Powers & Abilities Debunking Literally Every Argument Against Ryokugyu’s Black Blade UPDATE: Remembering The Fallen

Does Ryokugyu Have A Black Blade?


  • Total voters
    231
Are those real metal swords or biscuits?

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Biscuits.



:pepehawk:



.
Is Cracker another character?

Has Cracker another Power?

Has he a specific reason to do It?

Most importantly: doesn't Cracker have the real sword himself, using the fruit only to give his bisquits with copies of his sword
:milaugh:?

So, another failure.
 
Last edited:
The funny thing is, Greenbull's sword being made out of wood isn't even a legitimate argument to counter it being a sword. Weapons are named for their function, not their material.

Take a mace. A mace is a melee weapon with a weighted head designed primarily to inflict blunt force trauma.

A mace can be made entirely out of wood, entirely out of metal, have a wooden handle with a metal head or a wooden handle with a stone head. As long as the function is the same and it can perform said function then it doesn't matter what it is made out of, it is still a mace.

Same with bows. They can be made of wood or carbon fibre. Cultures with limited access to wood had to get creative with materials like animal horn and sinew. Regardless of what they are made out of, they are ranged weapons designed to fire arrows. Again, bows are named for their function, not for what they are made out of.

Meanwhile in One Piece, you have a man that can make biscuit as hard as steel and then precisely recreate his metal sword using biscuit equal in strength to steel. He then uses that weapon exactly like his metal sword because it is functionally the same.

That isn't a "fake" sword, that is just straight up a sword.

If biscuits can be sharp enough and strong enough to be used as swords in this universe, then so can wood. It would still be a sword.
I don't think you realize it but your post just help make the wooden sword argument.

If a YC level character with a biscuit DF can create swords, armor and shields out of biscuits as hard and strong as steel that can be used in battle. Then a top tier admiral with wood df would be able to create harder and stronger weapons. There is evidence supporting that claim.

GB was confident he could completely pierce Momo dragon form with his wood df power. Momo df power is supposed to be identical to Kaido's. GB took an ACoC hit to the head from Yamato club and it didn't break his wood body into pieces.

I'm not saying Cracker biscuit swords are not real weapons. I'm saying they're not real metal swords.


Is Cracker another character?

Has Cracker another Power?

Has he a specific reason to od It?

Most importantly: doesn't Cracker have the real sword himslef, using the fruit only to arm his bisquits with copies of his sword
:milaugh:?

So, another failure.
Has GB stated his weapon is black blade? No.

Has any other character stated GB weapon is a black blade? No.

Did GB wood take a ACoC club attack without breaking? Yes.

Most importantly, did GB use a wooden weapon as a kid? Yes.

Another failure.
 
I don't think you realize it but your post just help make the wooden sword argument.

If a YC level character with a biscuit DF can create swords, armor and shields out of biscuits as hard and strong as steel that can be used in battle. Then a top tier admiral with wood df would be able to create harder and stronger weapons. There is evidence supporting that claim.

GB was confident he could completely pierce Momo dragon form with his wood df power. Momo df power is supposed to be identical to Kaido's. GB took an ACoC hit to the head from Yamato club and it didn't break his wood body into pieces.

I'm not saying Cracker biscuit swords are not real weapons. I'm saying they're not real metal swords.




Has GB stated his weapon is black blade? No.

Has any other character stated GB weapon is a black blade? No.

Did GB wood take a ACoC club attack without breaking? Yes.

Most importantly, did GB use a wooden weapon as a kid? Yes.

Another failure.
 
I don't think you realize it but your post just help make the wooden sword argument.

If a YC level character with a biscuit DF can create swords, armor and shields out of biscuits as hard and strong as steel that can be used in battle. Then a top tier admiral with wood df would be able to create harder and stronger weapons. There is evidence supporting that claim.

GB was confident he could completely pierce Momo dragon form with his wood df power. Momo df power is supposed to be identical to Kaido's. GB took an ACoC hit to the head from Yamato club and it didn't break his wood body into pieces.

I'm not saying Cracker biscuit swords are not real weapons. I'm saying they're not real metal swords.




Has GB stated his weapon is black blade? No.

Has any other character stated GB weapon is a black blade? No.

Did GB wood take a ACoC club attack without breaking? Yes.

Most importantly, did GB use a wooden weapon as a kid? Yes.

Another failure.
So, again, this:



And the L goes on.

Btw, do we already have a bet on this?
 
I don't give a shit tbh lol
But when it comes to evidence and logic, he sure as shit has a black blade, a blade that is black
The only canon color scheme is the one used by Oda and Oda has not yet colored Ryukogyus blade.

It could be considered semi-canon at best and even that is a stretch since its officially stated (for real this time) that the colored manga and anime use their own color scheme until a color spread or cover shows the actual color scheme. Which has not happened yet.

Or does Marco have black hair?
 
Last edited:
Top