The thread said he forged it. He either did or not.
Zoro tamed a bb in TB. Sorry, but that is not an acceptable feat at this point.
I can live with the "defeated the weilder part" if it was a fair fight and the weilder was still in prime. Other than that it sound like you are trying to weasle your way out of losing.
Anyways, let do it like you suggest.
1. Ryo made the blade black. I delete my account.
2. Ryo did not make the blade black. You get an avi of my choosing. I will not really pick one that gets you banned of course. Not permanently anyways.
3. Its one of the pussy conditions I quoted. You also win, but can only choose an avi for me.
Don't worry, no deletion for reasons said and also I don't like forcing people out of forums.
The part about "taming" Is more like Enma's than Shusui's. Zoro picked up Enma at random, but It would be dumb to say he doesn't "deserve" Enma and he's not his rightful and proper wielder, even though Enma didn't "born" with him.
If Ryo had done someting similar with the BB, there Is no reason to argue he is unfit or doesn't deserve the blade, as It Isn't with Zoro.
My whole reasoning behind this Is: Oda chose a BB willingly and was to give Ryo a high level "feat", be It becuase he forged It, defeated the last holder or tamed It. Thinking Oda Just made a mistake or could have given him a normal blade, but didn't, Is flawed in itself.
On the other hand, if Ryo just picked a sword random and didn't earn It, sure: that wouldn't be a feat and I would be wrong.