Role Madness Harry Potter: A World Of Wizardry Game Thread

[Ultra]

i'd go die ig. i asked not to be cc'd

i was banking on being tr'd enough for real HP to be like "oh this guy is taking a bullet for me"

What the fuck does the bolded even mean

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

What do do suggest, I was ill the last couple of days and I am at work.

I'm all ears to muggle solutions.

At least full claim

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

also in general i couldn't resist the idea of potentially being in a room full of mafia and making them panic as HP claims and forces them to make reads all night long

 

[Ultra]

"Hey I'm claiming a role but don't counter claim me" doesn't advertise to mafia that you aren't in fact that role

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

What the fuck does the bolded even mean

i said "I'm HP. don't cc me" when i claimed HP

obviously ppl still believed it

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

or at least ppl entertained the idea all night long and were quick to sus me for it

 

[Ultra]

So the big problem is almost nobody here, I think, if they're Harry is going to quietly wait and abide by this gambit. Someone of considerable patience might, but there's almost nobody here who qualifies. It doesn't really matter that Crynig did this in a private chat, that information would be made public after. Also, there was like 10 people in there, so it's not even as if the possibility the real harry was in the chat was statistically irrelevant.

It's to the degree where I'd say with almost full confidence Harry Potter isn't in town, because otherwise a CC would have happened.

Which would make Harry a fake claim, and the fact that Crying both felt safe in "outting" themself as Harry Potter to bait people into doing shit to them a huge red flag.

 

[Ultra]

i said "I'm HP. don't cc me" when i claimed HP

obviously ppl still believed it

The only argument in your favor is that this is an incredibly bold thing to do as scum to be comfortable with pulling a juke like this

but it's made somewhat plausible if you know nobody will counter you

 

[Michelle]

oh i realized that can sound worst than it is

w-word is woman

I am a woman. Do you think that's insulting?

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

So the big problem is almost nobody here, I think, if they're Harry is going to quietly wait and abide by this gambit. Someone of considerable patience might, but there's almost nobody here who qualifies. It doesn't really matter that Crynig did this in a private chat, that information would be made public after. Also, there was like 10 people in there, so it's not even as if the possibility the real harry was in the chat was statistically irrelevant.

It's to the degree where I'd say with almost full confidence Harry Potter isn't in town, because otherwise a CC would have happened.

Which would make Harry a fake claim, and the fact that Crying both felt safe in "outting" themself as Harry Potter to bait people into doing shit to them a huge red flag.

I didn't feel safe doing it. it was a spur-of-the-moment plan and i told ppl don't cc me don't protect me, and i unclaimed it as soon as night actions were locked. we barely discussed it. i tried to keep the conversation focused on solving

 

[Michelle]

Well he claimed Draco, Draco while he was with the death eaters for a time it was mostly out of his control to be with them and the story point that Draco was ordered to kill Dumbledore makes me think Luka's win con is find and kill Dumbledore whihx if I'm right in my suspicions, I believe someone said they are Dumbledore and luka if he was paying attention can kill him tonight and win

Can be a fake claim.
I don't like his play and not many are suspecting him

 

[Ultra]

I didn't feel safe doing it. it was a spur-of-the-moment plan and i told ppl don't cc me don't protect me, and i unclaimed it as soon as night actions were locked. we barely discussed it. i tried to keep the conversation focused on solving

you are a sussy baka harry

that is all

 

[The Orca]

Your critique is completely irrelevant though. In fact it's not particularly hard to tell people what to do here. It's insufferable to play here because barely anyone tries or gives a fuck

Lmao. Well duh, its partly because of the game styles being more geared to moves and partly because you don't allow for others to be free to have their own thoughts most games. Like last game I and others were telling you, you were wrong on D1 and you just barreled into the town lynch. I had like 7/8 scum D1 lmao. People follow you just to follow you which from my view is so annoying, especially when you are wrong. But thats how you like it, you hate when someone else has a different opinion or way of solving games

 

[Seraphoenix]

Vote: Alwaysmind

You have him as POE fodder but vote for him just because someone asked? Sheep vote.

 

[Ultra]

People here claim and out themselves half the time completely voluntarily, no chance someone zips their lips and doesn't counterclaim just because you asked them to. Just isn't how people play here. I could buy the real HP maybe being very quiet about their claim but also being very obviously insistent that you were scum, absolute best case scenario

 

[Michelle]

I am once again asking you to play my POE game:
Claims I believe:
RA - mech clear by Jag
Stargate - Hagrid (consensus + 2x commute)
Charlie - Hermione. Investigator. is known to exist by Flower
Flower - Ron. dies instead of Hermione. Has protective stuff
Ratchet - Watcher + student (if UwU is a correct claim)
Emil - Sirius black. cleared(?) by Charlie.
Yoho - cleared by Charlie
Uwu - Umbridge
Ultra - SELF RESOLVES VIA POISON UNTIL HE DOESN'T
Crying - Reloader

Claims I don't believe:
Mr. Reloaded - Roleblocks ppl who target his target. Targeted Charlie N1 (I hope this isn't scum investigator but how else would Alexis know that Charlie is Hermione unless Alexis found out D2?). If the role is real tho it looks good for Mr. Reloaded to block Charlie though.
Alexis - claims redirector and then messenger. Idk how they knew who Hagrid or Hermione were.
Luka - Draco Malfoy. also a messenger who can give tamper immunity
Dr. Watson - can protect from vote manipulation and rolecrushing
Indigo - Roleblocker on odd nights. rolecrushes who targets them on even nights. I think this is 3p.

Unclaimed:
Michelle
PG
The Orca
KWEH
Seraph
CW
Destroya
YTW
AM
Muugen

So if I believe all 10 claims,
I would say KWEH, CW, Destroya, AM(?), YTW(?), Muugen(?) + 1 are maybe the other towns left?

Why AM in the left townies?

 

[Yoho]

Can be a fake claim.
I don't like his play and not many are suspecting him

Certainly possible, weather I'm right about him being the SK or not i still think he'd be a great lynch

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Why AM in the left townies?

he could be my HUSBAND if he claimed

 

[Seraphoenix]

So the big problem is almost nobody here, I think, if they're Harry is going to quietly wait and abide by this gambit. Someone of considerable patience might, but there's almost nobody here who qualifies. It doesn't really matter that Crynig did this in a private chat, that information would be made public after. Also, there was like 10 people in there, so it's not even as if the possibility the real harry was in the chat was statistically irrelevant.

It's to the degree where I'd say with almost full confidence Harry Potter isn't in town, because otherwise a CC would have happened.

Which would make Harry a fake claim, and the fact that Crying both felt safe in "outting" themself as Harry Potter to bait people into doing shit to them a huge red flag.

Voldemort and Harry are likely the two most important or powerful roles. If I were Harry I wouldn't counter claim so early in the game. That's asking for scum to kill you and gain a big advantage.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Before i lose senses aho e voring