Role Madness A Certain Magical Mafia II - Game Thread

[Random Asshole]

Root beer floats are overrated

You haven't had a good Root Beer float

 

[Ghostface Killa]

Hmmmm🧐

whats so shocking about that?

 

[Polar Bear]

Just fishing for a straight answer.

Whats with a coherent and normal playing Alexis vs the usual pure jibberish Alexis?

 

[The Orca]

We could say the same for you @The Orca you need to produce a read list please.

Pass

 

[The Orca]

Why won't you elaborate?

Does it matter right now?

 

[Ghostface Killa]

Pass

you willingly refusing to produce reads?

 

[Alexis2282AE]

Does it matter right now?

It will.

 

[Pot Goblin]

This (full reads = suspicious).

I was asked to give gun to head reads

 

[The Orca]

you willingly refusing to produce reads?

You willingly refusing to read?

 

[Ghostface Killa]

You willingly refusing to read?

I believe I asked you to produce reads and you refused. I'm reading quite fine. You not so much. Produce some reads.

 

[The Orca]

I believe I asked you to produce reads and you refused. I'm reading quite fine. You not so much. Produce some reads.

Cool. As long as you read the reads I have produced. Sounds like we are on the same page

 

[Ghostface Killa]

Cool. As long as you read the reads I have produced. Sounds like we are on the same page

I see no reads list. I am waiting.

 

[Ghostface Killa]

tbh, i really don't like painting this as t vs s, no matter what here

like, being reluctant to claim in this setup is a good thing imo and killa sounds more like some power level cop trying to catch flower in a lie or sth because he scum reads her rather than scum fishing for roles (he'd fish for everyone's role, not just flowers)

for me it looks like t vs t and from what you wrote i read it as "let's flip one and if they're town (or even scum tbh), let's flip other one" .-. Like, if you had to shoot one of them, which one is scum? Pick a side if you think there's scum :o

I seemed to miss this in my readback, but would have replied. No, I am not a cop or power level cop.

 

[The Orca]

I see no reads list. I am waiting.

Clearly you arent reading, sad. I've listed and explained probably 6-7 reads so far

 

[Ghostface Killa]

Clearly you arent reading, sad. I've listed and explained probably 6-7 reads so far

 

[Ali v2]

As soon as I pick up my waifu, I will be reading every single post, whether shit post or not mofos

 

[MangoSenpai]

I believe Stargate and Orca

So that makes mango scum?

I feel silly for asking this, but this is a joke right?

He was frozen in skoom chat.

Damn, I ended up reading the Arcane game. God damn I make myself laugh so much sometimes

What a fun game that was.
So you will have to excuse me if I'm not in peak condition right now, I have read over 300 pages from that game tonight

Yoho - Acting towny, making solid reads and points throughout, that + good, non-defensive reaction to being voted is giving me very good vibes.

Are you refering to his GTH reads?
Otherwise I'm not sure if I'm really agreeing with this assesment, but I'll allow you to elaborate

UwU - Has made several firm reads, including more detailied points about activity and behaviour.

From my memory (not reliable atm) he hasn't made any strong reads, but he has called me out for not "living up to expectations"

York - posting some content, made a good point about my VT claim, has good vibes so far.

Generally agree

MangoSenpai - Has made a lot of solid points.

Based

Flower - Very low post-to-read ratio, but overall content seems towny.

Dr. Watson - I very much like the point about Charlie.

What was the point about charlie?

Naomi - As much as I disagree with only scum being AFK (some people just have a crippling addiction to Warframe and Balatro instead). Yoho vote is odd, but everything else seems good.

Why is Yoho vote odd?
Also I will concur that being AFK is not exclusive to scum, but mafia tends to be more prone to being AFK than town is by nature.

Mr. Reloaded - Either town joking or an incredibly brave scum. Even if they were scum, scum!Reloaded would almost certainly claim town as their teammates, so NAI for anyone else.

Polar Bear - Not much content yet, but has made an attempt to push.

Fujishiro - Pretty much just shitposting.

Ghostface Killa - not much content, just lots of attempts to push Fujishiro. Very likely the two are on opposite alignments, feels a bit too consistent/reasoned for w/w theatre.

This is false, Killa has pretty much been fixated on Flower/ Gram (which the latter hasn't posted yet)

Charlie - Made some very good points - mostly votecounts being NAI, pointing out Flower's odd claim, etc.

Alwaysmind - While PRs are less important here, behaviour around Polar Bear, including making a claim about their role based on little evidence, seems odd?

What claim are you refering to?

Pot Goblin - Hesistant to make reads, and main readslist is made purely on vibes (meaning they don't have to explain them). Not a full scumread yet, but this is pretty scummy NGL.

The Orca - Isn't acting particularly scummy - but saying their role doesn't fit their character is odd - my role makes perfect sense as a VT, so theirs seemingly not so feels off to me, as does the weird hesistancy to reveal their passive until called out on it. Not a full scumread yet, but I'd like to know how, exactly, it doesn't fit their character, since its not a complaint anyone else has had.

So I take it that you are by this saying that you do not associate with Orca - in other words, what he flips is independent of your alignment?

Alexis - other than self-voting, hasn't provided any reads, or followed up on any of the few pushes made, and has voted several times without explanations. Feels like scum attempting to appear active through voting activity without needing to vote.

Ratchet - is responsible for every death that will happen throughout this game - hard scumread.

We should tranquilize Ratchet before it's too late..

🤧why you asking me specifically

I haven't come to a conclusion yet, I work better when there's actions but right now I have an eye on Flower, Killa, Fushi, Stargate

Those 4 are the ones I'm watching but I don't have a scum or town core as of now

What happened to Alexis?

Why won't you elaborate?

Same to you, why did you ignore my question - what made you vote for Fuji when you did?

This (full reads = suspicious).

What about that list pings you the most?

 

[Alwaysmind]

Whats with a coherent and normal playing Alexis vs the usual pure jibberish Alexis?

can you, like, not insult people's syntaxes?

 

[Yoho]

I feel silly for asking this, but this is a joke right?

Damn, I ended up reading the Arcane game. God damn I make myself laugh so much sometimes

What a fun game that was.
So you will have to excuse me if I'm not in peak condition right now, I have read over 300 pages from that game tonight

Are you refering to his GTH reads?
Otherwise I'm not sure if I'm really agreeing with this assesment, but I'll allow you to elaborate


From my memory (not reliable atm) he hasn't made any strong reads, but he has called me out for not "living up to expectations"

Generally agree

Based


What was the point about charlie?

Why is Yoho vote odd?
Also I will concur that being AFK is not exclusive to scum, but mafia tends to be more prone to being AFK than town is by nature.




This is false, Killa has pretty much been fixated on Flower/ Gram (which the latter hasn't posted yet)


What claim are you refering to?


So I take it that you are by this saying that you do not associate with Orca - in other words, what he flips is independent of your alignment?


We should tranquilize Ratchet before it's too late..

What happened to Alexis?

Same to you, why did you ignore my question - what made you vote for Fuji when you did?

What about that list pings you the most?

Alexis wasn't a scum read i just kicked him in the hole for locking me up

 

[Polar Bear]

can you, like, not insult people's syntaxes?