Role Madness A Certain Magical Mafia II - Game Thread
Aye aye@Yoho
@Dr. Watson
@MangoSenpai
@MUUGEN
Michelle
@York
@Alwaysmind
@Polar Bear
@Naomi
@Mr. Reloaded
@~UwU~
@Stargate18
@Pot Goblin
@Yo Tan Wa
Let's make an exercise, can everyone post their PoE with a short explanation?
I know some of you already posted but please answer at this with complete Poe and short reasons for it
@Dr. Watson
@MangoSenpai
@MUUGEN
Michelle
@York
@Alwaysmind
@Polar Bear
@Naomi
@Mr. Reloaded
@~UwU~
@Stargate18
@Pot Goblin
@Yo Tan Wa
Let's make an exercise, can everyone post their PoE with a short explanation?
I know some of you already posted but please answer at this with complete Poe and short reasons for it
Zero hesitancy, yes agreed on that with Mango.
Naomi defense on Flower, was hardcore. Beats me, though i expect townie Naomi to also do that for Flowa. If that's your sole reason, it's not a strong one.
How about checking how many players have Naomi sussed in this game, or thrown shade at, for me. I feel death to try that with heavy posters in my mobile.
Her because, i strongly feel the approach towards me did not feel genuine. No interactions or intent to solve me, ignored my question. Linking with Charlie flip for no reason.
Alexis tracked Yoho doing nothing did you mean him? I forgot the other person he had tracked, don't think it was Reloaded.
As for Uwu, Watson, n rest i need to iso these as well. I get less time so want the dayphase to run to completion, maybe I'll manage then.
For AM, idc if a player survives based on inactivity/irl reasons I don't mind scums winning that way, i play to be right on players.
The read on Polar is from last day phase only, i didn't read anything noteworthy this phase.
I can look into his posts again if you feel iffy on him, but he was my first town read this game. Usually they are always right, Michelle. They also joined quickly on Flower lynch, and had her as his top scum read.
Naomi defense on Flower, was hardcore. Beats me, though i expect townie Naomi to also do that for Flowa. If that's your sole reason, it's not a strong one.
How about checking how many players have Naomi sussed in this game, or thrown shade at, for me. I feel death to try that with heavy posters in my mobile.
Her because, i strongly feel the approach towards me did not feel genuine. No interactions or intent to solve me, ignored my question. Linking with Charlie flip for no reason.
Alexis tracked Yoho doing nothing did you mean him? I forgot the other person he had tracked, don't think it was Reloaded.
As for Uwu, Watson, n rest i need to iso these as well. I get less time so want the dayphase to run to completion, maybe I'll manage then.
For AM, idc if a player survives based on inactivity/irl reasons I don't mind scums winning that way, i play to be right on players.
The read on Polar is from last day phase only, i didn't read anything noteworthy this phase.
I can look into his posts again if you feel iffy on him, but he was my first town read this game. Usually they are always right, Michelle. They also joined quickly on Flower lynch, and had her as his top scum read.
It was Orca.
Was linking Fuji earlier as well, lol
Incomplete Iso, but early Flower n Charlie defense.
Townie posts,
Alexis was getting voted when he said it. Immediately after Reloaded says it, don't feels alligned with Charlie. Yoho also says it, but it's repeated at that point.
Alexis legacy were Naomi and Reloaded.
Was linking Fuji earlier as well, lol
Incomplete Iso, but early Flower n Charlie defense.
Townie posts,
Alexis was getting voted when he said it. Immediately after Reloaded says it, don't feels alligned with Charlie. Yoho also says it, but it's repeated at that point.
Alexis legacy were Naomi and Reloaded.
I gotcha
For me
Naomi- most of her reasonings for scum reading people are weak and seems like she's mainly just following others
Mango- he said Charlie's flip cleared Naomi but I just isoed them both and skim and scanned both of their text and Charlie had Naomi as a GTH town and Naomi was just voting Charlie because of Yorks efforts so I don't see how that flip cleared Naomi
Reloaded may also fallen down because when I asked why Charlie's flip clears Naomi he said it's cause Charlie was tunneling her, I was watching solar opposites at the time so didn't think to much of it, but after Iso both Charlie and Naomi just now I don't see any signs of Tunneling
Seems to me after my investigations those two where trying to cover for her
Am
Stargate
Polar
Uwu
Those 4 aren't necessarily Scum but feels to me they're kinda just skating by, safe to say at least one of those 4 are scum
For me
Naomi- most of her reasonings for scum reading people are weak and seems like she's mainly just following others
Mango- he said Charlie's flip cleared Naomi but I just isoed them both and skim and scanned both of their text and Charlie had Naomi as a GTH town and Naomi was just voting Charlie because of Yorks efforts so I don't see how that flip cleared Naomi
Reloaded may also fallen down because when I asked why Charlie's flip clears Naomi he said it's cause Charlie was tunneling her, I was watching solar opposites at the time so didn't think to much of it, but after Iso both Charlie and Naomi just now I don't see any signs of Tunneling
Seems to me after my investigations those two where trying to cover for her
Am
Stargate
Polar
Uwu
Those 4 aren't necessarily Scum but feels to me they're kinda just skating by, safe to say at least one of those 4 are scum
Yoho
Dr. Watson
MangoSenpai
AlwaysMind
Mr Reloaded
Yo Tan Wa
For the most part it's simply finding others town before these fellas
Yoho and Alwaysmind are in their usual playstyles, Reloaded could go either way
Yo Yan Wa was mostly because of activity but they've been trending up for me
Watson had a bad position on Charlie
Mango I'm just paranoid about, I like his activity but I agree with Yo that some of his pushes haven't been the best which worries me
I'm unsure if we have more indies to deal with here which adds to it
Dr. Watson
MangoSenpai
AlwaysMind
Mr Reloaded
Yo Tan Wa
For the most part it's simply finding others town before these fellas
Yoho and Alwaysmind are in their usual playstyles, Reloaded could go either way
Yo Yan Wa was mostly because of activity but they've been trending up for me
Watson had a bad position on Charlie
Mango I'm just paranoid about, I like his activity but I agree with Yo that some of his pushes haven't been the best which worries me
I'm unsure if we have more indies to deal with here which adds to it
My main issue with Watson was the lack of actual reads and heavy sheeping. For better or for worse, while they're more inactive they're now providing reads and attempting to push people. I don't townread them, but my reasons for scumreading them were them not drawing attention to themself, which seems to not be an issue at this point, and the voting pattern, which both Flower and Alexis were part of, and thus doesn't seem to be as strongly AI.
While his last readlist wasn't great, he had a good point about how you TRd him early on very strongly, too - he's not a townread by any means, but he's no longer top of my POE.
Having done a more detailed backread, however, I think the case on Yoho you presented is significantly tighter, and I am not a fan of how he's posting recently - no counterarguments presented to what you've been posting, just basic denials. If there's a reason I missed about why Dr. Watson is the higher priority kill, though, please tell me.
Vote Yoho
While his last readlist wasn't great, he had a good point about how you TRd him early on very strongly, too - he's not a townread by any means, but he's no longer top of my POE.
Having done a more detailed backread, however, I think the case on Yoho you presented is significantly tighter, and I am not a fan of how he's posting recently - no counterarguments presented to what you've been posting, just basic denials. If there's a reason I missed about why Dr. Watson is the higher priority kill, though, please tell me.
Vote Yoho
Been a bit busy recently, but current POE is:
Yoho - not giving any counterarguments to the accusations, definitely appears paired with Charlie.
Dr. Watson - is sheeping less, but still pretty suspicious.
Pot Goblin/Yo Tan Wa - low evidence here, but Flower defended them a lot, and given the hostile indie claim on Fuji (which may have been true), I could see either of them being scum members in a double bluff. Outside of that both came into thread out of nowhere near EOD2 to vote Flower, possibly as distancing, since the Flower wagon was less universal then the Charlie one.
Michelle - This is way down at the bottom, because scum would almost never claim vig with a scumsided record, but I can see a situation in which she's covering for another scum member with KP.
Yoho - not giving any counterarguments to the accusations, definitely appears paired with Charlie.
Dr. Watson - is sheeping less, but still pretty suspicious.
Pot Goblin/Yo Tan Wa - low evidence here, but Flower defended them a lot, and given the hostile indie claim on Fuji (which may have been true), I could see either of them being scum members in a double bluff. Outside of that both came into thread out of nowhere near EOD2 to vote Flower, possibly as distancing, since the Flower wagon was less universal then the Charlie one.
Michelle - This is way down at the bottom, because scum would almost never claim vig with a scumsided record, but I can see a situation in which she's covering for another scum member with KP.