Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1147 Spoilers Discussion

[MarineHQ]

😂

 

[NAMELESS]

If Holy Knights immortality is derived from Imu's devil fruit, would sea water or sea stone neg it?

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Immortality is Imu's power
Imu has yet to do something major
There is no way they are going to find Imu's weakness so soon
And Weakness is probably Nika or Yami
Like enel weakness was Gomu

So HK are not losing here

Immortality is only a portion of Imus power tbh. If he can hand this much power over to over a dozen people, who knows what he can do for himself.

 

[Shiroyru]

This one for real made me laugh out loud.

“The Holy Knights aren’t a known force, Saul just has access to the Library of Ohara!”

Then why didn’t Jinbe know about them?

 

[AverageNamiEnjoyer]

Immortality is only a portion of Imus power tbh. If he can hand this much power over to over a dozen people, who knows what he can do for himself.

Yeah but Immortality is still connected to Imu
Weakness will be treated as big deal

Imu, Other HK and Gorosei all relies on Immortality
Finding weakness of Immortality and 3 HK losing here will kill their hype too

Not gonna happen before Mary Geoise arc unless Imu gonna lose in Elbaf arc

 

[Fujishiro]

@Fujishiro since all holy knights are immortal do you think this hurts or helps the idea of Gunko being a Nerona?

Net neutral this chapter, still find it interesting that she’s specifically afraid of Nika, has no family name and has special eyes+ seems to just be discovering the outside world as if she never left MJ before.

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Immortality is Imu's power
Imu has yet to do something major
There is no way they are going to find Imu's weakness so soon
And Weakness is probably Nika or Yami
Like enel weakness was Gomu

So HK are not losing here

It’s not like this is the full extent of Imu’s power

the big deal here is immortality… Once that is dealt with, Imu will likely have VERY MANY other powers… Immortality is only a big deal now because the Gorosei and holy knights are regen merchants who fully rely on it

 

[Elder Lee Hung]

Then why didn’t Jinbe know about them?

The amount of lies you bake into a single question lmfao.

Jinbe reacting with surprise at the presence of the Holy Knights on Elbaf is not even close to confirmation that he has never heard of them lmfao. Why would Brook know about the Holy Knights but not Jinbe? Does Brook have access to the library of Ohara as well?

 

[AverageNamiEnjoyer]

It’s not like this is the full extent of Imu’s power

the big deal here is immortality… Once that is dealt with, Imu will likely have VERY MANY other powers… Immortality is only a big deal now because the Gorosei and holy knights are regen merchants who fully rely on it

That's the point
Other HKs and Gorosei have Immortality
So there's no way Immortality weakness will be found in the arc they are not even part of

 

[GalaxyLevelShanks]

Admirals are all weaker than Shamrock and Gunko lol enjoy being stronger than some dragon cosplay clown

 

[NAMELESS]

That's the point
Other HKs and Gorosei have Immortality
So there's no way Immortality weakness will be found in the arc they are not even part of

Sea Water and sea stone neg any df hax. If it's df derived, we already know a weakness.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Net neutral this chapter, still find it interesting that she’s specifically afraid of Nika, has no family name and has special eyes+ seems to not just be discovering the outside world as if she never left MJ before.

Yeah seeing as their all immortal it makes her a bit less special to me but I agree that all this is good reason to believe she may be a nerona.

I do think oda can go a bit sideways with Gunko though. Looking at Sommers call her a woman who’s never been loved, I feel like she may be an outsider even among the CDs I’m not sure if someone related to Imu would be treated like that tho?

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

This one for real made me laugh out loud.

“The Holy Knights aren’t a known force, Saul just has access to the Library of Ohara!”

Holy Knights have been randomly name dropped several times since the end of Wano already, without anything suggesting they're mean to be secret. Back during W7 we were actually told CP9 was mean to be a secret group the moment they got introduced.

To be fair, they likely aren't as well known as the marine since their role is more specific than the "world police" so most citizens will never encounter or hear about a a Holy Knight in their life but I don't see any real reason to assume their existence is actively concealed aside from agenda (aka WG lied about admirals being their strongest fighting force because they don't want anybody to know they actually have a strongest force for some reason).

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Because we’re told it doesn’t. What’s the point wasting the panel time showing something we’re already told?

People really believe Oda wrote Luffy specifically complaining about how no matter what he does he can't hurt the Elders for him to never have tried to hit them with one of his Wano power ups...
I get One Piece writing isn't flawless and characters sometimes do dumb shit but c'mon. This nonsense is just agenda.

Luffy has used every power in his arsenal against the elders. ACoC cannot hurt them.

I have On panel proof that Oda intentionally made Luffy not use his Wano abilities on the gorosei solely for the sake of creating fake Tension

when We see a panel of Luffy complaining that he cannot damage Warcury because he will get burned by the flames on top of warcury

see? I don’t even have to remind you how stupid this is considering what we saw in Wano

Oda CAN BLATANTLY have Luffy OUTRIGHT FORGET that he has fire resistant abilities in the middle of a fire fight and yet you think it’s impossible for Oda to have Luffy not use AdvCoC?

 

[AverageNamiEnjoyer]

Sea Water and sea stone neg any df hax. If it's df derived, we already know a weakness.

Someone said fishmen karate is weakness
Jinbei said Fishmen Karate is control of water
Both Jinbe and Robin knows fishmen karate
Gunko avoided attack called thunder shark

It's possible but would be so boring

 

[Sir Yasheen]

I have On panel proof that Oda intentionally made Luffy not use his Wano abilities on the gorosei solely for the sake of creating fake Tension

when We see a panel of Luffy complaining that he cannot damage Warcury because he will get burned by the flames on top of warcury

see? I don’t even have to remind you how stupid this is considering what we saw in Wano

Oda CAN BLATANTLY have Luffy OUTRIGHT FORGET that he has fire resistant abilities in the middle of a fire fight and yet you think it’s impossible for Oda to have Luffy not use AdvCoC?

What are you talking about he didn’t get burned by Warcury??? He hurt his hand because warcurys skin was too tough.

Also Luffys not fucking flame resistant

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

That's the point
Other HKs and Gorosei have Immortality
So there's no way Immortality weakness will be found in the arc they are not even part of

The holy knights are part of this arc

unless you’re going to say the holy knights run away (which is ridiculous since they can’t fucking die, why would they run)

Elbaf will not lose. The kids will be saved. The strawhat crew isn’t going to be wiped out this arc. So something MUST BE DONE about the holy knights

 

[NAMELESS]

Someone said fishmen karate is weakness
Jinbei said Fishmen Karate is control of water
Both Jinbe and Robin knows fishmen karate
Gunko avoided attack called thunder shark

It's possible but would be so boring

Nah, we already too late into the game to introduce new shenanigans. I'm cool with standard DF weakness. Sea stone is rare enough and we have yet to see a DF user drown to death. Oda is saving that to BB most likely.

 

[AverageNamiEnjoyer]

I think Imu's weakness is Nika like Enel's weakness was Gomu

 

[FlyFlower]

Why does Shamrock walk around in Mary Geoise wearing a cloak?

Is this so he doesn't get mistaken for Shanks, or is this a Lola/Chiffon situation because Garling hates Shanks's face?