Role Madness A Certain Magical Mafia II - Game Thread

[Michelle]

Fushi
Reloaded
York
Michelle
Flower

5 main towns

Naomi
Muugen
Mango
Watson
Uwu

Could be town but I'm not quite convinced

Alexis and Yo Tan- one hasn't posted yet and the other hasn't posted in a while so no read at all on those two


Everyone else likely scum

Expand a little on your reads please @Yoho

 

[Random Asshole]

The question remains, which shot was allegedly blocked. Mafia, Vig or the Worm?

Unless they lied about the kill being blocked.

The kill block was publicly posted

 

[Random Asshole]

Ghostface Killa, Shirai Kuroko, a Town (Science) Commuter Esper Cop, was killed.

Spoiler: Kuroko Data File

Power Level - Level 4
Affiliation - Judgement
Esper Power - Teleporter

The Orca, Yuzuriha Ringo, a Town (Science) Loved [Townie] (SCHOOL Member), was killed.

Spoiler: Ringo Data File

Power Level - Level 2
Affiliation - SCHOOL
Esper Power - Telekinesis

Someone tried to kill Random Asshole, but it failed.

It is Day 2. With 19 alive, it is 10 to lynch. You have approx 72 hours remaining.

Countdown
​

Spoiler: Mentions

@Yoho
@Dr. Watson
@MangoSenpai
@Fujishiro
@Flower
@MUUGEN
@Alexis2282AE
@Michelle
@York
@Alwaysmind
@The Orca
@Polar Bear
@Naomi
@Mr. Reloaded
@~UwU~
@Stargate18
@Pot Goblin
@Random Asshole
@Charlie
@Ghostface Killa
@Yo Tan Wa

​

@Alwaysmind

 

[Michelle]

Nao probably Town, too.

Why?

Spun a wheel for who is scum and I spun it thrice. Got Alexis twice.

Vote Lynch Alexis.

This is weird

Spoiler

You tagged me in two posts, one was about voting for Mr. Reloaded (seems like a solid choice, but I still think Orca is scummier, will change if it looks like its at risk), and the other asking for reads on 6 users (none of them have posted enough to be changed from my readlist).

To summarize the relevant reads:

York seems to be solving, probably my favourite of the six.
UwU - ditto. Neither have posted much recently, but they've at least posted something of value.
Reloaded - The long joke about being scum makes me think town, simply because it would an incredibly risky move putting so much spotlight on yourself as scum.
Polar Bear is at least doing something by questioning people - wouldn't vote right now, but not a full-on townread.
Random Asshole and Ali have posted so little it's not worth reading anything into their posts IMO. I have to assume if they're scum, wolfchat would have made them do something by now, at least?

Scum chat pings are not real. No one can convince RA to post even if when he is town and gathers some game interest he plays very good and he also had good presence in past scum games.
We either lynch him or we give him some time.

Spoiler

York improved yeah she can go to the town pile UwU hasnt done anything since I made this POE. Reloaded can and will open scum as scum he did it before, also not a fan of their claim and their non solving attitude, he says hes burned out but he can be scum thats burned out. Polar Bear is scum reading reloaded so depending on Reloadeds alignment this could be good or bad. He also scum reads Mango who I town read and Michelle who I think could be town.

RA is just process of elimination from my part, Ali was scum last game on OLF and he had a bad time he couldve rolled scum again this game and just had low motivation to post.

Tell me why you TR York pls

The death of 3 towns this is a tragedy

Yeah. What you'll do about it?

Ali was also town i was counting him

Hmm

yoho new there was 3 kills.

even though showed 2, and later ratchet update attempted fail kill.


yoho scum.

I had the same thought

can we yeet muugen. he scum.

my instincts is 100%

I hope

oh so you're certain of it, how's that?

I am. Bab vibes

I’ve already stated I can clear myself so you’re really trying to bark up the wrong tree here.

Do it now pls

I can see Muugen being scum but his activity is NAI, I have a bigger issue with him voting me of all people after last phase.

Can you tell me about a game where Muugen was town inactive?

finally someone sees yoho evil beside me, even with his claim. I don't see anything ping me town.

he came into thread stating 3 kills before ratchet updated 3rd attempted kill. there was no mention of 3 before yoho stated 3 kills.

If Yoho is scum this kind of clears Naomi, but if he is town I don't like the focus only on this thing

Players Alive:
Yoho
Dr. Watson
MangoSenpai
Fujishiro
Flower
Muugen
Alexis2282AE
Michelle
York
AlwaysMind
Polar Bear
Naomi
Mr Reloaded
~UwU~
Stargate18
Pot Goblin
Random Asshole
Charlie
Yo Tan Wa

What blue means?

This would be my POE order, I need to reread last phase.

Tier 1: Reloaded, RA
Tier 2: Yoho, Michelle, Charlie
Tier 3: Muugen

I have the reverse order.
I would start with Miugen of he can't clean himself

I read Mango say that Yohos character could be a linchpin if so maybe protects went to him instead of Ghostface.

Probably, sadly. The lynch pin discussion is not going to give us many clues unfortunately

scum leans
alex,yoho,muugen,michelle,yoho(made it worse when he said 3 kills before it was even updated)

will add ra, depending what he says.

Isn't this too simple? Like consensus reads.

Your PoE:
Yoho: yeah, that's fine, let's kill him. Him pestering Reloaded to speculate about who the vig is is also very weird

Reloaded: I don't really have a strong opinion on him but his flip would give us a very clear view of the D1 situation and, if he is town, we aren't really losing much. Sorry Reloaded

Michelle: I don't even know if I know what scum Michelle looks like. I do agree it seems odd to see her this follow-the-leader-y though

Charlie: Don't have many feelings on Chuck this game tbh. Kinda depends on if Reloaded is scum, ig(preferred Orca wagon to Reloaded(why yes, I am a hypocrite))

Muugen: more like MEH-Gen. Not helpful at all. Which isn't necessarily indicative for him but it is irritating


my own personal thoughts outside of those:

Nothing but gut reads, baby. AM and Polar both feel weird to me. Can't tell you why it's just my intuition

I don't like this. There's no conviction in anything York says.

Think Killa was from Scum since he gave game info and seemed generally townie
Orca was probably vigged since he was the alternate wagon to Ali

Can you share some reads?

Spoiler

Thank you, I appreciate it.

Looking at the fast string of votes I found suspicious for the Ali wagon (Pot Goblin to Yoho, all of which occured a 5 minute period):
Dr. Watson - Has posted a lot, but not much content in them. Only sheeped wagons.
Pot Goblin - no posts leap out as bad, posted just before suspicious period, voted by Alexis without context.
Flower - Only joined existing wagons, openly asked others who to vote for, stated to be playing on low energy.
Mr. Reloaded - ...Seems scummy, but has a good point in that claiming a 3rd vanilla role is a bad fakeclaim, and the failed kill seems odd - since Orca was a likely miselim D2, scum probably wouldn't kill Orca - so its safe to assume Orca was indeed a vig kill. So, either we have 2 town vigilantes, we have a serial killer, or Reloaded is town.
Naomi - reads look good, has been actively contributing to town.
Alexis - lowposter, didn't post for 12 hours before joining the wagon, hasn't posted after that except to join a new wagon. 100% scumread here.
Yoho - potential slip with the 3 town deaths line earlier, not much solving otherwise.

I'll check the Orca wagon for any similar fast periods.

I like this post

The issue is was that it was a really really bad thing to do especially if you're town. You do not under any circumstances want to try and lure out the vig. Or even speculate who it could be. You're helping scum doing that.

This is correct

You didn't deny being scum, that's sus

Good point

 

[Michelle]

Vote lynch Muugen

For now

 

[Yoho]

I fell asleep,anything happen?

 

[Michelle]

The turn against Fuji looks bad for Muugen.

Ghostface dead N1 also shows to him being scum imo.

 

[Michelle]

I fell asleep,anything happen?

No, but answer me pls

 

[Yoho]

No, but answer me pls

What answers do you seek

 

[Michelle]

What answers do you seek

Anything that comes from your mind related to my previous post where I quoted you

 

[Yoho]

Expand a little on your reads please @Yoho

Oke so starting with Fushi

I think Fushi is town because I don't think Scum Fushi would be so passionate about trying to solve and lead the people I think he would of just left Orca to the wolf's and went after someone that would be more obvious scum, him pushing for Ali who was low posting anyway was a fair sacrifice and thinking he's scum was understandable

Reloaded and York are mostly just vibes, but i think if York was scum she'd have a better performance

You- tbh I don't think I've ever seen Scumchelle and you're playing the same way I usually see you play thus putting you town


Flower is the one I'm least sure about mostly because I think town Flower would be much more active than she is, but I also think scum Flower would be trying to push people more


That's my current thought process

 

[Yoho]

Yeah. What you'll do about it?

Avenge them of course

 

[Alwaysmind]

@Alwaysmind

my bad, I missed that part of the post.

 

[Alwaysmind]

Vote lynch Fuji

In case this was missed.

 

[Random Asshole]

my bad, I missed that part of the post.

You're good lol

 

[Flower]

Flowers vote history is disgusting honestly lol. @Flower I need you to do more today sis.

Can’t do much the first 48h lmao. I‘m on my business trip today and tomorrow.

 

[Flower]

I check the game again when I‘m on the train later.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Hello ya'all

 

[MangoSenpai]

Just here to say I am away, I'll be back home tomorrow evening (local).

I have read most of today, but on the phone so I'll try to engage when I can

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Just here to say I am away, I'll be back home tomorrow evening (local).

I have read most of today, but on the phone so I'll try to engage when I can