MangoSenpai

Arbiter of Truth
I'm starting to unironically believing Yoho is just scum here.
I'll do the unthinkable and actually make a case!

Let's start with the very start, he opens the game claiming he didn't know it started, even though it had started mere moments ago.
Oh shit I didn't know this started
While it seems a bit innocent on the surface, I'd argue that this is not really a townie approach to entering the thread; reasoning being that it feels forced and uninspired. Like he just have to say something, just to say something.
Has anyone come off as suspicious yet?
His very next post is also lazy and uninspired, asking if anyone has "come off as suspicious", while the game has barely even started yet. This again strikes me as performative, this early in the game it makes little sense to ask this question. Firstly if he really wanted to know, there was a measly few pages to read back - which would've taken 5 minutes max.
Second, he makes no attempt at actually looking for scums, nor is he really doing much of anything. Which again just makes me ask, why even ask the question in the first place.
Both please and thank you? Just for being polite

Vote lynch Charlie
Now I will admit that this point is not really exclusive to this game, and is possibly NAI, but in the bigger picture is yet another red flag in my book;
Yoho mindlessly follows Fuji on his attempt to strongarm the Lynch to Charlie after failing to inspire Watson to go along with his read. Yoho is not the only one who voted Charlie on Fuji's command, but I am singling him out in this context.

If you take into consideration that he came into the thread asking a question that he really had no interest in pursuing, and just lets himself mindlessly vote for Charlie with no questions asked or any thought of his own with it - It really paints a bad picture.

Flower
Killa
Alexis
This is his GTH list he gave me when I asked ^

When I asked him to elaborate he had this to say;
Because either He's right and she's scum and needs to go down the hole or he's wrong and is scum himself and trying to paint Flower scum so he'll go down the hole, also just because he's tunneling her doesn't automatically clear him if she does flip scum, scum tunneling one of their own is a common practice

As for Alexis I'm kicking him down for throwing me in prison last game
Alexis was clearly just a shoehorn pick here, which I feel is redundant to harp on about.

But his reasonings for his picks are just very surface level, and pretty much reads as him not really giving it much thought himself.
As he later will admit, he say he is fine with eliminating both, even though from his wording here he is implying that it is a SvT (scum vs town) interaction- so in other words it just seems like a very inelegant attempt at justifying eliminating them both without having to bear any responsibility for their flips.

When I asked "what other than their interactions can you point to lending credence to your picks?" He had this to say;
Nothing concrete just playing by ear and thinking about what I've noticed people doing in past games, once we get some actions and reactions I'll be able to get a better idea of exactly what I'm working with
Essentially saying there is nothing, which goes back to what I was just saying - he is just trying to justify eliminating someone, it doesn't really matter who.
I have no qualms flipping them both but I'd rather wait for more information to become available before making rash decisions especially given how careful we gotta be with lynching this game

So with this I am going to Vote Lynch Yoho
 
Based on tea leaves rn

Players Alive:
Yoho - Town
Dr. Watson - Town

MangoSenpai - Scum
Fujishiro - Town
Flower - Town
Muugen - Town
Alexis2282AE - Chills... (Town)

Michelle - Scum
York - Town
Ali v2 - Scum
AlwaysMind - Town
The Orca - Town
Polar Bear - Town
Naomi - Town

Mr Reloaded - Indie
~UwU~ - Scum
Stargate18 - Indie
Random Asshole - Scum
Charlie - Town
Ghostface Killa - Town

Grammaton - Indie
How do you put in scum someone like me who had no posts?
Otoh i would like to be scum with Mango but it's not happening.
And why do you think we have 3 indies?
Killa had a pretty intense tunneling on Flower early on which tunneling someone that hard that early seems strange and the possibility he's tunneling his own scum mate didn't escape my notice

Fushi is doing his usual Fushi thing and gathering the troops, I'm never sure if he's just doing it for funsies or if it's part if his character role so I got an eye there

Stargate randomly claimed vanilla town unprovoked and with no explanation which makes me think he's lying given that vanilla town Is a common fake claim I've seen a lot

That's where I'm at now,
Idk if their are good enough to consider them scum. Tunneling is not a crime after all. Fuji playing like usual means he can be town and Star just posted a joke
This (full reads = suspicious).
Thanks for posting it.
 

Yoho

✌𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓢𝓲𝓶𝓹𝓵𝓲𝓬𝓲𝓽𝔂 𝓸𝓯 𝓛𝓲𝓯𝓮✌
I'm starting to unironically believing Yoho is just scum here.
I'll do the unthinkable and actually make a case!

Let's start with the very start, he opens the game claiming he didn't know it started, even though it had started mere moments ago.

While it seems a bit innocent on the surface, I'd argue that this is not really a townie approach to entering the thread; reasoning being that it feels forced and uninspired. Like he just have to say something, just to say something.

His very next post is also lazy and uninspired, asking if anyone has "come off as suspicious", while the game has barely even started yet. This again strikes me as performative, this early in the game it makes little sense to ask this question. Firstly if he really wanted to know, there was a measly few pages to read back - which would've taken 5 minutes max.
Second, he makes no attempt at actually looking for scums, nor is he really doing much of anything. Which again just makes me ask, why even ask the question in the first place.

Now I will admit that this point is not really exclusive to this game, and is possibly NAI, but in the bigger picture is yet another red flag in my book;
Yoho mindlessly follows Fuji on his attempt to strongarm the Lynch to Charlie after failing to inspire Watson to go along with his read. Yoho is not the only one who voted Charlie on Fuji's command, but I am singling him out in this context.

If you take into consideration that he came into the thread asking a question that he really had no interest in pursuing, and just lets himself mindlessly vote for Charlie with no questions asked or any thought of his own with it - It really paints a bad picture.


This is his GTH list he gave me when I asked ^

When I asked him to elaborate he had this to say;

Alexis was clearly just a shoehorn pick here, which I feel is redundant to harp on about.

But his reasonings for his picks are just very surface level, and pretty much reads as him not really giving it much thought himself.
As he later will admit, he say he is fine with eliminating both, even though from his wording here he is implying that it is a SvT (scum vs town) interaction- so in other words it just seems like a very inelegant attempt at justifying eliminating them both without having to bear any responsibility for their flips.

When I asked "what other than their interactions can you point to lending credence to your picks?" He had this to say;

Essentially saying there is nothing, which goes back to what I was just saying - he is just trying to justify eliminating someone, it doesn't really matter who.



So with this I am going to Vote Lynch Yoho
Do you not agree with my approach of figuring out who scum could be?
 

MangoSenpai

Arbiter of Truth
What do you think about Pot, Mango?
Awfully little, I'm afraid.

All he have done in the way of contributing is his rainbow list, where he put me as scum - when I asked about it, he pretty much had no answer for it.

Which if you're going to make a rainbow list, how can you make a list you're not even able to justify, it makes me really question the point of even posting it.


I guess what I'm trying to say is that he's Null>Scumlean
 

Yoho

✌𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓢𝓲𝓶𝓹𝓵𝓲𝓬𝓲𝓽𝔂 𝓸𝓯 𝓛𝓲𝓯𝓮✌
And yes it doesn't matter who
What approach?

What have you done in way of trying to solve?
People asked my thoughts and I gave them

I shared my suspicions and gave my suspects

No need to leave pages of dialog to share my thoughts
 

MangoSenpai

Arbiter of Truth
To clean it up for better readability

Dr. Watson
MangoSenpai
AlwaysMind


York
Fujishiro
Flower
Naomi
Charlie
Ghostface Killa


Michelle
Ali v2
Pot Goblin
Random Asshole
Grammaton


The Orca
Polar Bear
Mr Reloaded


~UwU~
Stargate18


Muugen
Alexis2282AE
Yoho




(Blue = Null | Yellow/ Orange = scumlean | Light Green = Townlean | Green = Town)
This was my full list from earlier @Michelle
 

MangoSenpai

Arbiter of Truth
And yes it doesn't matter who
Slip of the century?


People asked my thoughts and I gave them

I shared my suspicions and gave my suspects

No need to leave pages of dialog to share my thoughts
What you're saying is that you are playing entirely rectionary. Essentially you're admitting to not contributing anything unless someone asks you directly for your thoughts.

And even when people ask you, you struggle to come up with content.

In what world is this going to help your case?
 

Yoho

✌𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓢𝓲𝓶𝓹𝓵𝓲𝓬𝓲𝓽𝔂 𝓸𝓯 𝓛𝓲𝓯𝓮✌
Slip of the century?



What you're saying is that you are playing entirely rectionary. Essentially you're admitting to not contributing anything unless someone asks you directly for your thoughts.

And even when people ask you, you struggle to come up with content.

In what world is this going to help your case?
No no not a slip, anyone can die since I don't know for sure whose town and whose scum

I read and follow along some people are chiefs and lead the vote others watch from the shadows and decide what to do on their own giving reasons for their vote when they need to
 
Yoho is innocent
Innocent and good noodle are two different things. Innocent are when you have not committed a crime, yet.

No one has died yet. Why are you so worried about pleading innocence?

This is like saying that you didn't eat the cookie to your parents when its obvious that you did.
 

Yoho

✌𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓢𝓲𝓶𝓹𝓵𝓲𝓬𝓲𝓽𝔂 𝓸𝓯 𝓛𝓲𝓯𝓮✌
Innocent and good noodle are two different things. Innocent are when you have not committed a crime, yet.

No one has died yet. Why are you so worried about pleading innocence?

This is like saying that you didn't eat the cookie to your parents when its obvious that you did.
🤔 interesting analogy
 

Yoho

✌𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓢𝓲𝓶𝓹𝓵𝓲𝓬𝓲𝓽𝔂 𝓸𝓯 𝓛𝓲𝓯𝓮✌
So what does your cookies or noodles do?
Well if it helps clear my name, I'm Accelerator- Affiliation GROUP

That's all I can say for now,

As for your questions my cookies and noodles both get eaten of course
 
Top