr. Watson

Next claim
Click to expand...
Crying bc no Cryo said:
im trying to do some ISOs starting from the smaller ones and moving up to the larger ones if i have time

So here's why I'm on the fence about Dr. Watson: I've played with super busy people before. They generally attempt to read and make reads, and that's p much exactly what's going on here. Also the fact that they treat their Polar vote as kind of just a shrugyeet to get things moving along for the game is not the reasoning I'd expect for scum to bus one of their top roles. The only thing really hanging me up here is the timing of the Polar vote. It looks awful and unnatural bc it happens before the readup. And it doesn't appear like Polar was being discussed when the vote happens. Now, I could be wrong cuz I don't know per se what Dr Watson has and hasn't read up on, but that vote timing just skeeves me out. I'm willing to be wrong on the slot if they're mafia and just let them live another day just bc they seem to actually be putting in an effort to play AND I've been wrong about super busy people in the past so. Keeping my eye out on this one but nothing conclusive. This slot will remain POE for me but I don't think I'll be actively pushing for it

Dr Watson (ISO Summary/notes)
- is dealing with an ear infection but has been trying to keep up
- calls Ultra a strong intuitive tr
- says Alexis is hard to read alignment
- their Polar vote is really weird. There's no progression on it plus 30 mins later they say they just got off work so presumably they were either at work or just finishing work when they voted Polar. So unless they spent all day stewing about how Polar is mafia and just had to let out their feelings during work then idk how Dr. Watson found Polar. idk if Polar was being discussed at all around the time they voted, and they say in a later post they haven't been able to read much so it makes it less likely for them to find Polar.
- the reasoning for the Polar vote is to shake some acorns out of the tree (I guess they just wanted to get info from a vote?)
- asks Seraph for some reads
- throws Shade on Stargate for not having anything to say and nothing to work off of. Originally I thought this statement and general abrasiveness was towny bc i sometimes feel the same way when there's like 100 pages of material and someone says "what do u mean there's nothing to work with". But on a second read it reads like shading.
- Asking Michelle why they treated Polar as almost lock town is a good question tho
Click to expand...
Vote Lynch @Dr. Watson

Come play, girlie. I haven't forgotten about you and the Melkor shit as well.
 
Yoho

Yoho

✌𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓢𝓲𝓶𝓹𝓵𝓲𝓬𝓲𝓽𝔂 𝓸𝓯 𝓛𝓲𝓯𝓮✌
‎
#3,124
#3,124
@Dr. Watson you're next on my interrogation list

3 simple questions

1- have you been following the game close enough to have a read if so whose your suspects

2- I don't recall you expressing an opinion that you thought polar was scum, what made you vote him in the end?

3. Are you a main character or some obscure side character no one cares about
 
Destroya

Destroya

‎
#3,127
#3,127
Pot Goblin said:
I left my vote on Luka as I figured he'd be good with a secondary wagon should lynch shenqnigans happen

I think I would take Destroya and Ratchet off that list personally

Stargate definitely got some points for sharin the census and leans more town than not for me. Only thing that comes to mind is that the census can indeed come from a scum role, they'd have no problem sharing it as it's pretty much free cred.

Not sayin it's the case here but it's not hard clearing if anything
Click to expand...
The one thing that bothers me about split teams is would they know how many members are on each side? Census could have been a way to let the split team know how many wolves there are. I don't know how much weight I'd give this theory, but I also am not sure how much town points I'd give just for revealing the census.
 
Ratchet

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
‎
#3,129
#3,129
Indigo said:
already did
Click to expand...
Okay well I watched Ultra last night and received results saying that you targeted him. Yours was the only name. So there are a few possibilities here:

1 - You're lying about targeting Kweh.
2 - Ultra was Busdriven with Kweh.
2a. You are the busdriver, and busdrive Kweh and Ultra.
2b. The busdriver has a Ninja passive, and thus only you showed up.

Problem with 2b is I think that's pretty overpowered. Busdrivers can't easily be caught, so giving them immunity to the main thing that can catch them out would be somewhat counterintuitive. If you haven't fully claimed, that's what your next post needs to be.
 
Ratchet

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
‎
#3,134
#3,134
Ratchet said:
Vote: Indigo

Occam's Razor would be Indigo is a scum jailer that prevented Ultra from being healed last night.
Click to expand...
Jailer might not be quite right, something that blocks the target and prevents them from being healed. Given that I got results, it can't be a full jail.
 
Destroya

Destroya

‎
#3,138
#3,138
Ratchet said:
Vote: Indigo

Occam's Razor would be Indigo is a scum jailer that prevented Ultra from being healed last night.
Click to expand...
Considering most roles seems to have multiple abilities, or pinged me that he only has one. I think he added he can't control his role later on, but he was even unsure of what that meant. He also said he has nothing else, so any further comments he has about his role will be interesting to see.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top