I didn’t know for sure; I was trying to gauge his reaction. In Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, Hagrid wins a dragon egg, and Hermione briefly helps care for it before it is smuggled out of Hogwarts by Charlie Weasley’s friends. Stargate18 claimed to be Hagrid. Initially, I thought Charlie might have been Hagrid, but after Stargate’s claim, I reconsidered and concluded that Charlie could possibly be Hermione. I then claimed they were Hermione to observe how Charlie would respond.
um

no?

didn't u win a trial in triwizard tourney bc u correctly guessed Hagrid on D2? What were the 4 names listed and which one did u guess? @Pot Goblin @Crowned Witch can u verify what Alexis says?

but Stargate claimed today (D3)?
 
Okay my bad. I didn't know we were playing with chimps:hapnoel:
I mean you're kind of assuming someone has to be braindead to counterclaim which is wrong and not even the point.

Because you're conflating someone outing themselves voluntarily vs in reaction to a certain thing. Most players aren't going to take someone else claiming their shit lying down. It takes experience to understand the nuance of the situation and to hold the cards as it's happening. You're speaking with the benefit of hindsight in a pure hypothetical. Wouldn't be surprised if you would actually do it if you were Harry.
 
ok i see that AM has decided to grace us with his incomprehensive nonsense. toss him the fk out of here already

toss watson in the future too, no idea what the hekko she talking about
How is this Watson character normally? I got some aggressive energy from them
I mean you're kind of assuming someone has to be braindead to counterclaim which is wrong and not even the point.

Because you're conflating someone outing themselves voluntarily vs in reaction to a certain thing. Most players aren't going to take someone else claiming their shit lying down. It takes experience to understand the nuance of the situation and to hold the cards as it's happening. You're speaking with the benefit of hindsight in a pure hypothetical. Wouldn't be surprised if you would actually do it if you were Harry.
Yeah no. If I have an important role I'm not going to squander it.
 
New locations opened for the Horcrux search in addition to the old ones:

Clock Tower
Clock Tower Courtyard
Stone Bridge
Stone Circle
Hagrid’s Hut
Viaduct
Viaduct Entrance
Fluffy’s Corridor
Library Forbidden Section
Mirror of Erised Room
Chamber of Secrets

Be sure to keep them in mind.


1- @Pot Goblin
2- @Sir Yasheen Justin Finch - Fletchley Killed Night 1
3- @KWEH
4- @Alwaysmind
5- @Indigo
6- @Polar Bear Nagini Lynched Day 1
7- @York Jacob Kowalski Killed Night 1
8- @Charlie
9- @Flower ??? Game Removed
10- @Alexis2282AE
11- @Yoho
12- @Xlaw
13- @Luka
14- @Mr. Reloaded
15- @Red Night
16- @The Orca
17- @Seraphoenix
18- @Dr. Watson
19- @Jesse Pinkman Replaced by @Crying bc no Cryo
20- @Yo Tan Wa
21- @Stargate18
22- @~UwU~
23- @Ratchet
24- @Jaguark101
25- @Ultra
26- @Emil
27- @Michelle
28- @Random Asshole
29- @Destroya
30- @Crowned Witch
@EkkoLoJinx
@tepig19283
@MUUGEN
going to viaduct tn btw
 
How is this Watson character normally? I got some aggressive energy from them

Yeah no. If I have an important role I'm not going to squander it.
So you're going to say and do nothing as someone just claims your role, and in no shape or form are you going to try and communicate the fact to anyone that they're lying?

Well that kind of also makes you a bad town player, doesn't it?

That's the point, it's not exactly "squandering" if you think someone lying confirms they are scum (as what tends to be the case), so most players will object. Maybe make a laughable attempt at disguising a counterclaim.

You're assuming most people would deduce that Crying is lying, as town, and there's no need to respond to such a thing. Silly.
 
So you're going to say and do nothing as someone just claims your role, and in no shape or form are you going to try and communicate the fact to anyone that they're lying?

Well that kind of also makes you a bad town player, doesn't it?

That's the point, it's not exactly "squandering" if you think someone lying confirms they are scum (as what tends to be the case), so most players will object. Maybe make a laughable attempt at disguising a counterclaim.

You're assuming most people would deduce that Crying is lying, as town, and there's no need to respond to such a thing. Silly.
 
basically, I've recieved message from someone who I believe is town

and that person isn't Luka

how likely is it that there're 2 town messagers?
When did u get this message? this post that i'm quoting was written an hour after Stargate claimed hagrid btw
The four listed names were Fujishiro, Charlie, Yo Tan Wa ,and Indigo. I guessed Charlie.


Yes, but that was before my message was sent today.
When did u send your message?
 
Top